The San Francisco 49ers lost significant talent this offseason, leading many to declare that their Super Bowl window had slammed shut. While the team hopes its 11 draft picks from last week can help restock the roster and spark another run, one ESPN analyst remains unconvinced.
Former NFL defensive end Marcus Spears believes the 49ers' days as an NFC powerhouse are behind them, and not just because of their recent personnel losses.
"Based on what we've known San Francisco to be, and watching them go to NFC Championship after NFC Championship, and the Super Bowl, the window is closed," Spears said during a segment on NFL Live. "And the window is not closed because they can't compete. The window is closed [because] it's more people that has entered the fray, and they are no longer the team to beat in the NFC."
"It's more people that have entered the fray, and they are no longer the team to beat in the NFC."@mspears96 spoke on the 49ers having less "cachet" heading into this season 😯 pic.twitter.com/CjnhmCRE3X
— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) April 29, 2025
San Francisco is coming off a disappointing 6-11 season plagued by injuries and costly miscues. They're looking to bounce back in 2025, but with quarterback Brock Purdy due for one of the league's biggest paydays, building a deep, talent-rich roster around him will be more challenging.
Spears clarified that he isn't saying the 49ers will become irrelevant, only that their time among the NFC's elite may be over, especially with teams like the reigning Super Bowl champion Philadelphia Eagles and the rising Detroit Lions taking center stage.
"San Francisco is going to be formidable in the NFC," Spears said, "but San Francisco is not going to carry the same cachet that they've carried while we've been doing this job the last five to six years coming into a season."
He added that Philadelphia may now be the team to beat, but the NFC race is far more crowded than before.
"It's also because more fighters have entered the fray," Spears continued. "When you're staring at one man, it's a little bit easier than when you start staring at six or seven. And you can legitimately talk about that many teams in the NFC now potentially having an opportunity to be Super Bowl champions.
"So the window is closed when it comes to their dominance, but they still should be a part of that conversation."
H/t to Andy Lindquist of NBC Sports Bay Area for the find.