Surprisingly, this question is being asked so frequently, but if we approach it objectively, the answer is quite straightforward. The short response is that the 49ers should not part ways with Kyle Shanahan or John Lynch, as they consistently win and most teams in the NFL would eagerly welcome the opportunity to bring them on board. The longer explanation, however, is more nuanced.
I understand that fans are eager for the "quest for six" to finally come to an end, especially since the 49ers have come so close. It's "champoinship or nothing," right? Imagine if fans had the same expectations for the people in their lives. That would be crazy.
It's also understandable to be frustrated about not drafting Patrick Mahomes and missing (badly) on a few high draft picks. However, fans must remember that there are no guarantees in the NFL draft. It's worth noting that while Mahomes is an exceptional talent, he has flourished due to great coaching and a strong supporting team. He could have easily become a bust if he had landed on a struggling franchise. It's essential to recognize that these organizations are called "teams" for a reason.
Speaking of teams, John Lynch and Kyle Shanahan excel at building them. The fans don't need reminding of how poor the roster was when the current front office took over, but they have persevered and constructed a consistently formidable team through the draft. They always discover hidden gems overlooked by scouts and other organizations. While some of these players have moved on and others are aging, Shanahan and Lynch's strong drafting ability should help mitigate these losses.
This administration boasts an overall record of 70-62 and a postseason record of 8-4. While that may not seem impressive at first glance, context is crucial. The 49ers were without a legitimate starting quarterback in 2017, 2018, and 2020, which accounted for a significant 32 losses. Some fans might argue that "Shanny picked Brian Hoyer," and while that is true, we must consider the broader context. The team needed rebuilding, and Shanahan likely wanted to focus on that before putting a franchise quarterback into a challenging situation. When adjusting the record to reflect games played with a legitimate starting quarterback, the numbers improve to 54-30, which includes two Super Bowl appearances and two NFC Championship appearances—much better than most other teams.
It's perfectly fine to feel hurt or upset, especially for devoted fans who care deeply about their team. However, it's time to trust the process led by two proven and dynamic leaders. Or don't—it's your choice. Either way, be careful what you wish for.
