There are 200 users in the forums

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

Shop Find 49ers gear online

49ers Head Coach Kyle Shanahan Thread

  • DrEll
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 7,938
Originally posted by illinois9er:
There's 25+ teams that would be fighting over themselves to hire Kyle if Jed was foolish enough to move on from him. Yet our fans are clamoring to get rid of him lol

The majority of those 25+ teams don't have the pedigree or history we do. I don't give two s**ts that Cleveland's front office would start sucking in Kyle's nuts if he were available because to them a 10 win season is considered successful. We have a history of 5 SB WINS and 3 SB LOSSES, 2 LOSSES by one Kyle Shanahan. So please, using Carolina as a carrot stick to justify Kyle being here is weak. We need winners. Not almosts….
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by illinois9er:
There's 25+ teams that would be fighting over themselves to hire Kyle if Jed was foolish enough to move on from him. Yet our fans are clamoring to get rid of him lol

The majority of those 25+ teams don't have the pedigree or history we do. I don't give two s**ts that Cleveland's front office would start sucking in Kyle's nuts if he were available because to them a 10 win season is considered successful. We have a history of 5 SB WINS and 3 SB LOSSES, 2 LOSSES by one Kyle Shanahan. So please, using Carolina as a carrot stick to justify Kyle being here is weak. We need winners. Not almosts….

Live in the present.
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by illinois9er:
There's 25+ teams that would be fighting over themselves to hire Kyle if Jed was foolish enough to move on from him. Yet our fans are clamoring to get rid of him lol

The majority of those 25+ teams don't have the pedigree or history we do. I don't give two s**ts that Cleveland's front office would start sucking in Kyle's nuts if he were available because to them a 10 win season is considered successful. We have a history of 5 SB WINS and 3 SB LOSSES, 2 LOSSES by one Kyle Shanahan. So please, using Carolina as a carrot stick to justify Kyle being here is weak. We need winners. Not almosts….

I don't give two s**ts that you don't give two s**ts. Your constant nagging and whining is insufferable. I'd recommend a new hobby or just enjoying life in general.
Kyles offenses have been outscored 74-29 in the second half including OT in his 3 Superbowls. He has been outscored 58-12 in the 4th plus OT. His offenses are averaging less than 10 points per 2nd half and 3 points per 4th(no OT). This includes choking a 25 point lead and 2 ten points leads

That's pretty amazingly terrible if you have the ability to actually be honest. This even with some of the most potent offenses and offensive players in the NFL.
[ Edited by MucketyMuck on Apr 7, 2024 at 7:09 AM ]
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Kyles offenses have been outscored 74-29 in the second half including OT in his 3 Superbowls. He has been outscored 58-12 in the 4th plus OT. His offenses are averaging less than 10 points per 2nd half and 3 points per 4th(no OT). This includes choking a 25 point lead and 2 ten points leads

That's pretty amazingly terrible if you have the ability to actually be honest. This even with some of the most potent offenses and offensive players in the NFL.

not sure if we went over this one but it talks about some of the issues in game.

Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Kyles offenses have been outscored 74-29 in the second half including OT in his 3 Superbowls. He has been outscored 58-12 in the 4th plus OT. His offenses are averaging less than 10 points per 2nd half and 3 points per 4th(no OT). This includes choking a 25 point lead and 2 ten points leads

That's pretty amazingly terrible if you have the ability to actually be honest. This even with some of the most potent offenses and offensive players in the NFL.

Kyle fan here. Agree 100
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Kyles offenses have been outscored 74-29 in the second half including OT in his 3 Superbowls. He has been outscored 58-12 in the 4th plus OT. His offenses are averaging less than 10 points per 2nd half and 3 points per 4th(no OT). This includes choking a 25 point lead and 2 ten points leads

That's pretty amazingly terrible if you have the ability to actually be honest. This even with some of the most potent offenses and offensive players in the NFL.

not sure if we went over this one but it talks about some of the issues in game.


This triggers me but its really well done. It's no wonder why Aiyuk is a peeved. Kyle continuously forced it Deebos way and didn't even give BA a chance. Spags ran circles around Shanny.
[ Edited by MucketyMuck on Apr 7, 2024 at 7:55 AM ]
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Originally posted by CatchMaster80:
Okay let's assume that Kyle sucks like some seem to believe. Who you going to replace hm with? I haven't heard any viable suggestions . We can't resurrect Bill Walsh.

I don't see many that think he sucks, and I'll just speak for myself but what I say is that he has some very glaring weaknesses that is the difference between him having 3 rings and him choking away 3 rings.

I think we will be relevant as long as he's coach but I just don't see us getting over the hump with him. Last year for example was the easiest road possible and we still failed despite being the most talented roster in the NFL. I all but guarantee you that it'll be much tougher next year.

I just want to win a damn Superbowl. I don't care who it is at HC or QB. I was a Jimmy guy but he failed. Brock is young and he deserves to run it back but he failed. Shanny is the only constant and we even added the best RB in the entire league and we still failed. Getting so close and failing because of inexcusable mistakes is tiresome. Some may love their 2nd place participation trophies but me? Just getting there don't mean s**t. Better than sucking but that's not saying much. We are no different than the Cowboys.

