If the decision were up to Jeremiah, he would pick Lance before Jones. He would even pick Fields instead of the former Crimson Tide quarterback.
"Kind of going through the whole process of both those guys, that would be my choice, between those two, because I do think they expand the playbook," Jeremiah told Rich Eisen on The Rich Eisen Show. "And to kind of use a phrase you hear more and more in the NFL right now, you get to play 11-on-11. When you've got your quarterback that can move around and run a little bit, you're no longer playing 10-on-11 anymore. That's somebody that the other side has to worry about."
But the decision isn't up to Jeremiah. It's up to Shanahan, and the analyst certainly understands the 49ers coach's thinking. While he thought the idea of adding a playmaker like Fields or Lance might be appealing to Shanahan, he understands why the coach might favor Jones.
"Trying to do my homework on this pick in the last couple of days, I talked to somebody who had interviewed Kyle for a head-coaching job before he got the Niners job, and he said, 'When we talked about quarterbacks, he said it begins and ends with accuracy,'" Jeremiah said. "Like, that is the most important thing, is how accurate you are with the football. And that's a huge strength of Mac Jones."
Jones completed an impressive 77.4 percent of his passes last season against some good competition. Fields completed 70.2 percent of his passes. In 2019, during his last full season, Lance completed 66.9 percent of his passes.
"So, [Jones doesn't have] the arm strength, not the great athlete," Jeremiah continued. "Obviously, you hear about how smart he is, how quick he processes, all those things. But if accuracy is the be-all, end-all, the guy completes 77 percent of his passes. He's the most accurate guy right now. So, that's why, in my opinion, that's why Kyle is where he is on this evaluation."
Jeremiah added: "I just personally believe that both Trey and Justin, while they might not be at Mac Jones' standard of accuracy right now, I think they can get there. I think they can get there. I know Mac Jones is never going to acquire the athleticism that those two kids have."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Vic Fangio: 49ers QBs Brock Purdy, Mac Jones have similar skill sets
The Philadelphia Eagles are preparing to host the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday in an NFC Wild Card playoff matchup. The two franchises have met just twice in the postseason, splitting those meetings with one win apiece. The 49ers enter the playoff game banged up, a familiar... -
49ers praise Mac Jones for keeping playoff hopes alive during Purdy's absence
The San Francisco 49ers understand they might not be in their current position without quarterback Mac Jones' contributions this season. When starter Brock Purdy missed time with a turf toe injury, Jones stepped in for eight games and delivered steady production, throwing for... -
Bucky Brooks: Why the Eagles are the 49ers' best playoff matchup
While many view the Philadelphia Eagles as one of the toughest possible playoff matchups for the San Francisco 49ers, NFL analyst Bucky Brooks sees it differently. In fact, Brooks believes the Eagles may be the best matchup the 49ers could have drawn and explained why during a... -
49ers find Spencer Burford replacement in 2026 NFL mock draft
Mike Renner released his latest 2026 NFL mock draft for CBS Sports, and he has the San Francisco 49ers addressing the interior of the offensive line in the first round. Specifically, Renner projects head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch to target a long-term...