Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by PrisonOfGlass:

Originally posted by LeProfessionnel:

Where's the doom squad?


Also, this samsung advertisement that takes up the whole screen is worse than the doom squad. Are you guys THAT hard-up for money?

If by doom squad you mean the folks who aren't afraid to actually look at their team objectively, everybody seems pretty happy with this move so far.

They getting there jimmies rustled

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by cciowa:
already addressed my pleasure in another thread so no need to repeat. a wise much needed move. to help us short term and hopefully long term and also i think the powers to be knew many fans were upset with 0-8 and needed a ray of hope. but that is just speculation on my part. lynch did a good job and now i hope he will be just as good in trading our top pick for multiple picks for the various holes in our team

ShannyLynch were also scared of the 0-16 which was a very real possibility.

Um, it sounds like New England called the Niners. So the "scared of 0-16" is probably not accurate. Although it is very scary, and it's Halloween.

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

If Garoppolo indeed becomes a franchise QB, it would be a huge freaking steal!

what 2nd round pick have we hit in awhile, can't remember. So getting JG is already a steal

Well, Niners traded up from that 2nd round pick the last two years for Garnett (we'll see) and Foster (looks good so far when he's healthy)...so kinda hard to judge.

Those were 1st round picks not 2nd round picks.

.......

Correct.....but how did they get those picks?

I'm not following?

Are you trying to say that trading a second round pick for a first round pick, makes the player a 2nd round pick?

What I am trying to say is when you suck at picking in the second round, trade the pick for proven players or trade back into the first round which is an easier pick for novice gm's.

I think he is saying we could have used that pick to trade back into tyke first round.... which is kind of dumb because u would still be taking a unproven rookie.

Kentwan Baller was a late first round pick. We gave up a second. In my mind if we gave up someone with potential for a QB (most important position) who has been studying under the best in the game (currently, Montana still GOAT) I WILL TAKE IT!!!!

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
So your going to dig your feet in and try to hold on with this DL talk huh

i would be fine if they picked the best o line guy in the world with the first pick, better if they trade the pick

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by cciowa:
already addressed my pleasure in another thread so no need to repeat. a wise much needed move. to help us short term and hopefully long term and also i think the powers to be knew many fans were upset with 0-8 and needed a ray of hope. but that is just speculation on my part. lynch did a good job and now i hope he will be just as good in trading our top pick for multiple picks for the various holes in our team

ShannyLynch were also scared of the 0-16 which was a very real possibility.

i think at the very least, they could feel some heat building and i am sure. while they did it for the long term .. i think they knew they needed to make a splash and give he fans who are not happy something to look forward to

Originally posted by highwayone:
Um, it sounds like New England called the Niners. So the "scared of 0-16" is probably not accurate. Although it is very scary, and it's Halloween.

maybe they did not want the ghost of bill walsh visiting them tonight.. again it was just speculation on my part,. no big deal.. i really never care who called who and whose dick was bigger. i am just happy it went down and the pats got nearly a first round pick,all good.. but that dang o line

Is he going to be introduced today?

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by cciowa:
already addressed my pleasure in another thread so no need to repeat. a wise much needed move. to help us short term and hopefully long term and also i think the powers to be knew many fans were upset with 0-8 and needed a ray of hope. but that is just speculation on my part. lynch did a good job and now i hope he will be just as good in trading our top pick for multiple picks for the various holes in our team

ShannyLynch were also scared of the 0-16 which was a very real possibility.

i think at the very least, they could feel some heat building and i am sure. while they did it for the long term .. i think they knew they needed to make a splash and give he fans who are not happy something to look forward to

I think they realized they needed to fill those seats at Levi, people will come if only to see if JG is any good.

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by glorydayz:
Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

If Garoppolo indeed becomes a franchise QB, it would be a huge freaking steal!

what 2nd round pick have we hit in awhile, can't remember. So getting JG is already a steal

Well, Niners traded up from that 2nd round pick the last two years for Garnett (we'll see) and Foster (looks good so far when he's healthy)...so kinda hard to judge.

Those were 1st round picks not 2nd round picks.

.......

Correct.....but how did they get those picks?

I'm not following?

Are you trying to say that trading a second round pick for a first round pick, makes the player a 2nd round pick?

What I am trying to say is when you suck at picking in the second round, trade the pick for proven players or trade back into the first round which is an easier pick for novice gm's.

?

I think you are reading more into my comment than I intended.

1) I don't think drafting ability magically dissipates between the 32nd and 33rd pick.

