Does Anyone On This Webzone Believe That Aaron Donald Is The Best Defensive Player Ever!?!

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by dugo:
Not even close.."good" I'd go even say a great player ..."for this era",, teams do have to scheme a bit for him ,but he's not constantly dominate ,,to many other defensive players of his caliber and skillset for him to be the "best ever" . LT changed the game ,,Mean Joe Green instilled fear through out the entire team he would play against , Theres Ray Lewis,,and so on and so on Heck ,i'd even be inclined to say Ronnie Lott in his day commanded the same amount respect Donald brings to the game ..On top of that Lott brought a much better leadership and a commanding field presence to the ENTIRE defense then what Donald brings to his,, yes i am biased to a extent, I'm a niners fan .. but the truth isn't.. It is what it is ..Bottom line is that there are just to many other great players that changed the game , were innovators ,instilled fear ,commanded respect and were constantly dominate..IMHO Donald isn't,...HOF absolutely ,best ever ...nope

HOF maybe if he isn't busted for roids everyone knows that keeps you out. To even compare Donald to Ronnie Freakin Lott oh lord.. He was 100x the player Donald is.

Originally posted by TheGore49er:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by dugo:
Not even close.."good" I'd go even say a great player ..."for this era",, teams do have to scheme a bit for him ,but he's not constantly dominate ,,to many other defensive players of his caliber and skillset for him to be the "best ever" . LT changed the game ,,Mean Joe Green instilled fear through out the entire team he would play against , Theres Ray Lewis,,and so on and so on Heck ,i'd even be inclined to say Ronnie Lott in his day commanded the same amount respect Donald brings to the game ..On top of that Lott brought a much better leadership and a commanding field presence to the ENTIRE defense then what Donald brings to his,, yes i am biased to a extent, I'm a niners fan .. but the truth isn't.. It is what it is ..Bottom line is that there are just to many other great players that changed the game , were innovators ,instilled fear ,commanded respect and were constantly dominate..IMHO Donald isn't,...HOF absolutely ,best ever ...nope

HOF maybe if he isn't busted for roids everyone knows that keeps you out. To even compare Donald to Ronnie Freakin Lott oh lord.. He was 100x the player Donald is.

Lol you new at the nfl? Most players roid. And roids were really big in the 80s as well.

Originally posted by JMC52:
Never understood how hyped Donald is, I don't think he ever took over a niner vs Rams game.

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by JMC52:
Never understood how hyped Donald is, I don't think he ever took over a niner vs Rams game.

Yup exactly this. It's nuts. 49ers board saying they'd take Donroid over Lott or BY it's just shameful. Shut it down create a new site hope for better results

Originally posted by JMC52:
Never understood how hyped Donald is, I don't think he ever took over a niner vs Rams game.

Originally posted by Aj_hwd954:

Originally posted by JMC52:
Never understood how hyped Donald is, I don't think he ever took over a niner vs Rams game.

This. You'd think the "greatest defensive player of all-time" would at least have a couple badass games against the 49ers

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:

Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:

Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Anyone that saw LT, end of the conversation.

500x better than Donald I'd rather have LT for one season than Donald for his career.

Yup. Also, Reggie white and Bruce smith come to mind as well.

Yeah White, Smith, LT, Derrick Thomas, 100 other guys, heck BY was better maybe Donald got more sacks (yay) but BY was a much better run defender and better team player locker room guy. Dude won the Eshmont Award 8 times. You think Donald would have done that? See you in the Hall next to BY, Donald, if they don't bust you on roids first.

Originally posted by ninersrule4:
He's a douche but he's the best D player of this generation