Videos are auto-populated by an affiliate. This site has no control over the videos that appear above.
"All of this is part of why I'm so proud to be a part of this and what's built. Joan in payroll. She's not only in payroll, Joan's my financial advisor. Joan's making sure I've got enough money in my 401K. You go on and on and on. Vilma at the front desk. You've got all of these wonderful people in the building. The boys downstairs making that great Mexican feast at Christmas. There's a whole lot that goes on inside this building that nobody knows about. So, with that, you really get an understanding and we all get an understanding of what we're a part of. So, I'm going to tell you, with me, with the football, I take all that."
I've told this story before, of course. But if you'd indulge me, I'd like to tell it one more time. I don't think I'll ever tell it again.
It goes like this: the Niners and I were born together, at the same instant.
I was only nine, and I hadn't gotten into sports. I didn't live near a big city, and my dad didn't root for any pro teams. An older cousin of mine was into the Steelers, like every other kid his age; he was sort of like a big brother to me, so I said I liked the Steelers too. I didn't know they were any good, and I never sat and watched them play. But their colors were cool, so I asked my dad for a Steelers school-bag. He got me one, and that was my involvement in sports.
Then, of course, Joe came along.
I was totally awestruck. He was more than merely a "sports hero"; he was a god, and I worshiped him. And when, just once, my faith wavered—oh, did he ever make me pay, in the cruelest, most spectacular way. When I ran upstairs crying, convinced that he couldn't drive 89 yards, he just went ahead and did it, capping it with the most famous play in the history of the world. And I missed it. Too late, my dad called me back downstairs. I saw the extra point go through, my mouth just hanging open in shock. And then the camera turned to Joe, who looked at me as if to say, "Stick with me, kid."
That's where it all began. For both the Niners and for me. I've loved them every moment since.
And until this week, they've loved me back.
"A lot of people say the speed of the game is the biggest difference between college and pro football. I happen to disagree. I think it's the speed of life. Young people with so much, so fast and being able to handle it and being able to channel it and having people around them to guide, to advise, to care. So, those factors there, which I will say was a big part of my interview and proactive approaches to things and things that our organization is doing and the ways things are going that way and that's exciting and it's all to benefit the players."
That's why I've had so much trouble, letting go of Walsh's Niners. Those are my Niners, the great Niners, what the Niners should always be. Walsh himself couldn't live forever, but his genius should, in the Niners today. Why should only other teams dip into his limitless coaching tree? Why should only other teams exploit his offensive innovations? Losing games is one thing; it's much worse to lose yourself, and that's what the Niners seemed to have done.
At the press conference "explaining" Jim Harbaugh's departure, Jed York finally seemed to get it. "I want a teacher," he said. "I think what made Bill Walsh so successful is that he was a great teacher. Whether that was players, or whether that was other coaches. When you look at his successful coaching tree, when you look at the 49ers Hall of Fame down the road, you want to say that as of 2012 or 2013, 29 of the 32 coaches of the NFL have either a direct or indirect relationship with Bill. That's what made this organization successful."
What was this, if not a recognition that the Niners indeed had lost their way? That the Niners themselves should return to that "successful coaching tree," to which Harbaugh had proven he didn't belong?
As Trent Baalke began the hiring process—which turned out to be as much a sham as the one by which he himself was hired—one prospect outshone the others. Indeed, Mike Shanahan was perfect: a true disciple of Walsh; the architect of the most prolific offense the Niners have ever had; and the "teacher" who singlehandedly converted Steve Young from a running quarterback, skittish in the pocket, to perhaps the greatest passer in the history of the league. Shanahan would've done the same with the Niners' new skittish quarterback, he would've given their offense a desperately needed overhaul, and he would've finally restored their glorious identity—all while keeping intact the league's best defensive staff. The prospect seemed too good to be true.
And, of course, it was.
"My X's and O's philosophy are quite simply you build a team to a scheme. You go into the draft, you go into free agency and you acquire…you're in the talent acquiring business, to a scheme, OK? And then I feel like the most thing is when that's over, now you have to do a 180. And now, see I look at it from a personnel to fit a scheme. So, I'm looking at that scheme and I'm trying to fit the pieces. We don't live in a perfect world, it's not a perfect science. Things happen. People aren't available. So, once we have that talent and we have those players, now we have to flip that and now we look at it, we want to take that scheme and fit it to the players. So to me, when you talk philosophical, that's the way in building your schematics and building your approach to teaching and your building blocks, that's where the…you have to have that latitude going in there to be able to… It's a structure. We stay within our structure, but you have to have that latitude to be able to adapt and adjust your schematics to fit the players. So, I hope that answers your question."
Obviously, Jim Tomsula was the choice all along, and all I can do is apologize. Once again, Baalke proved me wrong. I actually thought that Baalke's issue with Harbaugh was the same as mine: his offensive stubbornness. I actually thought that Baalke recognized the Niners' need for an offensive innovator (if not Shanahan, then perhaps Adam Gase, with whom Baalke dishonestly flirted). I actually wrote—don't worry, Boss!—that Baalke wouldn't be "dumb enough" to hire a coach as bad as Erickson, Nolan, or Singletary. And on all three counts, I was wrong.
You, my dear readers, were right. Baalke's issue was merely this: Harbaugh's refusal to kowtow to Baalke. Baalke had no interest in hiring a better coach, since a better coach would only be more self-assured. Instead he simply wanted a puppet. A man with "humility." A man who'd equate confidence not with skill but with "arrogance." A man without any vision of his own. A man who would do only what he was told.
