Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by Brucey72:
The biggest thing I gathered was him saying "last year was strange I wouldn't wish that on anyone "

Should put to rest the nonsense that he would be willing to come back for another year.

When Jimmy said that, almost like a throw-away ... it said a lot. The situation is terrible for him and another year of taking it "I wouldn't wish that on anyone." He never expressed it during the season, either with words or body language. It's as if he's an excellent actor or something, which may be his next job if the Panthers don't make a move.

Still going? Wow.

Originally posted by Brucey72:
The biggest thing I gathered was him saying "last year was strange I wouldn't wish that on anyone "

Should put to rest the nonsense that he would be willing to come back for another year.

That's what I was arguing in here a month or so ago. No one is even considering his thoughts on this. He may not even want to be a part of this team this coming season. We drafted his replacement. I just don't see both sides being able to mend that relationship.

Originally posted by joanieb:

Originally posted by Brucey72:
The biggest thing I gathered was him saying "last year was strange I wouldn't wish that on anyone "

Should put to rest the nonsense that he would be willing to come back for another year.

When Jimmy said that, almost like a throw-away ... it said a lot. The situation is terrible for him and another year of taking it "I wouldn't wish that on anyone." He never expressed it during the season, either with words or body language. It's as if he's an excellent actor or something, which may be his next job if the Panthers don't make a move.

The situation for Jimmy was no worse than it is for any player who knows there is a replacement waiting in the wings. QBs have more attention on them but in the NFL every player knows he has to prove himself every week. Kind of like the hot shot salesman that has a big month but then has to prove he can do it again.

I left my Jimmy voodoo doll In charlotte. Hopefully all that effort pays off.

Originally posted by RidetheHyde:
I left my Jimmy voodoo doll In charlotte. Hopefully all that effort pays off.

Did u take the pin out of his right shoulder?

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Win percentages, do QBs have much of an influence on them or not?

Win percentage is a correlation stat in football,...not a causation one. You can literally be the worst-performing player on the field even as a QB and win football games.

You are big on facts, right? Well,....those are facts. Posting about them over and over will never change that. The only thing that would change it is if we completely changed the rules of the sport.

Needless to say.....the logical connections made here on this board over and over are pretty atrocious...



You really do fail in all 3 areas, and I sincerely hope it's purposeful.

But the most blatant one you are attempting over and over to get away with with this Win % stuff is the "Reverse Causality" fallacy.

This is what you're trying to do:



Cross out QB and insert any other position you want in there,....doesn't matter. It's just a logical failure and always will be.

If what you were trying to pass off was legit,...we'd have several teams or more fighting for his services.

But the other 31 teams clearly understand the logical pit here above that you are trapped in,...hence, the reason why we cant seem to get a 1st for him.

Originally posted by NCommand:
Still going? Wow.

Not sure why everyone here hasn't shut it down and flocked to the injury thread yet.

Originally posted by Rathof44:

Originally posted by RidetheHyde:
I left my Jimmy voodoo doll In charlotte. Hopefully all that effort pays off.

Did u take the pin out of his right shoulder?

Ya I switched it to his uterus

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Win percentages, do QBs have much of an influence on them or not?

Win percentage is a correlation stat in football,...not a causation one. You can literally be the worst-performing player on the field even as a QB and win football games.

You are big on facts, right? Well,....those are facts. Posting about them over and over will never change that. The only thing that would change it is if we completely changed the rules of the sport.

Needless to say.....the logical connections made here on this board over and over are pretty atrocious...



You really do fail in all 3 areas, and I sincerely hope it's purposeful.

But the most blatant one you are attempting over and over to get away with with this Win % stuff is the "Reverse Causality" fallacy.

This is what you're trying to do:



Cross out QB and insert any other position you want in there,....doesn't matter. It's just a logical failure and always will be.

If what you were trying to pass off was legit,...we'd have several teams or more fighting for his services.

But the other 31 teams clearly understand the logical pit here above that you are trapped in,...hence, the reason why we cant seem to get a 1st for him.

Hey Josh Norman made it to the championship last year. All he does is win baby!

Originally posted by random49er:

Originally posted by TheWooLick:
Win percentages, do QBs have much of an influence on them or not?

Win percentage is a correlation stat in football,...not a causation one. You can literally be the worst-performing player on the field even as a QB and win football games.

You are big on facts, right? Well,....those are facts. Posting about them over and over will never change that. The only thing that would change it is if we completely changed the rules of the sport.

Needless to say.....the logical connections made here on this board over and over are pretty atrocious...



You really do fail in all 3 areas, and I sincerely hope it's purposeful.

But the most blatant one you are attempting over and over to get away with with this Win % stuff is the "Reverse Causality" fallacy.

This is what you're trying to do:



Cross out QB and insert any other position you want in there,....doesn't matter. It's just a logical failure and always will be.

If what you were trying to pass off was legit,...we'd have several teams or more fighting for his services.

But the other 31 teams clearly understand the logical pit here above that you are trapped in,...hence, the reason why we cant seem to get a 1st for him.

What's Kyle's record with Jimmy and without? This team started winning literally the very first game, very...first...game... Not the second, not the fourth... Very first game Jimmy started playing.

You'd have a point if the team was winning pre-Jimmy but they weren't The wind always blows. Drinking and smoking has never been healthy. Your examples are truly stupid. Not you, I don't think you're stupid but your examples are just ridiculous.



Jimmy started game 13... The team was 3-24(three and TWENTY FOUR) before Jimmy then Jimmy comes and and we start winning the very first second he's in. 2 NFCC's and a SB appearance later.

Wind has always generated power. Always.

Cigarettes and booze have never been healthy. Ever.

It's called a constant... Wind constant... Smoking being bad... constant...

49ers winning was not, yet losing was. A direct change happened and the constant turned opposite. You do not suddenly get healthier for smoking. Windmills did not just magically create wind(in your case)...but the team got better with Jimmy. This is undeniable.

"Man, I think people got short-term memory loss or something because, before Jimmy came ... he saved us I won two games, four games, and when Jimmy came he really turned it around, brought us to the point where we're at now. I have nothing but love and respect for Jimmy ... being able to see what goes into it, what he goes through day in and day out. I wish nothing but the best for him, and that's my guy."

-Arik Armstead

Hopefully some GM reads that and finally offers some picks for Jimmy.

Originally posted by TheGore49er:
Hopefully some GM reads that and finally offers some picks for Jimmy.

You better hope... .. .

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Hopefully some GM reads that and finally offers some picks for Jimmy.

Only way a GM offers anything is their starter gets hurt and are desperate. More likely cut in couple months.

Nuclear off season.

Garoppolo stays on the roster and Deebo leaves. Brutal.