There's no real bad answer with those choices. Kelce has played much longer, and his resume is superb. The six-time Pro Bowler has been doing it for eight years and has racked up over 1,000 receiving yards in each of the past five seasons, including a tight-end record of 1,416 receiving yards last season. That record broke the one set by the 27-year-old Kittle just two years earlier.
Kittle has two seasons with over 1,000 receiving yards on his resume. He was limited to eight games last season but still recorded 634 yards. Kittle is seen as the better overall tight end, as he is just as good of a blocker as he is a receiver, but he obviously doesn't yet have the illustrious resume that Kelce has.
Again, while there is no wrong answer, Pro Football Focus went ahead and ranked the NFL tight ends anyway. In the top spot is Kelce, but the analytics site acknowledges that it could have gone either way.
"It's a 1a/1b situation at the top of the position with Kelce and Kittle," wrote Ben Linsey. "Kelce earns the top spot heading into the 2021 season off the back of another dominant showing this past season, paired with an injury-limited campaign for Kittle. ... [Kelce's] knack for getting open paired with that after-the-catch ability makes him the most dangerous receiving threat at the tight end position the league has to offer right now."
Clearly, Kittle's limited playing time last season impacted his ranking. You have to wonder if he would have been the undisputed top tight end had he lasted 16 games.
"Kittle still imposed his will as both a receiver and blocker when on the field in 2020," wrote Linsey. "The issue was that he was only on the field for eight games, missing significant time with a broken bone in his foot.
"Since 2018, Kittle is the highest-graded tight end in the NFL (93.4) on the back of the highest receiving grade at the position (93.7) and third-highest run-blocking grade (78.0). Unlike Kelce, the majority of his damage comes inline, where Kyle Shanahan does as good of a job as any coach in the NFL at creating mismatches in coverage. Kittle's 1,811 receiving yards when lined up inline since 2018 are over 500 more than any other tight end."
What's interesting about the ranking is that rookie Kyle Pitts of the Atlanta Falcons is listed at No. 4.
"This may be early for a player who has yet to take an NFL snap, but it's a reflection of the caliber of prospect Pitts is coming out of Florida. He's just different," Linsey explained.
Click here to view Linsey's entire ranking over at Pro Football Focus.
Related News
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' George Kittle Among Finalists for 14th Annual NFL Salute to Service Award
NFL Communications provided the following information. The NFL and USAA, an official NFL Salute to Service partner, announced Minnesota Vikings running back Aaron Jones, San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle and Los Angeles Chargers defensive end Morgan Fox as finalists... -
PFF head coach carousel 'best fits' offers potential good news for 49ers
Pro Football Focus contributor Dalton Wasserman recently analyzed the current head coaching vacancies around the NFL, identifying the best candidates for each job. While former New York Jets head coach Robert Saleh is reportedly interviewing for roles with teams like the... -
49ers' Fred Warner named first-team All-Pro; George Kittle, Kyle Juszczyk selected as alternates
Linebacker Fred Warner is the only San Francisco 49ers player selected for the prestigious Associated Press 2024 All-Pro Team, one of the NFL's most coveted honors. Warner earned a first-team All-Pro selection, while tight end George Kittle and fullback Kyle Juszczyk received... -
PFF suggests 49ers sign this linebacker in free agency
NFL free agency is still two months away, but for Pro Football Focus, it's never too early to make predictions. Contributor Bradley Locker highlighted one free agent for each NFL team to target this offseason, and for the San Francisco 49ers, he suggested bolstering their...