"So, for us, if you invest $25 (million) or $50 million into your rookie to get them ready, then to me, we're investing in the long-term future of our team," York told Matt Maiocco. "And you never want to put somebody out there, especially a guy who you heard the sort of parlance about Trey, [that] he hasn't played as much.
Those $25 million and $50 million figures come from Garoppolo's salary over the next year or two. York knows what Lance could mean for the team's long-term success. However, the 49ers roster is built to win now, and that's not something the team should necessarily throw on the shoulders of a rookie.
On Thursday, York suggesting that the 49ers are fine sitting Lance for a year or two sparked discussion during an early segment on ESPN's NFL Live. Both Keyshawn Johnson and Dianna Russini felt the strategy was sound. Analyst Todd McShay, however, had a different opinion.
"Listen, I don't care about the message. I care about reality," McShay told Johnson, Russini, and host Laura Rutledge. "Yes, I understand, Trey Lance, 17 starts, FCS, only one game this past season. But when you study the tape, he processes as fast as Mac Jones from Alabama or any other quarterback in this entire class.
"And again, being real, the last 13 years, there's been 39 quarterbacks drafted in the first round. Only three of them did not start a game. So, history tells us it's a long shot that Lance is not going to start. I get it. Garoppolo is there. He can be a good starter when he's healthy, but he hasn't stayed healthy."
Including the playoffs, Garoppolo owns a 24-9 record as the 49ers' starting quarterback. He led the team to a Super Bowl during the 2019 season. However, he has also missed 23 games due to injuries over the past three seasons.
Head coach Kyle Shanahan and general manager John Lynch have been very transparent in sharing that Garoppolo's inability to stay on the field was the driving force behind the decision to trade up to draft a quarterback.
"First of all, I think they're going to try to work him in, regardless," McShay continued. "Second of all, there's a real good chance Jimmy G gets injured. Third of all, you don't trade all the way up, and even if it was for Mac Jones, and adjust your mindset because Trey Lance blew you away, and then not play him this upcoming season.
"I think Trey Lance is going to start more games than any other quarterback for San Fran."
H/t to Alex Didion of NBC Sports for the find.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Why John Lynch believes a longer offseason will benefit the 49ers
For the first time since 2020, the San Francisco 49ers will begin their offseason earlier than usual, missing the playoffs after three consecutive deep postseason runs. With one game left in an injury-plagued and mistake-riddled campaign, the 49ers are shifting their focus to... -
George Kittle, Ricky Pearsall have big games; Key stats from 49ers-Lions
The San Francisco 49ers dropped to 6-10 on the season after a 40-34 Week 17 loss to the Detroit Lions at Levi's Stadium in Santa Clara, California. Below are several statistics and notes from Monday's game, which were provided by the 49ers Communications staff. 49ers... -
Five things the 49ers should do in the final two games
The 2024 season has been a disappointment for the San Francisco 49ers. Actually, that's too nice. It's been a disaster. From contract disputes to players losing babies, a slew of injuries, and even a player being shot, 2024 has been a season the 49ers and their fans would like... -
Nick Bosa on early offseason start for 49ers: "We kind of needed it as a team"
San Francisco 49ers head coach Kyle Shanahan acknowledged that while he'd prefer to be preparing for the playoffs, starting the offseason work earlier could prove valuable. With the team's streak of deep playoff runs at an end, the 49ers enter their season finale at 6-10,...