There are 359 users in the forums
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
That underthrow to Pearsall was so brutal, he throws that s**t out there that's a walk in TD
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
That underthrow to Pearsall was so brutal, he throws that s**t out there that's a walk in TD
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by father49er:
Purdy's been throwing a lot of rainbows. I wonder about his health.
maybe shut him down and play dobbs see what happens. no reason to get brock wrecked going into next year.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
maybe shut him down and play dobbs see what happens. no reason to get brock wrecked going into next year.
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by taney71:
I generally agree. It is clear that Purdy is better than Jimmy G (not that hard to be) but needs perfect conditions (literally, no rain or snow) and great teammates around him. Purdy getting a 60m contract will greatly limit the 49ers's ability to build a good team around him. Certainly the 49ers can sign a handful of great players but the roster will have major holes. Heck, even now with Purdy on the cheapest contract a team can get the 49ers roster has holes and it shows.
What compounds the 49ers problems is that its roster is aging and most players on the wrong side of 20 or even in their 30s with a TON of miles on their bodies. It is clear from this year that many of the "core" 49ers are either washed (Deebo, Juice, etc.) or could be washed (CMC) or might not be the same after injury (BA). The future doesn't look bright right now
Never thought I'd say this... Jimmy might be better than Purdy.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by taney71:
I generally agree. It is clear that Purdy is better than Jimmy G (not that hard to be) but needs perfect conditions (literally, no rain or snow) and great teammates around him. Purdy getting a 60m contract will greatly limit the 49ers's ability to build a good team around him. Certainly the 49ers can sign a handful of great players but the roster will have major holes. Heck, even now with Purdy on the cheapest contract a team can get the 49ers roster has holes and it shows.
What compounds the 49ers problems is that its roster is aging and most players on the wrong side of 20 or even in their 30s with a TON of miles on their bodies. It is clear from this year that many of the "core" 49ers are either washed (Deebo, Juice, etc.) or could be washed (CMC) or might not be the same after injury (BA). The future doesn't look bright right now
Never thought I'd say this... Jimmy might be better than Purdy.
Absurd statement.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Had two check downs sitting right there on 2nd and 10. Da f**k man
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by Niner4ever:
I really like Brock but it's good to be honest. He saved us from the Lance bust and is better than Garoppolo but I've seen multiple games where he can't put the team over THAT hump and this team needs someone that can.
The team can not and must not give him the bag!
I know it's unpopular but Shanahan needs to swallow some ego and bring in a humbled Rodgers for 1 year.
Is that being honest? Jimmy G was more consistent here and while Lance just seems to be not an NFL player. He hasn't really played much since 2019. I have no idea if he could have put it together if he had started a full season. Rodgers is done. Father time comes for us all.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Originally posted by Jcool:
Originally posted by taney71:
I generally agree. It is clear that Purdy is better than Jimmy G (not that hard to be) but needs perfect conditions (literally, no rain or snow) and great teammates around him. Purdy getting a 60m contract will greatly limit the 49ers's ability to build a good team around him. Certainly the 49ers can sign a handful of great players but the roster will have major holes. Heck, even now with Purdy on the cheapest contract a team can get the 49ers roster has holes and it shows.
What compounds the 49ers problems is that its roster is aging and most players on the wrong side of 20 or even in their 30s with a TON of miles on their bodies. It is clear from this year that many of the "core" 49ers are either washed (Deebo, Juice, etc.) or could be washed (CMC) or might not be the same after injury (BA). The future doesn't look bright right now
Never thought I'd say this... Jimmy might be better than Purdy.
Absurd statement.
reality is they are probably around the same. both a lil bit short vs KC. same outcome. it will be a mid level NFL starter on a QB1 deal. jimmy had the quick release and a lil more zip. brock is a lil more natural (when pressured) and a scrambler.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I have no interest in having a conversation about Jimmy with you. Your opinion on him is nothing close to reality, so miss me with you saying "reality is."
Brock played at an MVP level last year, and was basically doing that the partial year before as well.
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
I have no interest in having a conversation about Jimmy with you. Your opinion on him is nothing close to reality, so miss me with you saying "reality is."
Brock played at an MVP level last year, and was basically doing that the partial year before as well.
i never saw him as mvp. in my mind he wasn't mvp of his own backfield. that was CMC. he played darn good ball. so did Jimmy in 2017, 2019, and 2021. basically, when healthy.
Originally posted by socal1632:
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
That underthrow to Pearsall was so brutal, he throws that s**t out there that's a walk in TD
It's pretty simple boys and girls. An elite qb or one near it has 8-9 wins right now. The current so so Ohio State qb Howard throws as good(as in yikes over 20 yards) a ball, Kyle's massive failure is not prioritizing the qb position beyond system level talent. Brock can't stand on his own, exposed by the loss of Mcaffrey in the backfield.
Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:
Purdy was in the MVP conversation last year, regardless if he wasnt the MVP in your own mind. I am not saying he should have won either, but he was absolutely deserving of being in the conversation.
We havent had a QB in the MVP conversation since a lot of posters on this board were still wetting their diapers. You dont get rid of that because of a down year that had him missing his WR1, WR2, RB1, and HOF LT for some/most/all of the season.
Originally posted by mcwoot:
Originally posted by socal1632:
Originally posted by FredFlintstone:
That underthrow to Pearsall was so brutal, he throws that s**t out there that's a walk in TD
It's pretty simple boys and girls. An elite qb or one near it has 8-9 wins right now. The current so so Ohio State qb Howard throws as good(as in yikes over 20 yards) a ball, Kyle's massive failure is not prioritizing the qb position beyond system level talent. Brock can't stand on his own, exposed by the loss of Mcaffrey in the backfield.
THe problems on this team are a lot bigger than QB. No way are we 8-9 wins.