"Well, if you just said 20 carries a game, I mean, the 49ers want to play 20 games this year. That's 400 touches," analyst Brian Baldinger said on 95.7 The Game's "The Morning Roast" show. "He did that once in Carolina, and he was on the shelf for the next two years—on and off the shelf. It's just too much."
McCaffrey played just 10 games in the two seasons that followed that impressive 2019 campaign before the Carolina Panthers traded him to the 49ers in 2022.
Given the running back position's punishing nature, Baldinger is concerned about McCaffrey's longevity in the NFL.
"You look at the wear and tear that those guys take and the way that he runs between the tackles, I just think you better get, whether it's [Elijah] Mitchell or [Jordan] Mason or somebody, touches, and get them some rhythm. I think you got to preserve him to a degree, especially if it's a runaway game. You gotta find ways to get them off the field."
Despite the 49ers holding a commanding 31-point lead, head coach Kyle Shanahan kept McCaffrey on the field late in Sunday's game against the Jacksonville Jaguars. The running back aimed to break the record for the most consecutive games with at least one touchdown but narrowly fell short.
An injury to McCaffrey with the win well in hand would have been disastrous, but the running back appreciated his team's effort to get him into the record books.
"It means a lot to me for them to keep me in at the end of the game there and try to give me that record," McCaffrey said after the game. "But, hey, I'll take a huge win."
McCaffrey may be the offense's most dynamic playmaker, so Baldinger understands the desire to keep him on the football field. It's challenging to sideline such an impressive player, especially considering the drop-off from McCaffrey to the 49ers' other running backs.
Still, the extensive playing time is concerning, with Baldinger noting, "He might be able to go 400 carries and be fine and get to the offseason, but not many backs can do it, and I've tracked it. I mean, I don't care if your name was Shaun Alexander or Deuce McAllister; every single back that went 400 touches literally was washed up the next year."
You can listen to the entire conversation with Baldinger below.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
49ers' Christian McCaffrey shows off recovery progress with vacation pics
Christian McCaffrey's 2024 season didn't unfold as he had hoped. The San Francisco 49ers running back missed the first eight games due to Achilles tendinitis. He returned to action in November, only to suffer another setback in his fourth game back—a PCL injury that... -
What the Browns playing in London means for the 49ers
The Cleveland Browns have announced that they will host a game at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium in London during the 2025 season, part of the NFL's slate of eight international games—the most ever in a single season. It's official! We're headed to London in 2025, and... -
Why the 49ers' wait for Robert Saleh could extend beyond this weekend
Former New York Jets head coach Robert Saleh is scheduled to meet with the Jacksonville Jaguars on Friday for a second interview regarding their head coaching vacancy. Meanwhile, the San Francisco 49ers are closely monitoring the situation, as head coach Kyle Shanahan is... -
Falcons hire defensive coordinator once on the 49ers' radar
The Atlanta Falcons are hiring Jeff Ulbrich as their new defensive coordinator, removing another highly qualified candidate from the market. The #Falcons are hiring Jeff Ulbrich as their defensive coordinator, per sources. A former NFL linebacker, Ulbrich finished last season...