Witherspoon started the majority of the games opposite Sherman last season but a sprained posterior cruciate ligament (PCL) during Week 15 created an opportunity for Tarvarius Moore, then a rookie, to start the final two games of the year.
Witherspoon, a third-round draft pick in 2017, has appeared in 26 games with 21 starts over during his two NFL seasons and registered 69 tackles, 11 passes defensed, two interceptions, and a forced fumble. He impressed during his rookie campaign but struggled early in 2018.
"He went through some lulls last year and took a step back, but fought his way through it," head coach Kyle Shanahan said on Wednesday. "To finish the year, I think he realized, 'I played one year. I didn't have it all figured out. I realized that my second year.'
"Now he comes in here with a very clear mind. He's confident because he knows he can do it, but he also knows he's got to work at some stuff, too. I've seen a guy who came in with the mindset to be a lot better."
San Francisco concluded its offseason program on-field work on Wednesday and Witherspoon received some rave reviews for his progress. Of course, that comes after watching non-contact work, and the media has been limited in what it has been allowed to observe. While reporters were allowed at both minicamp practices this week, they were limited to one session a week during organized team activities.
Still, that's a pretty good sample size to start making some assumptions.
"Cornerback Ahkello Witherspoon might have been the best player on defense during the offseason program," wrote Matt Maiocco of NBC Sports Bay Area. "He routinely had tight coverage and broke up numerous passes."
Matt Barrows of The Athletic added, "Witherspoon has looked good — he's has had at least one highlight — in every practice that's been open to reporters. What's more, the plays have been of the aggressive variety with Witherspoon playing tight on receivers and hawking the ball on short throws at or just beyond the line of scrimmage."
Moore has been competing at safety this offseason. Maybe Witherspoon's impressive offseason made the decision to move Moore from cornerback to his natural position — the one he played in college — of safety easier.
"Perhaps his play, coupled with Richard Sherman's improved health, encouraged the 49ers to move Tarvarius Moore to safety this spring," wrote Barrows, who doesn't believe Moore would have been able to compete with Witherspoon.
Maiocco sounds more confident about the reasoning behind the move.
"Witherspoon's elevation in play –- along with Jimmie Ward's fractured collarbone – prompted the 49ers to move Tarvarius Moore to free safety," he wrote.
During the team's time off, Witherspoon shouldn't feel satisfied with his short-term victory. More competition will be coming during training camp. The next hurdle for Witherspoon is making sure newcomer Jason Verrett doesn't leap past him on the depth chart.
Verrett has not participated during the team's offseason program because he is rehabbing from a torn Achilles he suffered last summer.
"I feel like I'm going to be on track to be ready for training camp and the rest of the season," Verrett told reporters on Wednesday.
The 49ers consider him to be one of the league's best cornerbacks. The only problem is that injuries have prevented Verrett from proving that to be true. His healthiest season came in 2015 and earned him a Pro Bowl selection.
"When he's on the field, he's one of the best corners in our game," Sherman said of Verrett in May. "When he's healthy, and he's moving, he has great instincts, he has great movement, he has good ball skills. He's just a pest. He's always there. He's always close to the ball. Even when the receiver is making a catch, it's really a tough, contested catch."
The 49ers have received a lot of criticism for bringing in players with injury histories, but general manager John Lynch believes Verrett was worth the risk.
"Jason Verrett is an [Pro Bowl] football player when healthy," Lynch said in May. "He hasn't been healthy, so there's a lot of risk-reward there, but we wanted to add there, and we took a gamble. We think that's a good flyer."
Verrett feels confident about his chances to land a starting role once he's healthy and has a chance to prove himself on the practice field.
"The day I get on that football field, they're definitely going to like what they see," he said.
The starting job opposite Sherman should be one of the more intriguing storylines heading into training camp.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers coach Kyle Shanahan reveals key goal to beat Colts in Week 16
The San Francisco 49ers clinched a playoff berth Sunday after the Pittsburgh Steelers defeated the Detroit Lions. Still, the 49ers have plenty at stake heading into Monday night's Week 16 matchup against the Indianapolis Colts. Entering the game, San Francisco is slotted as... -
Seahawks beat Rams in thriller: What the NFC West shift means for the 49ers
The Seattle Seahawks edged the Los Angeles Rams, 38-37, in a dramatic overtime finish on Thursday night at Lumen Field, seizing control of the NFC West race. The result also represented a best-case scenario for the San Francisco 49ers, who now have a clearer path to the... -
49ers mailbag: What's up with Jordan Elliott's knee? Can SF stop Jonathan Taylor? What's on the 49ers' list for Santa?
The San Francisco 49ers are gearing up for the final push toward the 2025 postseason. How far they will be able to go will depend on their health and how many young players perform. Especially since some are reserves who are playing for injured players. We opened the 49ers... -
Sources say 49ers LB Fred Warner could return for late postseason run
According to sources familiar with the situation, San Francisco 49ers star linebacker Fred Warner has a chance to make it back for the postseason if the team makes it to the NFC Championship Game, or more likely, the Super Bowl. On Saturday, Ian Rapoport and Mike Garafolo,...