"I think [Prescott] would have success (in Kyle Shanahan's system)," Rice said during the radio interview. "But I don't think he would be like Jimmy G. Overall, I think Jimmy G is the better quarterback than Dak. I'm sorry. I'm just going to call it. That's just my opinion. That's my opinion, and I could be wrong, but I think, right now, with Jimmy G, he's the better quarterback than Dak Prescott."
So that prompted a debate Wednesday morning on Good Morning Football. Which quarterback is better? Garoppolo or Prescott.
While Nate Burleson strongly disagreed with Rice, Peter Schrager and Kyle Brandt weren't so quick to dismiss the Hall of Famer's take.
"Garoppolo took his team to the Super Bowl last year," said Schrager. "And Garoppolo, when he was the quarterback for the Patriots, won games there, and was right on the heels of Brady. [He] was so good that when they traded Garoppolo, it almost felt like maybe that was a questionable decision, now that we're at this point in both their careers.
"I think Garoppolo could make an argument. You know what? In fact, I'll say it. I think Jimmy Garoppolo is the quarterback I'd rather have right now than Dak Prescott. I've seen him go through it. ... You go into New Orleans last year, Week 14; Saints are everyone's favorite to win the Super Bowl. Jimmy Garoppolo takes the 49ers, who everyone thought was just a flash in the pan, and a couple of big wins early, are going to fall apart late, and beat [the Saints] in New Orleans.
"Then you go into Seattle, Week 17, everything on the line, Garoppolo leads his team downfield and wins in Seattle, in front of the 12 — something the 49ers could never do. And they go on and play in the Super Bowl after dominating in two playoff games. So, I don't understand why this is such a hot take."
As Burleson shook his head in a bit of disbelief, Brandt backed up Schrager. He did, however, feel Rice could have been more confident in his take rather than saying, "That's my opinion, and I could be wrong."
"Dak Prescott was bupkis last year in the games that mattered, the really big games," said Brandt. "Jimmy Garoppolo? I understand he missed the one notable throw to Emmanuel Sanders, but he also was good in the other big games. He did his job, so it's not a wild take.
"If you were to ask a GM right now, or head coach, 'You have one big game to win. Do you want Garoppolo, or do you want Dak Prescott?' I think they'd say, 'Jimmy.' He's done it more recently."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers mailbag: What do the 49ers have left in the tank for the last four games? Will SF bring back Robert Saleh? Can Brock Purdy beat good teams?
It's always a big week when the San Francisco 49ers play the Los Angeles Rams. In 2021, the rivalry became even bigger when the 49ers had to win in the season's final week, in Los Angeles, to make it into the playoffs. On Thursday night, the 49ers must win again to keep their... -
No Nick Bosa or Trent Williams at final 49ers practice before Bears game
Defensive end Nick Bosa and left tackle Trent Williams were absent during the early portion of Friday's practice, the segment open to the media. Neither player has participated in practice this week, raising significant doubts about their availability for Sunday's matchup... -
49ers vs. Rams injury updates: Ji'Ayir Brown questionable to return
The San Francisco 49ers entered Thursday night's NFC West showdown against the Los Angeles Rams without key players, most notably left tackle Trent Williams, who is sidelined for the fourth straight game with an ankle injury. On defense, standout rookie safety Malik Mustapha... -
Report: 49ers likely to suspend De'Vondre Campbell for quitting on the team
According to NFL insider Ian Rapoport, the San Francisco 49ers are expected to suspend linebacker De'Vondre Campbell following his actions during Thursday night's loss to the Los Angeles Rams. This likely marks the end of Campbell's tenure with the team. Campbell, who signed...