There are 231 users in the forums

🤔 Rest or Play vs Rams❓- Pregame Thread 2023 Season Wk 18 🐏💥

Shop Find 49ers gear online

🤔 Rest or Play vs Rams❓- Pregame Thread 2023 Season Wk 18 🐏💥

Originally posted by JTB1974:
I don't want my QB going 3 weeks without playing. Niners are already getting a week off after this Sunday. It would be different if the team had nothing to play for but had a playoff game the following week. Then I would rest everyone if that was the case. I think the healthy starters should play the 1st half this Sunday. Then sit them.

That's BS. These guys are pros, just because they don't play 2 games, doesn't mean they won't be practicing for 3 weeks to get ready to play in the playoffs.

You'll quickly regret that decision when even one single starter is hurt and out for the playoffs. This team has proven they struggle when even one key starter is down. We need to sit EVERYONE and practice like hell the next 3 weeks and focus on a 3 game sprint.
Originally posted by thl408:
This game could be like a preseason game 2 type of game. Coaches don't care about winning and call vanilla plays - just get out of there with starters healthy and backups gaining experience. Tough for the paying fans.

Agree with Thl this is probably closest to what will go down. Still, i wonder if kyle / McVay don't have some kind of discussion. Discussion is a lot different than collusion. Just for fun…

McVay: "I'll sit Donald if you sit Bosa."
Kyle: : And I'll sit Deebo if you sit Puka".

This plus all guys with nicks already, eg Brock, AA, CMC, etc. It's is fun to think about but it won't happen.
Originally posted by Patton:
Originally posted by JTB1974:
I don't want my QB going 3 weeks without playing. Niners are already getting a week off after this Sunday. It would be different if the team had nothing to play for but had a playoff game the following week. Then I would rest everyone if that was the case. I think the healthy starters should play the 1st half this Sunday. Then sit them.

That's BS. These guys are pros, just because they don't play 2 games, doesn't mean they won't be practicing for 3 weeks to get ready to play in the playoffs.

You'll quickly regret that decision when even one single starter is hurt and out for the playoffs. This team has proven they struggle when even one key starter is down. We need to sit EVERYONE and practice like hell the next 3 weeks and focus on a 3 game sprint.
It's a risk, but it's football. The players want to play. They work very hard to maintain a competitive mindset each week, and rely heavily on routine and familiarity. It's a tough decision for a coach, but you can't just shut it all down. Sure, maybe you sit a vet like Trent, but if the young guys are healthy, you play them, maybe not a full game. You practice the same, you prepare the same, you play with the same intensity. You don't treat this like anything but another game.

As much as some fans would like to see every key starter rest for 3 weeks, that's not NFL reality. The first round bye is enough for most healthy players. These guys are tough. you keep that edge, and routine. I think Kyle for the most part, treats this like a regular game until into the second half or so.

Also, like Kyle has stated, you can't sit everyone, you still have to field a team. Can't wait for Sunday so we can stop discussing this lol
Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
Originally posted by thl408:
This game could be like a preseason game 2 type of game. Coaches don't care about winning and call vanilla plays - just get out of there with starters healthy and backups gaining experience. Tough for the paying fans.

Agree with Thl this is probably closest to what will go down. Still, i wonder if kyle / McVay don't have some kind of discussion. Discussion is a lot different than collusion. Just for fun…

McVay: "I'll sit Donald if you sit Bosa."
Kyle: : And I'll sit Deebo if you sit Puka".

This plus all guys with nicks already, eg Brock, AA, CMC, etc. It's is fun to think about but it won't happen.

I'm guessing it's more complicated: players have per-game played bonus, Rams may want the 6th-seed, etc.
I say we play Trent and Brock with a lot of 2 TE sets early on for pass protection.
Who is officially in/out? Can we keep an updated list?
Originally posted by JTsBiggestFan:
I say we play Trent and Brock with a lot of 2 TE sets early on for pass protection.

Trent is not playing dude.
Originally posted by BoldRedandGold:
This... Just don't be dumb and play the starters the whole game like I know shanahan wants to...

Yeah, what an idiot headcoach. We haven't seen such a schlamiel----since Bill Walsh.

There's a tough balance between stale, cold but rested players, on the one hand, and primed, acute, but wore down players, on the other. We've seen success and failures over the years with both approaches.

The head coach is privy to Intel about his team we don't have. He got us to this point and merits some respect.

----Or maybe he's just dumb....

Well
Matt Stafford isn't playing

so they must nit care about the six seed
Originally posted by LundyLove:
Well
Matt Stafford isn't playing

so they must nit care about the six seed

Yep basically just another Preseason game.

Do we even start Purdy then?
Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Originally posted by LundyLove:
Well
Matt Stafford isn't playing

so they must nit care about the six seed

Yep basically just another Preseason game.

Do we even start Purdy then?

CMC/Purdy/Trent/Bosa don't suit up. Deeb/kittle/BA/Ward for a series.
Wentz v Darnold would be the Ginger Bowl
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by SlipAndSlideBosa:
Originally posted by LundyLove:
Well
Matt Stafford isn't playing

so they must nit care about the six seed

Yep basically just another Preseason game.

Do we even start Purdy then?

CMC/Purdy/Trent/Bosa don't suit up. Deeb/kittle/BA/Ward for a series.

if purdy dont suit up who plays the backup?
Originally posted by D0PEMAN:
if purdy dont suit up who plays the backup?

Brandon Allen
Originally posted by 49erFaithful6:
Wentz v Darnold would be the Ginger Bowl

Wentz is starting, so looks like an automatic L for the Niners, lol....

How about Aaron Donald?
Share 49ersWebzone