Yes, San Francisco earned just six wins last season. However, as almost anyone will tell you while defending the team, the roster endured a historic number of injuries in a bizarre 2020. In fact, the 49ers were the second most injured team over the past two decades. Only the 2016 Chicago Bears had players miss more games in a single season.
The 49ers are tied for the sixth-best odds to win Super Bowl LVI, per MyBookie. They are tied for the fifth-best odds, per DraftKings. Sullivan feels head coach Kyle Shanahan's team could easily win a championship ... if everything goes right. That is rare, which appears to be one reason why Sullivan lists San Francisco among his overrated teams.
There are other reasons, of course.
"While there is plenty of talent to like on this roster, there are some rather large questions," wrote Sullivan. "First, what's the deal at quarterback? San Francisco made waves this offseason by trading up to the No. 3 overall pick to eventually select North Dakota State quarterback Trey Lance, signaling that he is the future under center for the franchise. Despite making that monumental move, the team still hung on to former franchise QB Jimmy Garoppolo."
Right now, the plan is to have Garoppolo start Week 1 of the regular season, allowing Lance as much time as he needs to absorb Shanahan's playbook and acclimate to the speed of the pro level. Lance started just 17 games in college and played in just one since January of 2020.
With Garoppolo on the roster, there is no need to rush Lance onto the football field. At least, that is the thinking among the coaching staff. The problem is that Garoppolo has missed 23 games over the past three seasons due to injuries and has made it out of September injury-free as a starter just once.
"While the ideal situation for San Francisco may be for Garoppolo to play and play well in 2021 and then hand off the starting job to Lance in 2022 after a year of seasoning, that may be too tall of an ask," Sullivan continued. "When healthy, Garoppolo has shown that he can lead a team to the Super Bowl. The problem, however, is that he's never healthy. He's only played one full season in the league to this point (which just so happened to be the year San Francisco advanced to Super Bowl LIV). With that in mind, Garoppolo's durability is hardly something you can take to the bank. If he does go down, the Niners may throw Lance into the deep end a bit earlier than they may want."
Shanahan hasn't ruled out the possibility of starting a rookie quarterback. However, the coach has also stated that it would be difficult for Lance — or any inexperienced passer — to beat out Garoppolo.
"I thought Jimmy's had as good of an OTAs as he's had since he's been here," Shanahan said last month, per Kirk Larrabee. "He's very on point from a mental and physical standpoint. I know Trey's really going to have to be on it to come in and seriously push him."
A healthy Garoppolo might be able to guide San Francisco back to the big game. However, Sullivan feels that would be a tall order for Lance.
"Finally, it's also worth pointing out that San Francisco lost defensive coordinator Robert Saleh this offseason," Sullivan adds, "and no longer has veteran corner Richard Sherman, who was playing at an All-Pro level during that Super Bowl run a few years ago."
The three other teams on Sullivan's list were the Denver Broncos, New England Patriots, and Los Angeles Rams.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
CBS Sports' bold draft prediction: 49ers trade for Jalen Ramsey
CBS Sports' John Breech made several bold predictions ahead of the first night of the 2025 NFL Draft, and one of them involves a surprising move by the San Francisco 49ers—not to trade up or down the draft board, but to acquire veteran help at cornerback. With 11 total... -
Schefter: 49ers among teams interested in trading down in draft
According to ESPN's Adam Schefter, the San Francisco 49ers are among the teams considering a trade down in the first round of the 2025 NFL Draft, which kicks off Thursday. Holding the No. 11 overall pick, the team has several directions it could go with its top selection. The... -
49ers GM John Lynch speaks ahead of 2025 NFL Draft
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch spoke with reporters as the team prepares for the 2025 NFL Draft. Here is everything he said. Transcript provided by the San Francisco 49ers Communications staff. Opening comments: "Alright, first thing, hopefully everybody had... -
49ers roundup: One common theme among 5 mock drafts
The San Francisco 49ers could go in several directions with their first-round pick due to a roster hit hard by offseason departures. Analysts and experts continue to speculate on what general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan will do with their first of 11...