There are 259 users in the forums

Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by thl408:
Originally posted by darockzillahitman:
Originally posted by Niners816:
Originally posted by darockzillahitman:
I think we should be awfully concerned about the fact that Belichick was willing to trade him, and for only a 2nd round pick, when he used a 2nd rounder to draft him to begin with.

Belichick does not lose on trades. He knows how to make it so that all his coaches and players would fail anywhere else. He teaches them to fail without him, and they don't realize it. He's the greatest chess player of all time.

He makes it so his players can't succeed outside the Patriots' gimmick offensive and defensive systems, and he makes it so his coaches have no idea how to implement what he does anywhere else. The man is a twisted genius. Last year's Patriots team was the least talented roster in the NFL, and he made them 17-2 and Super Bowl champions.

The NFL runs through Belichick. You have a chance to win when he decides he's going to give you a chance to win. Our only hope is that Belichick just felt bad about letting Jimmy's career go to waste backing up Brady for another 5 years. Otherwise, we're going to see Jed talking about "accountability" and how he wants to "compete to with Shuper Bowlsh" after a couple firings in another 3-4 years.

Since when is an Erhardt-Perkins offense a gimmick? In fact, it's one of the 3 main pro offenses.

That's not even remotely what they're running. You're classifying it as something from over 30 years ago based on a freak'n tree.
How do you know that's not what they are running? Yes it was created over 30 years ago, but it lives on today, just like WCO terminology, and Air Coryell terminology. But E-P is just that, a method to calling plays. Forget how they call the plays for a minute. Think more about what the plays are requiring the players to do. The Patriot's passing offense is very complicated with many route adjustments by the WRs. Nothing about it is a gimmick. I'm assuming your definition of gimmick is, "simple, easily defended, not sustainable". There are many WRs that just can't grasp it and can't function in that offense. Regarding their defense, it's a multiple defense that will run 3-4 and 4-3 in the same game. Not a gimmick.

https://www.si.com/nfl/2016/01/22/tom-brady-patriots-charlie-weis-option-routes
But what truly separates the Patriots' system is the extensive combination of receiver route adjustments, based on the defense or a defender's positioning, that all pass catchers—even running backs—have to know. Most offenses include at least a sprinkling of option routes designed, essentially, to use a defense against itself. But New England's offense is built on them.
When Brady is surrounded by talented players who know the system and can execute it—like the group the Patriots had during the bulk of their 10–0 start, with Gronkowski, Edelman, receiver Danny Amendola and running back Dion Lewismostly healthy—this offense can make sweet, unstoppable music. And when Brady doesn't have that luxury? Whoever those players are, they won't be staying around for long. "There were a couple guys in our past, he wouldn't throw the ball to them," says Weis. "You'd get pissed and say, 'Why didn't you throw to him?' He'd answer, 'I didn't trust him.'

Well the good news is Jimmy G-Spot's been exposed to a complicated system on offense, but it's also nice he's been exposed going against a complex defense.. Even if just mainly in the film room.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by Team49ers:
Greg spoke about how he already liked him coming out of college. His quick release, his quick feet, ability to move in the pocket, great accuracy. Mentioned his great game against the cards last season, his scoring drive in the 4th that put the pats on top. He stated that if Jimmy continued with the Pats that we would have been successful, and how Jimmy G is a great fit for Shannys offense. I almost jizzed in mah pants listening to it.

Before the 2014 draft, Idaho, myself and a few others were all over Garoppolo as a low risk guy to take a shot on in the 2nd round, in spite of Kaepernick still playing well, having been to a SB and two conference championships. The guy jumped off the game film in terms of looking like everything you could possibly want in a West Coast Offense style quarterback. It gave me flashbacks to the style of quarterback that the 49ers used to be all about.

Ultra competitive and confident guy, lightning quick release, fairly good footwork and mechanics for a guy playing in an Air Raid-hybrid offense, decisive with the football and showed the ability to go through his progressions, lead his receivers and outstanding ball placement to maximize yards after catch. I really thought that he would move up to the late 1st, early 2nd before all was said and done because of how complete of a passer he was. The main knocks about him were the level of competition and transitioning from a gimmicky sort of offense and he has addressed both of those concerns during his time in the NFL thus far.

Having him and Shanahan paired up together, if they can protect him it has the potential to be a hell of relationship and lead to some high octane offense out on the football field.

