Instead of saying goodbye to Santa Clara, the San Francisco 49ers, and his teammates, his career took an unexpected U-turn. He opted to remain with the Niners, his home over the last four-and-a-half seasons. For the 49ers, they lucked out. The worst-case scenario happened on Sunday. Trey Lance suffered a broken ankle and will undergo season-ending surgery today.
Keeping Garoppolo on the roster suddenly doesn't seem as foolish as some wanted everyone to believe. San Francisco remains a championship contender, even after losing its starting quarterback. Not every team can overcome such a loss.
"I mean, honestly, at one point, I didn't think I was going to be a Niner," Garoppolo told Sports Illustrated's Albert Breer. "I was pretty set on going to a couple different teams I had in mind. And then all of a sudden things switched [at the] last second."
Garoppolo had been throwing at the 49ers' facilities since late June, trying to regain the strength in his surgically repaired shoulder. When training camp arrived, he didn't feel like part of the organization anymore. Everyone was just waiting for a trade opportunity to present itself. That never came.
In the middle of training camp, head coach Kyle Shanahan spoke with Garoppolo about the possibility of remaining with the 49ers, not as a starter but as Lance's backup. That would, of course, mean a salary cut. It was an idea that Garoppolo admits was never on his radar. When no trade market developed and the regular season quickly approached, the quarterback decided the best option was to stay put.
"There was a lot of familiarity with the organization, the offense, teammates, all that stuff played a role," Garoppolo said. "It was just a good opportunity. I know we got a good team here, and I know everyone keeps saying this, but we've got a chance at a Super Bowl, and that's what I'm trying to do."
Now, Garoppolo is a starting quarterback again, and he didn't have to switch teams to get to this point. Obviously, he doesn't like how it happened. He likes Lance and didn't want to see the 22-year-old quarterback's season end as it did. The two have grown close.
"It's tough, man," Garoppolo said. "Injuries, it's never fun, and especially for a young guy like that, I've been in his shoes, and it's going to be tough initially. But it's how you come out after. I'm a big believer in that. Trey's a tough dude, he's got a good mindset, and I'm hoping [for] the best for him."
Still, Garoppolo can't help but be excited about the opportunity. While he doesn't know what his future holds beyond this season, he knows his 49ers are capable of something special. San Francisco fell short during the 2019 season. Maybe this season will be different.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' glaring need still apparent in early 2026 mock draft
The San Francisco 49ers did not select an offensive tackle during the 2025 NFL Draft—a position many considered one of the team's most significant needs, given Trent Williams' age and the fact that the future Hall of Fame left tackle missed the final seven games of the... -
49ers tried to trade up for Mykel Williams, still landed him at No. 11
The San Francisco 49ers had their sights set on Georgia defensive end Mykel Williams before the start of the 2025 NFL Draft. Believing he wouldn't last until their pick at No. 11, the team explored trade-up scenarios in an effort to secure him earlier. But to their... -
Baldy breaks down potential impact of key 49ers draft picks
NFL analyst Brian Baldinger recently shared his breakdown of key San Francisco 49ers draft picks, highlighting the team's effort to rebuild its depleted defensive line with several early selections. Baldinger provided detailed insights on four players from the 49ers' 11-man... -
John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan discuss the 49ers drafting Mykel Williams; Williams speaks to reporters
San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch and head coach Kyle Shanahan spoke to reporters after selecting Georgia defensive end Mykel Williams with the 11th overall pick. Additionally, Williams spoke to reporters via Zoom. Here is everything they said. Transcripts...