In the end, the Niners' decision-makers figured a move from Jimmy Garoppolo to a 42-year-old quarterback at the end of his career, no matter the accomplishments, didn't make long-term sense for the organization.
Lynch joined 95.7 The Game on Thursday and shared that he and Shanahan realized early on that Brady might have an interest in returning to the team he cheered for as a kid.
"Long before anybody called up and said, 'Hey, he'd be interested,'" Lynch said on the Joe, Lo and Dibs show, "we kind of said, 'Hey, OK, this is really weird and odd, number one, that arguably one of the greatest players of all-time becomes free.' And then the fact that there's a connection. Kyle and I looked at each other and just said, 'Hey, is this something we should be looking at?'"
Lynch and Shanahan proceeded to watch film of Brady for about two days to determine if the move was something they should consider pursuing. That included looking at the film of Garoppolo during his time within Shanahan's offense.
"And the cool things is," Lynch continued, "kind of at the same time, we both looked at each other and said, 'You know what? We've got what we believe to be the long-term answer in our building right now.' We felt like it was our duty to take a quick look at Tom, and this was nothing to disparage him, but that's not going to be a long-term answer.
"We figured we did what we think was the responsible thing to do. We took a good look, but the answer is right here in our building. And I think the coolest thing for us is we come out of that more convicted in who Jimmy Garoppolo is, and what he means to this team, than ever before."
Lynch's words mirror what Shanahan said this week during an interview with The Athletic.
"Once we realized and heard this could be realistic, this isn't just talk, we looked into it all," Shanahan said, "especially with the respect we have for Tom and everything, and how great of a player he is. We looked into it to try to see if it would be better for our team this year and in the future. When we weighed it all together, we didn't think it would.
"We felt great with where we were at, and kind of confirmed how we are with Jimmy."
In the end, looking into the possibility of adding Brady reaffirmed the 49ers that they already have their long-term answer.
You can listen to the entire conversation with Lynch below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers stars open up about Eagles matchup: 'We know we have a challenge ahead of us'
There's no denying the task facing the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday will be difficult. Still, the team believes it's prepared—and confident that playing its best football will be enough to overcome the challenge. The 49ers will travel to Philadelphia this weekend to face... -
Vic Fangio: 49ers QBs Brock Purdy, Mac Jones have similar skill sets
The Philadelphia Eagles are preparing to host the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday in an NFC Wild Card playoff matchup. The two franchises have met just twice in the postseason, splitting those meetings with one win apiece. The 49ers enter the playoff game banged up, a familiar... -
These 7 49ers players are inactive vs. Eagles
The San Francisco 49ers have released the list of inactive players for their Wild Card playoff matchup against the Philadelphia Eagles. These seven players will not suit up for the game. Inactives: LB Luke Gifford (quadricep) DL Kevin Givens RB Isaac Guerendo CB Chase... -
Loss of George Kittle latest heartbreaker in 49ers' injury-plagued season
Just how much must San Francisco 49ers fans endure this season? The sight of All-Pro tight end George Kittle making a catch, going down near the sideline, and immediately grabbing his leg was the latest gut punch for the 49ers in what has been a brutal, injury-plagued 2025...