2) I'm saying the last few years the 49ers haven't made a 2nd round pick because they traded it to move up a few picks and take a guy they targeted and we don't know yet how that will turn out.

3) The last two 2nd round picks the 49ers actually used were on Jaquiski Tartt and Carlos Hyde...two players who are pretty good and may or may not be a part of the rebuild. Thats only 2 2nd rounder in 4 years.

4) I'm saying that trading that 2nd round pick may preclude them from doing what they've done in the last 2 years and trading back up into round one. Doing that doesn't guarantee anything but that is what became of the last 2 picks. IE there have been no 2nd rounders in the last 2 years to judge.

5) To be 100% clear, I am 100% on board with the trade. I'm simply stating that the pick wasn't worthless.

Originally posted by JoseCortez:

Oh No! We gave up Vance MacDonald, Taylor Mays or LaMichael James

Or for those who wanted to use the pick to trade back into the end of the first round we are not getting:

Ahmed Plummer
Rasaun Woods
Manny Lawson
Kentwan Baller
AJ Jenkins

Damn.... I change my mind...we should not have traded for Jimmy....




Lol jk

Originally posted by glorydayz:
I think they realized they needed to fill those seats at Levi, people will come if only to see if JG is any good.

am sure that was a piece of the pie to

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by sacniner:

Originally posted by cciowa:

already addressed my pleasure in another thread so no need to repeat. a wise much needed move. to help us short term and hopefully long term and also i think the powers to be knew many fans were upset with 0-8 and needed a ray of hope. but that is just speculation on my part. lynch did a good job and now i hope he will be just as good in trading our top pick for multiple picks for the various holes in our team

ShannyLynch were also scared of the 0-16 which was a very real possibility.

i think at the very least, they could feel some heat building and i am sure. while they did it for the long term .. i think they knew they needed to make a splash and give he fans who are not happy something to look forward to

I think they realized they needed to fill those seats at Levi, people will come if only to see if JG is any good.

I was already planning to see niners/cards but with this...I fear prices will rise

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by Marvin49:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by glorydayz:
Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

If Garoppolo indeed becomes a franchise QB, it would be a huge freaking steal!

what 2nd round pick have we hit in awhile, can't remember. So getting JG is already a steal

Well, Niners traded up from that 2nd round pick the last two years for Garnett (we'll see) and Foster (looks good so far when he's healthy)...so kinda hard to judge.

Those were 1st round picks not 2nd round picks.

.......

Correct.....but how did they get those picks?

I'm not following?

Are you trying to say that trading a second round pick for a first round pick, makes the player a 2nd round pick?

What I am trying to say is when you suck at picking in the second round, trade the pick for proven players or trade back into the first round which is an easier pick for novice gm's.

?

I think you are reading more into my comment than I intended.

1) I don't think drafting ability magically dissipates between the 32nd and 33rd pick.
2) I'm saying the last few years the 49ers haven't made a 2nd round pick because they traded it to move up a few picks and take a guy they targeted and we don't know yet how that will turn out.
3) The last two 2nd round picks the 49ers actually used were on Jaquiski Tartt and Carlos Hyde...two players who are pretty good and may or may not be a part of the rebuild. Thats only 2 2nd rounder in 4 years.
4) I'm saying that trading that 2nd round pick play preclude them from doing what they've done in the last 2 years and trading back up into round one.

Oh, OK I get it.

You can ease your mind, as we still have a second round pick (from the Saints).

In the end this is a QB driven league. You have to do any and everything you can to secure a FQ until you do. This may or may not end up being the move that nets that FQ, but as a 49ers fan I appreciate the effort.

Originally posted by Marvin49:

?

I think you are reading more into my comment than I intended.

1) I don't think drafting ability magically dissipates between the 32nd and 33rd pick.

2) I'm saying the last few years the 49ers haven't made a 2nd round pick because they traded it to move up a few picks and take a guy they targeted and we don't know yet how that will turn out.

3) The last two 2nd round picks the 49ers actually used were on Jaquiski Tartt and Carlos Hyde...two players who are pretty good and may or may not be a part of the rebuild. Thats only 2 2nd rounder in 4 years.

4) I'm saying that trading that 2nd round pick may preclude them from doing what they've done in the last 2 years and trading back up into round one. Doing that doesn't guarantee anything but that is what became of the last 2 picks. IE there have been no 2nd rounders in the last 2 years to judge.

5) To be 100% clear, I am 100% on board with the trade. I'm simply stating that the pick wasn't worthless.

We still have a 2nd and two 3rds we can use to trade up into the first if needed. Granted, it will take more because we can expect the Saints 2nd to be more at the back end than front.