Kittle was the top-ranked tight end in the NFL Top 100 Players of 2020. He wasn't just the highest-graded tight end last season by Pro Football Focus; he was the analytics site's highest-graded NFL player, period. Who owns the NFL's single-season record for receiving yards by a tight end? That would be Kittle.
None of that mattered to ESPN personality Stephen A. Smith. He diligently argued — unsuccessfully — this week to convince his co-host Max Kellerman and guest-host Booger McFarland that Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs, not Kittle, is the NFL's best tight end.
"He's had about four or five (it's four) consecutive 1,000-plus-yard seasons," Smith said of Kelce. "He's good for at least 85 receptions a season. I think last year he had about 97 for twelve-hundred (yards) and change. Travis Kelce's the real deal as far as I'm concerned."
Smith goes on to note that Kittle deserves a lot of credit for his blocking.
"But outside of that, I don't see anything that he's bringing to the table that Travis Kelce can't bring or hasn't brought over the last several years," Smith continued, "and there's something to say about your resume. I think Travis Kelce is that dude. I think he's the best tight end in football.
"Kittle's right there with him. Please don't get me wrong ... but I also think, if you're San Francisco, you've had to rely upon him a lot more as well because you were bereft of weapons at the wideout spot until, really, Deebo Samuel came on the scene last year."
Kellerman's response?
"You're wrong," he said as McFarland laughed.
Kellerman notes that Kittle averages more catches, yards, and yards per catch than Kelce. Only that last one is accurate over the last two seasons, though. Then you have his ability to make things happen — forcibly, if necessary — once he has the ball in his hands.
"Kittle's specialness, even there, as much as he can catch it is the way he runs it, the way he refuses to go down, which is inspirational to watch," Kellerman explained.
And it is Kittle's skill as a run-blocker that separates the 49ers tight end from Kelce.
"Kelce is a great tight end, but I don't think there's really a debate right now," Kellerman added. "The number one guy in the business is Kittle."
McFarland notes that each tight end is perfect for the system in which he plays, praising Kelce's route-running and Kittle's blocking. In the end, he went with Kittle as his "total package" tight end.
"I think the spot that puts George Kittle over the top is when he gets the ball in his hands," McFarland said while reminding Smith of the play against New Orleans that saw Kittle dragging Saints defenders downfield with him.
Smith didn't want to hear it, arguing that Kelce's lengthier resume makes him the clear top choice. He also didn't waste an opportunity to throw shade on quarterback Jimmy Garoppolo once again.
You can watch the entire heated debate below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Mock draft: 49ers add playmaking tight end to complement George Kittle
The buzz around the San Francisco 49ers potentially using the 11th overall pick on Penn State tight end Tyler Warren has recently cooled. With more pressing needs to address, such as rebuilding the defensive line and upgrading the offensive line, selecting a tight end in the... -
Kyle Shanahan Sees Tight End Luke Farrell As Prime 49ers Roster Asset
There are certainly other higher-profile roster moves taking place in San Francisco these days, but one of the lesser talked about changes may have a bigger impact on the 49ers' offense this year than some might expect. Three weeks ago, the 49ers signed free-agent tight end... -
Despite waning time in San Francisco, George Kittle is everything the 49ers aspire to be
The San Francisco 49ers have spent much of the offseason trimming the fat and cleaning house, focusing on becoming much younger, more athletic, and, most importantly, durable heading into the 2025-26 season. It's been a spring that's seen plenty of aging veterans packing their... -
PFF links South Carolina DT T.J. Sanders to 49ers as best Day 2 draft fit
While most mock drafts focus on predicting first-round selections for teams like the San Francisco 49ers, Pro Football Focus (PFF) analyst Mason Cameron took a different route—identifying the best Day 2 fits for each NFL team. These are players projected to be selected in...