Samuel's 1,405 receiving yards in 2021 were a career-high, with the wideout averaging an impressive and league-leading 18.2 yards per catch. However, since then, he has failed to surpass 900 receiving yards in a single season and has missed six games over the past two seasons.
While Samuel is still viewed as one of the game's most unique playmakers, his inability to live up to expectations after signing his lucrative deal has earned him the "overrated" label from Pro Football Network contributor Anthony DiBona.
"San Francisco 49ers WR Deebo Samuel appeared to emerge as one of the position's best in 2021," DiBona explained. "But ever since receiving a massive payday from the Niners, Samuel's production has fallen off a cliff."
Some have questioned Samuel's long-term durability, given his physical style of play. Brandon Aiyuk has led the 49ers in receiving yards over the past two seasons, establishing himself as the clear WR1 on the roster. This has led to speculation about Samuel's future, as the team may not be financially capable of paying two receivers top-tier money after the upcoming season.
"In 2021, Samuel hauled in 77 receptions for a whopping 1,405 receiving yards and six touchdowns," DiBona continued. "In each of the last two seasons combined, Samuel has totaled just 1,524 receiving yards. It's safe to say that Samuel has become overrated at this point."
It's worth noting that San Francisco lost each of the two games that Samuel missed last season, along with the preceding game in which he exited early due to a shoulder injury.
Overrated or not, Samuel provides quarterback Brock Purdy and the 49ers offense with another dynamic weapon, enhancing the team's chances of achieving its Super Bowl aspirations during the upcoming season.
More San Francisco 49ers News
-
Does this PFN 7-round mock draft properly address the 49ers' needs?
The San Francisco 49ers enter the 2025 NFL Draft with several pressing needs following what felt like a mass exodus during free agency. In addition to trading away key contributors like wide receiver Deebo Samuel and running back Jordan Mason, the team lost linebacker Dre... -
Deebo Samuel on transition from 49ers to Commanders: 'I like to win'
Deebo Samuel requested a trade from the San Francisco 49ers in January during the team's exit meetings following a disappointing six-win 2024 season. Two months later, he got his wish. The 49ers sent him to the Washington Commanders in exchange for a fifth-round draft... -
Kyle Juszczyk reveals why he returned to the 49ers
The release of Kyle Juszczyk seemed logical, especially given the San Francisco 49ers' offseason roster purge. Most believed the fullback's time in the Bay Area was over. He even visited the Pittsburgh Steelers, which appeared to be a likely next destination for the... -
Why Mac Jones joining the 49ers won't affect Brock Purdy's extension talks
Some believe that the signing of quarterback Mac Jones—a player head coach Kyle Shanahan coveted in the 2021 NFL Draft before ultimately choosing Trey Lance—was a negotiation tactic by the San Francisco 49ers in their contract extension talks with Brock Purdy....