While Purdy has enjoyed significant success in his brief career, doubters still seek to diminish his accomplishments, arguing that the 24-year-old quarterback benefits more from a talented supporting cast and head coach Kyle Shanahan's system than from skill.
Benjamin's ranking of Purdy seems to contradict that narrative.
"Let's give the kid the respect he deserves," Benjamin wrote. "Two seasons, two NFC title games, one valiant Super Bowl effort. Does he have a sterling setup in San Francisco? Yep. Does he operate like a 10-year vet, managing the pocket as both an efficient and mobile gunslinger? Also yep."
Purdy has guided the 49ers to two NFC Championship Games and a Super Bowl appearance in his two NFL seasons. In 2023, the quarterback set a single-season franchise record with 4,280 passing yards.
49ers legend John Taylor recently discussed Purdy, taking exception to the quarterback's detractors. He reflected on the two Hall of Fame quarterbacks he played with over his illustrious career—Joe Montana and Steve Young.
"If Joe didn't have the group that he had, Joe wouldn't have been Joe," Taylor asserted. "If Steve didn't have the group that he had, Steve wouldn't have been Steve. I've never seen one of those two quarterbacks block for himself, hike the ball to himself, throw the ball to himself and go catch it.
"But they always say, 'Oh, if he didn't have the surrounding party.' Well, that's how teams win. That's how championships are made—of all different parts, not just one person."
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
The Real Case with 49ers QB Brock Purdy
Full disclosure: I am not a journalist. I am not a journalist from the Bay Area who is tuned in to inside sources, such as Matt Maiocco and Matt Barrows, who have been nailing it for decades. No, I am the voice of reason, the voice of the reality check, and today it's "the... -
Insider: 49ers, Brock Purdy negotiations remain far apart; Geno Smith deal could be key
According to Benjamin Allbright, who covers the Denver Broncos for KOA radio and is well-connected across the NFL, the San Francisco 49ers and quarterback Brock Purdy remain far apart in their contract extension negotiations. Both sides had hoped the talks would progress... -
49ers, Brock Purdy take note: Latest QB deal features massive guarantees
ESPN's Adam Schefter reports that the Buffalo Bills and quarterback Josh Allen have agreed to a record-breaking six-year, $330 million contract. While the $55 million average annual salary doesn't surpass Dak Prescott's yearly earnings, the $250 million in guaranteed money is... -
Dianna Russini refutes report of 49ers' first offer to Brock Purdy
Last week, NFL insider Jason La Canfora seemingly reported that the San Francisco 49ers' first offer to Brock Purdy was a contract extension averaging $45 million annually—well below market value for quarterbacks and a figure that wouldn't even make Purdy a top-10 paid...