Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NCommand:
They have been pretty quiet for 4 weeks. Same in the Mac Jones thread.

A lot has built up since then.

Let them have this one and get it out of their system.

Hopefully we get back on track with our winning formula next week.

lol since when have I been quiet about Jimmy? I gave him praise the past month or so. I didn't think he played very will vs MINN and he was bad vs Seattle. Nothing this year has changed how I view Jimmy. He's inconsistent and has been for years.

Who gives a s**t about Mac? He gets to play the easiest schedule in football, has one of if not the best defenses in football, and a top 10 rushing team. He's not SF's QB and people need to give over it.

It has NOTHING about 'Letting this have this one" it's talking about the game and what the only problem really is (Jimmy Garoppolo). The QB is the only one.

FTFY

If you don't think he was a big part of the loss then that's all I need to know....

Haha. Oh, you actually think other areas actually had something to do with a loss? Awesome!

Let's hear 'em. Maybe in the game day thread where it's more comprehensive.

I don't understand your point nor your purpose other than to be argumentative. There being other issues with the team has nothing to do with discussion of Jimmy's short comings, nor does it make them any more excusable. Seems this is a bit more personal for you rather than honest discussion about a player.

Originally posted by Sinsation:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
yeah same here. starting to think he doesn't know the plays

He knows the plays. That's not the problem. KS uses the motions and shifts to make it easier to recognize the defense. Jimmy then makes an educated guess on what the coverage is and then decides PRESNAP, where the ball is going. The problem is when he guesses wrong and still makes the bad throw, it results in those head scratching INTs. The run game and PA help hide this BIG deficiency.

Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
What's worse than the bonehead plays are the one's he isn't making. So much is left out on that field. I don't know yet whether Trey can take advantage of those opportunities or not but im not going to pretend those misses, alongside the bad secondary, aren't the biggest factors in why the 9ers are 6-6.

Yes, I have also noticed how many big plays he leaves out there. Again, the only logical explanation for him not seeing it, is because he's not actually looking for it. He has already decided; the defense showed me this, I'm throwing it here.

TThat's how that's how it's supposed to work though isn't it? The quarterback has a progression and if the first read is open or looks like it might be open then that's where the ball goes. It doesn't matter that four other receivers might be wide open. the play goes to where it's designed. Now here's a question. Is it a good play or a bad play if the quarterback breaks progression and throws to a target of opportunity? Well it's probably a good thing, unless the receiver drops it or the throw doesn't work out or a Defender comes in to cover and maybe make a pic. Then what happens when the quarterback gets to the sideline? The quarterback gets chewed out by his control freak coach for taking a chance and messing up when obviously the brilliant play design would have worked out perfectly. If that's the mentality on the sideline I wouldn't expect any quarterback to be taking too many chances even if the receivers are wide open. How are you so sure that's not the case?

Originally posted by adrianlesnar:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NCommand:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by NCommand:
They have been pretty quiet for 4 weeks. Same in the Mac Jones thread.

A lot has built up since then.

Let them have this one and get it out of their system.

Hopefully we get back on track with our winning formula next week.

lol since when have I been quiet about Jimmy? I gave him praise the past month or so. I didn't think he played very will vs MINN and he was bad vs Seattle. Nothing this year has changed how I view Jimmy. He's inconsistent and has been for years.

Who gives a s**t about Mac? He gets to play the easiest schedule in football, has one of if not the best defenses in football, and a top 10 rushing team. He's not SF's QB and people need to give over it.

It has NOTHING about 'Letting this have this one" it's talking about the game and what the only problem really is (Jimmy Garoppolo). The QB is the only one.

FTFY

If you don't think he was a big part of the loss then that's all I need to know....

Haha. Oh, you actually think other areas actually had something to do with a loss? Awesome!

Let's hear 'em. Maybe in the game day thread where it's more comprehensive.

I don't understand your point nor your purpose other than to be argumentative. There being other issues with the team has nothing to do with discussion of Jimmy's short comings, nor does it make them any more excusable. Seems this is a bit more personal for you rather than honest discussion about a player.

Is this NY85's alter account?