He's had the team in 2 SBs .Each was close but in the end Mahomes and Reid made the right calls and plays. I don't look at these losses as Kyle's fault. I think they're more because of Reid and Mahomes. When it came to crunch time they came up big and outplayed the Niners.
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
This triggers me but its really well done. It's no wonder why Aiyuk is a peeved. Kyle continuously forced it Deebos way and didn't even give BA a chance. Spags ran circles around Shanny.

Yeah that's a rough watch
Again I ask, what coach would've not banged his head against the goalpost vs Spags? Perfect team couldn't beat him with an inferior talent group to this Chiefs team.

Sometimes the opposition deserves credit. Doesn't mean it's an indictment of the coach, it's a credit to the opposition. Same with Reid dominating Salah at the end of the last SB.
[ Edited by 9ers4eva on Apr 7, 2024 at 10:14 AM ]
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Again I ask, what coach would've not banged his head against the goalpost vs Spags? Perfect team couldn't beat him with an inferior talent group to this Chiefs team.

Sometimes the opposition deserves credit. Doesn't mean it's an indictment of the coach, it's a credit to the opposition. Same with Reid dominating Salah at the end of the last SB.

Nah. Watch the video above and understand how Shanny continuously made the wrong calls and forced the ball to the wrong WR. Aiyuk was our best WR and Shanny didn't even give him a chance. He was fourth in targets for the team in the playoffs behind Jennings. In the Superbowl there were 5 players between both teams that had more targets than Aiyuk. This is the biggest game of the year and between Aiyuk and Kittle had very little impact. Hell Marquez Valdes-Scantling had as many targets as Aiyuk.

Give Spags credit for man handling a so called offensive genius but there's more to the story than just Spags.
[ Edited by MucketyMuck on Apr 7, 2024 at 10:28 AM ]
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Nah. Watch the video above and understand how Shanny continuously made the wrong calls and forced the ball to the wrong WR. Aiyuk was our best WR and Shanny didn't even give him a chance. He was fourth in targets for the team in the playoffs behind Jennings. In the Superbowl there were 5 players between both teams that had more targets than Aiyuk. This is the biggest game of the year and between Aiyuk and Kittle had very little impact. Hell Marquez Valdes-Scantling had as many targets as Aiyuk.

Give Spags credit for man handling a so called offensive genius but there's more to the story than just Spags.

I'd have to see how every play breaks down to know Aiyuk wasn't a target on plays more than that. He was clearly the primary on the 3rd down play that Brock misread. Could there have been more misreads during the playoffs? Only they know.

Kyle could've called a better game this SB. This is the first one where it's legitimate to criticize him for some calls. The other ones weren't on him, especially when Jimmy had multiple open guys all over the place vs KC and LA and missed them. Only thing I wish for was having Brock for those two games. Would've won both as neither team had the talent of this KC D on the backend.
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Again I ask, what coach would've not banged his head against the goalpost vs Spags? Perfect team couldn't beat him with an inferior talent group to this Chiefs team.

Sometimes the opposition deserves credit. Doesn't mean it's an indictment of the coach, it's a credit to the opposition. Same with Reid dominating Salah at the end of the last SB.

Nah. Watch the video above and understand how Shanny continuously made the wrong calls and forced the ball to the wrong WR. Aiyuk was our best WR and Shanny didn't even give him a chance. He was fourth in targets for the team in the playoffs behind Jennings. In the Superbowl there were 5 players between both teams that had more targets than Aiyuk. This is the biggest game of the year and between Aiyuk and Kittle had very little impact. Hell Marquez Valdes-Scantling had as many targets as Aiyuk.

Give Spags credit for man handling a so called offensive genius but there's more to the story than just Spags.

Agree Kyle's ego is too big for him to make adjustments and he thinks he can out smart his competition. Works a lot in the regular season but not when it really matters against Good coaches. I hope he can change but with O line issues we have I highly doubt it. He just is too stubborn to win it all. Maybe his next team.
Originally posted by bassmanr:
Originally posted by MucketyMuck:
Originally posted by 9ers4eva:
Again I ask, what coach would've not banged his head against the goalpost vs Spags? Perfect team couldn't beat him with an inferior talent group to this Chiefs team.

Sometimes the opposition deserves credit. Doesn't mean it's an indictment of the coach, it's a credit to the opposition. Same with Reid dominating Salah at the end of the last SB.

Nah. Watch the video above and understand how Shanny continuously made the wrong calls and forced the ball to the wrong WR. Aiyuk was our best WR and Shanny didn't even give him a chance. He was fourth in targets for the team in the playoffs behind Jennings. In the Superbowl there were 5 players between both teams that had more targets than Aiyuk. This is the biggest game of the year and between Aiyuk and Kittle had very little impact. Hell Marquez Valdes-Scantling had as many targets as Aiyuk.

Give Spags credit for man handling a so called offensive genius but there's more to the story than just Spags.

Agree Kyle's ego is too big for him to make adjustments and he thinks he can out smart his competition. Works a lot in the regular season but not when it really matters against Good coaches. I hope he can change but with O line issues we have I highly doubt it. He just is too stubborn to win it all. Maybe his next team.

Lol so stupid. We win multiple playoff games every year, so it's not just regular season. He makes a lot of adjustments as well. Some of you have no understanding of football at all.
Share 49ersWebzone