"Entering the season, I gave Beathard a mid-third-round grade," McShay explained. "I loved his leadership and toughness. He was a tough evaluation this season, as his pass-protection fell apart and he lost key WRs to injuries. We ended up giving a fringe fourth/fifth-round grade and ranked him No. 156 overall. While I'm surprised the 49ers traded back into the third round to select Beathard with higher-ranked options like Joshua Dobbs and Nathan Peterman still on the board, I do understand why they'd be intrigued by his 2015 tape."
McShay's colleague, Mel Kiper, ranked Beathard as the 243rd-best player available while Pro Football Focus ranked him as the 10th-best quarterback available.
49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan was asked why he feels like Beathard is a good fit for his offensive system. "Well, one thing that helps is being able to see guys play the way you're going to ask them to play," he answered. "I think that helps with being at Iowa, having watched the system that he's in. it's easier to see. And, to watch him over the years, he's a three-year starter. He's led his team to a bunch of wins, especially in 2015 where they had a better team. I think he played unbelievable.
"They struggled a little bit more this year. I don't think he had as good of players around him. But, he's a leader, he's tough, processes very well, extremely accurate and I think he lives and dies football."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Why the 49ers won't receive draft compensation for losing Robert Saleh
When Robert Saleh first left the San Francisco 49ers, the team was awarded two compensatory draft picks under the NFL's minority coaching development program, which incentivizes teams to develop candidates who are later hired as head coaches or general managers. Saleh... -
Why the 49ers lost the numbers game up front—and what must change in 2026
Four or five. Or maybe six. Another out or held in. There are three things every quarterback needs: time, good pass catchers, and a good running game. That first set of numbers above refers to how many players a team must use to get pressure on the quarterback. If they can... -
Why the Seahawks listed Sam Darnold as questionable for 49ers playoff game
The Seattle Seahawks ruled out just one player for Saturday night's NFC playoff matchup against the San Francisco 49ers—tackle Josh Jones (knee). However, one designation on the injury report drew more attention: quarterback Sam Darnold was listed as questionable due to an... -
49ers' Trent Williams sends a clear message about his NFL future
San Francisco 49ers left tackle Trent Williams will be 38 years old at the start of the 2026 NFL season, a milestone that naturally raises questions about his long-term future. However, the future Hall of Famer has made it clear that retirement is not imminent. Williams...