Originally posted by CatchMaster80:

Originally posted by Joecool:
Jimmy has been playing well for 4 or so straight games. Every QB runs into a bad game. Even though he had a "bad" game, he brought us back in a position to win. SEA just made a better play and the refs crapped the bed at the worst times for us and at the best times for SEA.

The fact that the previous 4 games were probably the best stretch of his career says a lot. Low bar.

I don't think anyone said this.

I'm sick of watching Garoppolo throwing off his back foot - next year can't get here soon enough.

Originally posted by mayo49:
I'm sick of watching Garoppolo throwing off his back foot - next year can't get here soon enough.

Hopefully Trey has a great private QB coach this off season who continues to work with him on his own mechanics too. I want him to come in ready to go.

Originally posted by mayo49:
I'm sick of watching Garoppolo throwing off his back foot - next year can't get here soon enough.

Just out of curiosity because I've honestly forgotten at this point: when the Niners traded for Jimmy did he supposedly have good mechanics or just the quick release? For some reason I've always thought he was mechanically sound. But maybe that simply wasn't the case and I've been in a world of my own.

Originally posted by JoeBart324:
Just out of curiosity because I've honestly forgotten at this point: when the Niners traded for Jimmy did he supposedly have good mechanics or just the quick release? For some reason I've always thought he was mechanically sound. But maybe that simply wasn't the case and I've been in a world of my own.

He's been about the same. It's actually half beneficial for us as the offensive line is typically in his lap as he's throwing the ball

Originally posted by mayo49:
I'm sick of watching Garoppolo throwing off his back foot - next year can't get here soon enough.

Jimmy doesn't throw off his backfoot. He just doesn't step into his throws. He's all hip torque. It's great for quick, short throws, but a terrible habit for anything intermediate to deep.

Originally posted by Heroism:

Originally posted by mayo49:
I'm sick of watching Garoppolo throwing off his back foot - next year can't get here soon enough.

Jimmy doesn't throw off his backfoot. He just doesn't step into his throws. He's all hip torque. It's great for quick throws but a terrible habit for anything intermediate to deep.

I consider it a flaw - he needs to step into his throws, that's why he doesn't have any zip on his throws. He needs to correct that with his new team next year.

jimmy should have been gone the day after we drafted trey...but no THIS IS WHAT WE HAVE

When Jimmy came in on Fire to end the 17 season I was convinced hook line and sinker. 4 years later and I really can't wait for him to be gone. Im so sick of the indecision and bad ints. Every freaking week im sreaming at the TV "THROW THE FREAKING BALL!!!". 4 years later and he still seems to struggle with Shanahans offense. Im over it. I hope and pray that Trey is the man, because Jimmy is not and we are treading water with him at QB imo.

Originally posted by eric_anthony:

Originally posted by trevorontario:
Kyle needs to limit Jimmy's pass plays to 20 tops, and run the rest of the time to limit his turnovers

Get a new qb then who doesn't turn the ball over too much

Not directed at anyone in particular however it is Kind of hilarious on here..
it's like some of you haven't been watching the 49ers play Seattle for the last 10 years..
lol

Seattles won 17 of the past 20, & I'm gonna go out on a limb here and say that Jimmy didn't play every one of the other 16 games…

Jimmy didn't play well, but we've gotten hammered by Seattle for years with different coaches & players including the QB..

Originally posted by CJ75:
Crazy how turnover prone he is for a game manager

Lol
Crazy some haven't noticed that for years that seattles owned us

Originally posted by wisecraft:
I can't believe how much time he had on some of the pass plays. He was just standing still flat-footed and waiting for a receiver to open up. Why not feel the pocket and move to change the throwing lane. He doesn't have the arm talent. I was actually shocked to see that throw to Kittle in the back of the end zone. I can't remember him ever making a throw that was as impressive. Sucks to have a average to below average throwing QB. I guess it the little throws that count

On that pass to Kittle, he almost missed the window. Kittle was open for a long time and he just about waited too long. Woerner was open for the game winner on the final drove but he threw to Kittle underneath instead. Watching from the stands you can see the open receivers much more than on TV.
He's really a lucky, lucky QB and boy did he miss Deebo Sunday. Least I got some good Chowder in Seattle! Jack's in Pikes Market was pretty bomb!