Andy Reid of the Kansas City Chiefs took the top spot, followed by Bill Belichick of the New England Patriots, Sean McVay of the Los Angeles Rams, and John Harbaugh of the Baltimore Ravens.
Shanahan at No. 5 is two spots higher than Daugherty had him a year ago. It's also worth noting that Shanahan is the only name among the top six that has yet to win a Super Bowl as a head coach.
"After failing to eclipse six wins in three of his first four seasons, Kyle Shanahan has now made the NFC Championship Game in three of the past four," Daugherty wrote. "This, even as his quarterback plans keep finding new and exciting ways to go up in smoke. For a while, it seemed like Shanahan might owe a surprising amount of his success to Jimmy Garoppolo. Beleaguered though he's long been, a healthy 'Jimmy G' was the common denominator between Shanahan's first two conference title tilts.
"Then Garoppolo broke his [foot] and gave way to the literal final pick of the draft. Had Brock Purdy's ulnar collateral ligament not evaporated into thin air on live television during this year's conference championship game against the Eagles, Shanahan might have again been Super Bowl bound. Instead, we are left to wonder who will be under center Week 1. Whoever it is will be calling the shots for one of the league's most carefully constructed rosters, one where Shanahan has as much influence as any head coach."
With a career record of 52-46, Shanahan's .531 winning percentage is tied with Jacksonville Jaguars head coach Doug Pederson as the lowest among Daugherty's top 11 coaches.
Daugherty doesn't view Shanahan's system as perfect, criticizing one aspect that has become a staple of the pre-snap action. Still, the admiration for the 49ers' play caller is apparent.
"Shanahan's vision can sometimes be irritating — no one needs to motion Kyle Juszczyk this many times — but is perhaps the most finely honed in football," Daugherty noted.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Draft analyst believes Oregon tackle would be a good fit for 49ers
ESPN draft analyst Matt Miller, a longtime San Francisco 49ers fan, has identified a player he believes would be a perfect fit for the team's offensive line. Miller has long advocated for the 49ers to draft offensive linemen early. However, the earliest the team has done so... -
PFF names 49ers' breakout candidate for 2025
Pro Football Focus contributor Bradley Locker recently identified one breakout candidate for every NFL team heading into 2025. The pick for the San Francisco 49ers was wide receiver Ricky Pearsall, a young player whose 2024 rookie campaign took an unexpected turn. The 49ers... -
49ers legend Patrick Willis names favorite current linebackers
Hall of Fame linebacker Patrick Willis recently spoke with Touchdown Wire's Ed Easton Jr., offering his insights on today's NFL game. Willis, who spent his entire eight-year career with the San Francisco 49ers, earned five first-team All-Pro honors and was selected to the Pro... -
Over The Cap names 6 candidates as potential 49ers cap casualties
Salary cap resource OverTheCap.com recently published a list of 100 NFL players who might become cap casualties, with their teams potentially parting ways with them to free up salary space. The feature had the following six San Francisco 49ers players listed: DT Maliek...