Yep.
Jeff Christiensen's and Bob Spoos comments were a big deal to me as well as far as the small school and gimmick offense concerns. He said Jimmy G was the best QB he ever coached, and they coached Tony Romo and Sean Payton. Said there was no comparison. Jimmy was the best he coached. Period.

Also, i forgot that Daddy Shanny is an EIU alumn....
[ Edited by IdahoNiner on Nov 1, 2017 at 6:24 PM ]
Originally posted by darockzillahitman:
I think we should be awfully concerned about the fact that Belichick was willing to trade him, and for only a 2nd round pick, when he used a 2nd rounder to draft him to begin with. Belichick does not lose on trades. He knows how to make it so that all his coaches and players would fail anywhere else. He teaches them to fail without him, and they don't realize it. He's the greatest chess player of all time.
The counter-point to this is that the Patriots tried hard -- allegedly very hard -- to keep Jimmy a Patriots. Brady claims he's not retiring anytime soon -- maybe even not for another 4-5 years -- and despite this, the Patriots supposedly were willing to lock up Jimmy Garoppolo to a long-term deal. This meant that they were willing to pay big money to two quarterbacks.

Now, these were just reports. There are one of two ways to interpret this:

1. the Patriots were just posturing. It's possible that all along they planned on trading him, and that the notion of keeping him on as Brady's backup long-term (even at a high salary) was just nonsense. If it's common knowledge you're trying to move a player, teams aren't going to offer as much; if opposing teams think a player is an extremely valued part of your team, they're going to sweeten the pot to pry him away. Again... it's possible it could be posturing. Maybe they were just leaking reports that they were infatuated with him in an attempt to build trade value.

2. the Patriots and Belichick truly were extremely high on Garoppolo and believed he was the heir to Brady's throne. There were a lot of reports that they really did offer him some aggressive extensions to get him to stay. Publicly, Belichick has been effusive in his praise of him Garoppolo -- as others have stated, that's uncommon.

Ultimately though... if Garoppolo isn't willing to accept a backup role, he's not going to re-up with the Patriots. The Patriots could've franchised him to keep him around, but that would've got expensive really quickly. I don't think the Patriots trading him is necessarily a sign that they didn't think highly of him.
some good articles about his development etc.

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2013-09-18/sports/ct-spt-0919-haugh-eastern-illinois-football-20130919_1_jimmy-garoppolo-quarterback-urban-meyer

http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2013-09-18/sports/ct-spt-0919-haugh-eastern-illinois-football-20130919_1_jimmy-garoppolo-quarterback-urban-meyer

http://www.espn.com/blog/cleveland/post/_/id/2907/how-jimmy-garoppolos-personal-quarterback-coach-etched-his-name-in-browns-history
  • Jasta
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 1,729
So anyone want to comment why he fell to the low second round in 2014?

I know the draft is always a crapshoot but it wasn't a great year for QBs. Bortles and Manziel are/were terrible, Teddy Bridgewater had potential but blasting caps for knees. Derek Carr is probably the best so far but still not exactly a HoFer. All went before Jimmy G.
Originally posted by Jasta:
So anyone want to comment why he fell to the low second round in 2014?

I know the draft is always a crapshoot but it wasn't a great year for QBs. Bortles and Manziel are/were terrible, Teddy Bridgewater had potential but blasting caps for knees. Derek Carr is probably the best so far but still not exactly a HoFer. All went before Jimmy G.

Smaal school, air raid system
Originally posted by theduke85:
Originally posted by darockzillahitman:
I think we should be awfully concerned about the fact that Belichick was willing to trade him, and for only a 2nd round pick, when he used a 2nd rounder to draft him to begin with.
Belichick does not lose on trades. He knows how to make it so that all his coaches and players would fail anywhere else. He teaches them to fail without him, and they don't realize it. He's the greatest chess player of all time.
The counter-point to this is that the Patriots tried hard -- allegedly very hard -- to keep Jimmy a Patriots. Brady claims he's not retiring anytime soon -- maybe even not for another 4-5 years -- and despite this, the Patriots supposedly were willing to lock up Jimmy Garoppolo to a long-term deal. This meant that they were willing to pay big money to two quarterbacks.

