It's incredible what a difference a play can make.
Two separate quarterback rankings, one by Pro Football Focus and the other by The Athletic, named Garoppolo as a Tier-3 passer. FS1 personality Colin Cowherd feels that is too low, and made his case this week on why the 49ers quarterback is better than most credit him (h/t to Patrick Tulini).
"Jimmy Garoppolo is in Tier 3, along with Ryan Tannehill, Nick Foles, Daniel Jones, Sam Darnold, Baker Mayfield, Kyler Murray," Cowherd said of Mike Sando's list on The Athletic. "Now, come on. Kirk Cousins? Come on."
The host of The Herd went on to share some of Garoppolo's stats from 2019 — his first full season as a starter and coming off an ACL injury. They are below.
| Garoppolo | NFL Rank | |
| Wins | 13 | T-1st |
| Comp Pct | 69.1 | T-4th |
| Pass TD | 27 | T-5th |
| 4th-Qtr Comebacks | 4 | T-1st |
| Game-winning Drives | 4 | T-4th |
| Passer Rtg | 102.0 | 8th |
Cowherd pointed out that some might argue that Garoppolo has Kyle Shanahan, one of the best minds in football, designing plays for him.
"(Drew) Brees has Sean Payton," Cowherd rebutted. "(Tom) Brady had (Bill) Belichick. (Dan) Marino had Don Shula. Jimmy Johnson and Troy Aikman. Dan Fouts was great. He had [Don] Coryell. Joe Montana had Bill Walsh. Find me the single Hall-of-Fame-level quarterback who had lousy coaches."
Cowherd points to other quarterbacks playing today, like Patrick Mahomes having Andy Reid and Russell Wilson having Pete Carroll.
"Why do people not get Jimmy Garoppolo?" Cowherd asked. "My guess is two things."
He notes that the 49ers defense gets the headlines as reason number one. The second is that Garoppolo doesn't have some of the traits that experts see in the more exciting quarterbacks in the league.
"He's not as big and strong as Cam (Newton) or Big Ben," Cowherd said. "He doesn't have Mahomes' arm or Aaron Rodgers' release or the escapability of Lamar Jackson or Russell Wilson or Carson Wentz. There's nothing to grab on to. There's nothing to say, 'Look at that!'"
Cowherd also believes that Garoppolo outplayed Mahomes during the first three quarters of Super Bowl LIV.
"Garoppolo may not be a Tier 1, but he's mid to upper Tier 2," Cowherd added. "And there's no way he's middle of Tier 3."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Why Tuesday is crucial for Dre Greenlaw's long-awaited 49ers return
Linebacker Dre Greenlaw is inching closer to his long-awaited return to the football field after suffering a torn Achilles in February. The San Francisco 49ers have targeted Thursday night's game against the Los Angeles Rams for his potential 2024 season debut. However, that is... -
"We're playing for our playoff lives": Why John Lynch believes 49ers can deliver
Every game has become a must-win for the San Francisco 49ers, who host the Los Angeles Rams on Thursday night at Levi's Stadium. Treating each matchup as a playoff contest, the 49ers understand that another loss could seal their fate—playoff elimination. At 6-7, the team... -
Why Ron Rivera would be wary of paying 49ers QB Brock Purdy top-market money
The San Francisco 49ers are gearing up to face a pivotal decision in a few weeks. That's when they can start negotiating a contract extension for quarterback Brock Purdy. Despite some lackluster performances this season, the organization remains committed to keeping Purdy for... -
Bears D-lineman fined for hit on 49ers QB Brock Purdy
San Francisco 49ers quarterback Brock Purdy briefly left last weekend's game against the Chicago Bears after a brutal hit from defensive end Darrell Taylor in the third quarter. Although Purdy returned after missing just one play and appeared to be fine, the NFL deemed Taylor's...