It's that last part that drew ire from fans. It wasn't just because of Cousins ending up in San Francisco, a rumored scenario that seems to pop up every offseason, but what the 49ers give up in the trade. King has the Niners surrendering not just Garoppolo in the deal but also the No. 12 overall pick. That sounds like too much for what doesn't, on the surface, seem like an upgrade.
"Does Kyle Shanahan still love Kirk Cousins? I don't know," King said on 95.7 The Game last week while defending himself. "I still think he respects him a lot, and deep down inside, sees one day that it might be fun to actually be able to have this guy as his quarterback because he loved him so much when he was in Washington."
King defended himself again in his latest Football Morning in America column. This time, the writer pointed to each quarterback's injury history as the reason why Cousins could be viewed as an upgrade over Garoppolo.
"I think I fully understand the many Niners fans who thought my suggestion of Kirk Cousins for Jimmy Garoppolo and a first-round pick was a crazy overpayment to Minnesota," wrote King. "When they're both on the field, there's not that big a difference. I'd rather have Cousins, but it's a close call. But there's the 'when they're both on the field' part.
"Cousins has missed one of his last 96 games due to injury. Garoppolo has missed 23 of his last 48 games due to injury. The question is: Is it worth a first-round pick to have the insurance of having a B quarterback on the field every week—or would you rather take the risk that Garoppolo, a B quarterback at best if his history is the judge, plays for 16 games? And if not, that you have a decent chance of winning with a (Nick) Mullens or a (C.J.) Beathard or some other veteran backup?
"I'm not saying Cousins is the missing piece on a Super Bowl champ. I am saying, I might rather have the insurance of the 13th-best quarterback (or whatever you'd rate Cousins), knowing he's likely to be on the field every week."
Last week, Football Outsiders wrote something similar in an ESPN feature, calling Cousins a "healthier version" of Garoppolo. They, too, pointed to the 49ers quarterback's 23 missed games over the past three seasons.
"They're not identical players -- Garoppolo hits more explosive plays but also gives up more sacks and interceptions -- but Cousins has basically been a healthier version of Garoppolo," wrote Football Outsiders. "And that health could mean the difference between San Francisco challenging for Super Bowls or missing the playoffs entirely."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
John Lynch defends 49ers' offseason approach: 'We still have a lot of Hall of Fame-worthy players'
The San Francisco 49ers have taken an aggressive approach in past offseasons, determined to push their Super Bowl window as far as possible. After coming painfully close to securing a championship last year, that urgency remained heading into the 2024 season. However, after a... -
Peter Schrager doubts Brock Purdy will earn over $55M annually from 49ers
The San Francisco 49ers would undoubtedly prefer to resolve their quarterback situation sooner rather than later. The team is negotiating with Brock Purdy on a contract extension, sparking significant debate about his standing among the NFL's top quarterbacks and market... -
Former 49ers foe joining 3rd team in 3 years
Russell Wilson's time with the Pittsburgh Steelers lasted just one season. The veteran quarterback, a longtime nemesis of the San Francisco 49ers, is reportedly signing a one-year, $10.5 million deal with the New York Giants, which could rise to $21 million with... -
CFL team eyeing former 49ers first-round pick
Quarterback Trey Lance spent two seasons with the Dallas Cowboys after being traded by the San Francisco 49ers, who selected him third overall in the 2021 NFL Draft. The move to acquire Lance remains one of the most costly mistakes of the John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan era, as...