While the 49ers got the player they would have, under different circumstances, drafted with their first selection at No. 13 overall, Walder sees the Vikings as the clear winners in that trade. In fact, he is downright "confused" by the decisions to give up so much in the deal and the choices made with their two first-round selections.
San Francisco used its first selection to draft defensive tackle Javon Kinlaw and did so with two highly-touted receivers, Jerry Jeudy and CeeDee Lamb, still on the board. Walder believes the choice of either would have filled a bigger need for the 49ers. It's not that he doesn't like Kinlaw, just that he sees him as less valuable than either of the wideouts mentioned.
"Perhaps the argument against Jeudy or Lamb was that this was a deep receiving class," writes Walder, "and strong talent could be found later. But that line of thinking went out the window when the 49ers squandered so much value to trade up to get Brandon Aiyuk."
Walder notes that, according to ESPN's NFL Draft Predictor, there was a 59 percent chance that Aiyuk would have still been available at No. 31. Of course, there have been reports that the Miami Dolphins or even the Green Bay Packers may have had their eyes on Aiyuk. As soon as the 49ers leaped over Miami, the Dolphins traded out of the spot, which might support the claim.
"All of this seems like bad process by San Francisco," adds Walder. "But the Vikings deserve credit, too. They were presented with an offer that moved them down six spots and paid them much more than those six spots are worth, and they took the deal."
Head coach Kyle Shanahan explained last week that the 49ers were shocked to see Aiyuk still available after the Vikings selected wide receiver Justin Jefferson at No. 22.
"Aiyuk was one of the guys we were going to [draft at No. 13] if Kinlaw wasn't there," Shanahan said. "And then to still be there, sitting there at 31, and a guy that we would have done it if we had to at 13, is sitting there when [our next selection is] 31, available at 25. We feel very strongly from our intel over the last few months, there's no way Aiyuk is getting to 31."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers Brandon Aiyuk trade: Why moving him now makes sense—and why it doesn't
The 49ers' return window for Brandon Aiyuk closes April 1, offering the Niners one final opportunity to trade him and move on from a contract decision they reportedly never wanted to make. No, it's not April Fools, but it sure feels a lot like Groundhog Day. Just months after... -
Schefter: 49ers not expected to trade Brandon Aiyuk
Tuesday marks an unofficial deadline for any potential trade involving Brandon Aiyuk. The San Francisco 49ers wide receiver is set to receive a $22.85 million bonus on April 1, making a trade unlikely beyond that date. "Once the 49ers pay that bonus, any trade talks for Aiyuk... -
Projection of Early Return of 49ers' Brandon Aiyuk Continues to Gain Traction
The big story of the 2024 pre-season in San Francisco was the long, arduous contract negotiation involving 49ers' star wide receiver Brandon Aiyuk. By the beginning of the regular season, his contract was done, but the drama continued. Aiyuk was viewed by some 49er fans... -
John Lynch: Brandon Aiyuk expected to remain with 49ers in 2025
On Monday, San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch shut down trade speculation surrounding Brandon Aiyuk, stating at the annual league meeting in Florida that the wide receiver is expected to remain with the team this year. Aiyuk suffered ACL and MCL injuries on October...