Now, these were just reports. There are one of two ways to interpret this:

1. the Patriots were just posturing. It's possible that all along they planned on trading him, and that the notion of keeping him on as Brady's backup long-term (even at a high salary) was just nonsense. If it's common knowledge you're trying to move a player, teams aren't going to offer as much; if opposing teams think a player is an extremely valued part of your team, they're going to sweeten the pot to pry him away. Again... it's possible it could be posturing. Maybe they were just leaking reports that they were infatuated with him in an attempt to build trade value.

2. the Patriots and Belichick truly were extremely high on Garoppolo and believed he was the heir to Brady's throne. There were a lot of reports that they really did offer him some aggressive extensions to get him to stay. Publicly, Belichick has been effusive in his praise of him Garoppolo -- as others have stated, that's uncommon.

Ultimately though... if Garoppolo isn't willing to accept a backup role, he's not going to re-up with the Patriots. The Patriots could've franchised him to keep him around, but that would've got expensive really quickly. I don't think the Patriots trading him is necessarily a sign that they didn't think highly of him.

The way Lynch was soooo cautious about keeping the talks under wraps in consideration of the Pats, I am convinced there was a disagreement between Belichick and Kraft. To keep Garoppolo, they had to play him, and move on from Brady. One of them wouldn't allow that, so they had a fire sale to get Garoppolo out of the building.

Let the debate begin who wanted Brady until the wheels fall off, and who wanted the young stud. I don't have a clue.
[ Edited by BOI49er on Nov 1, 2017 at 6:59 PM ]
Originally posted by Jasta:
So anyone want to comment why he fell to the low second round in 2014?

I know the draft is always a crapshoot but it wasn't a great year for QBs. Bortles and Manziel are/were terrible, Teddy Bridgewater had potential but blasting caps for knees. Derek Carr is probably the best so far but still not exactly a HoFer. All went before Jimmy G.

He went to EIU, small school, didn't face a lot of tough competition, questions about him being able to handle an NFL offense and playing under center considering he was coming from an offense that was a step above a typical Air Raid scheme.


[ Edited by Phoenix49ers on Nov 1, 2017 at 7:02 PM ]
  • Jcool
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 44,199
Originally posted by Jasta:
So anyone want to comment why he fell to the low second round in 2014?

I know the draft is always a crapshoot but it wasn't a great year for QBs. Bortles and Manziel are/were terrible, Teddy Bridgewater had potential but blasting caps for knees. Derek Carr is probably the best so far but still not exactly a HoFer. All went before Jimmy G.

WEAKNESSES

Is a tad undersized with small hands and short arms. Uses a three-quarters delivery that could lead to batted balls. Works heavily out of the shotgun in a spread offense, and footwork could require adjustment to working from under center. Does not always feel pressure in the pocket. Does not rip the deep out or drive the ball with high RPMs. Undershoots and often hangs the deep ball. Makes receivers work for the ball downfield, and deep accuracy could stand to improve. Makes a lot of simple, one-look reads and was not heavily challenged by consistent pressure or complex looks in the Ohio Valley Conference.

http://www.nfl.com/draft/2014/profiles/jimmy-garoppolo?id=2543801
The play that Garoppolo was injured on against Miami.

Originally posted by Jasta:
So anyone want to comment why he fell to the low second round in 2014?

I know the draft is always a crapshoot but it wasn't a great year for QBs. Bortles and Manziel are/were terrible, Teddy Bridgewater had potential but blasting caps for knees. Derek Carr is probably the best so far but still not exactly a HoFer. All went before Jimmy G.

He didn't fall, he sky rocketed in the off season prior to the draft.

He went from being talked as a late round flyer pick at the end of the season, to being drafted in the second round by the Patriots....
Originally posted by Jasta:
So anyone want to comment why he fell to the low second round in 2014?

I know the draft is always a crapshoot but it wasn't a great year for QBs. Bortles and Manziel are/were terrible, Teddy Bridgewater had potential but blasting caps for knees. Derek Carr is probably the best so far but still not exactly a HoFer. All went before Jimmy G.

Small school, not protypical size and it was a pretty solid draft. Even Baalke found 3 current starters for us (Ward, Hyde and Johnson plus Lynch who has started)
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:


Boy, a playpass off of outside stretch action.....I have a funny feeling we will be seeing this.
Search Share 49ersWebzone