A man who, when asked the most basic of coaching questions—what's your offensive philosophy?—would respond with such nonsensical gibberish that Baalke would have no choice but to save him: "I think somewhere in there, he said we're going to run the football."
Like any good ventriloquist, Baalke literally spoke for his puppet. (And what he said suggested no offensive innovation at all.)
The league pointed and laughed. At Tomsula, at Baalke, and at all of us.
"So, that's the first thing I learned. Second thing I learned is why not? Why not? Ok, why? Why not? Let's go. Let's do it. Take the step. Let's go. All in, OK? But don't be afraid to step in. Get up and look, step in. Jump in. Let's go. All in. The magic tricks and all the fluff and stuff in life and all those things, football and anything you're doing, outwork 'em. That's not just physical. That's not just physical. I mean outwork them mentally, physically. Outwork people. Earn it. Earn it. We all love people that earn it."
It's true, of course. We do love people who earn it. We love them because we can trust them with it. After all, if they don't earn it, they won't appreciate it. They won't feel any need to protect it. And eventually, they'll crush the dreams of the people who love it.
York didn't earn his job; he didn't do a thing to get it. Baalke didn't earn his job either; he was just in the office next door. And now, fittingly, they've given us Tomsula, not because he's qualified, but specifically because he isn't. If what we love are people who earn it, we certainly can't love anyone here.
That is to say, we can't love these Niners. As much as it hurts, we simply can't.
"I'm going to apologize to Jed. That was a remedial example that I made. I'm sorry for that. But, you know just trying to make the point of doing the little things correctly."
Jed's the one who should apologize. I'm a Niner fan; I don't know how to be anything else. But I've never been this embarrassed to be one. Tomsula's obviously a nice guy; all the players seem to love him. And yeah, his job isn't to "win the press conference." But he had to know that the fans would have doubts. He had to know to be ready to meet them. And his failure was totally absolute. As the face of our franchise, he's so grossly ill-equipped that he simply can't be taken seriously.
Those years before Harbaugh were tough, of course. But this is indescribably worse. We'd survived those years. Just two years ago, we were five yards away from a Super Bowl title. All we needed was an innovative offense. Instead we're right back where we began. We'll have the same archaic O—Baalke's already guaranteed it—and now our defensive staff is gone. And the head coach, once again, is nothing but an empty shell.
I'd never lost hope that Walsh's Niners—the Niners I loved, the Niners I was born with—would find their way back and retake their place. Now I can't pretend anymore. Now my hope is gone for good. My Niners are gone, permanently. What was once the most feared, the most respected, the most admired franchise in all of sports is now a certified laughingstock, as it will be for years to come.
This is what York and Baalke have wrought. And I don't think I'll ever forgive them.
-
leakyfausett
Are they still dead? Just wondering
Feb 22, 2015 at 5:17 PM
-
jim
Didnt know you owned the team. My team?
Feb 22, 2015 at 11:24 AM
-
CWeber
For those SBL investors: if you want to sell your seats, go to
strmarketing.com. I unloaded my SBL seats, listed two weeks ago, got purchased last week money transferred quickly. York and Baalke deserve a empty stadium. And... This doesn't mean I'm not a 49er fan, I am boycotting this ownership!
Feb 17, 2015 at 7:22 AM
-
Dallas Niner Fan
Seems to me the super bowl proved the exact opposite, how many times did Brady throw the ball?
Feb 9, 2015 at 7:16 AM
-
Webzone Commenter
Well the Super Bowl proved what me and Chris P understand, the way to win in the NFL is to rush the damn ball. THe Seahawks got down to the half yard line and then tried to get all fancy with beast mode in the backfield and threw a stupid pass instead of just running the ball in and winning the game. Passing is for losers and the Super Bowl proved it once and for all. Hopefuly with Coach Tomsula we can get back to doing what MIke Signeltery understood, you have to pound the rock. And pound it some more. Greg Roman said the 49ers could have led the league in rushing if he had wanted to, but I guess he didn't want to. That's sure smart. I'm glad that loser is finally gone and we can finally get back to winning Super Bowls again. And then maybe all these liberal media losers will realize how stupid they were in bashing our coach before a single game was played. Is it too much to ask to just wait and see how things turn out?
Feb 6, 2015 at 12:57 PM
-
Lucky Phil
Baalke said yesterday It's a good thing Jed has a small penis because I wouldn't still be here if he didn't. #200.
Feb 1, 2015 at 12:35 PM
-
m singeltary
All 49ers fans know that this franchise is in deep trouble. The last Lowell Cohn editorial spelled it out quite well. I feel bad for all 49ers fans but the group I feel most sad for are the people who bought season tickets. They put their money where their mouth is and got screwed by Baalke and the little York. This franchise wont be winning many games next year or in the near future. Those high priced tickets wont be wanted by anybody. You will soon be stuck. Like a bad marriage. Divorce will be expensive. So what choice will you have but try and stick it out. Try to be positive. The first scapegoat on this team will be Kaepernick. He will only be able to do so much. All of the blame will be on him to start. Then the blame will be spread around because the defense will rank somewhere in the middle 15-20th at best. The offense will rank at best 20th in the nfl. So where will that leave this team as a record??
In this division somewhere between 5 and 7 wins. Everyone try to stay positive but the truth is we will have to lose for a while until we have new leadership and that will take time.
Jan 31, 2015 at 9:52 AM
-
Terry B.
Good riddance, Chris P. Please just go away. For your parting shot, you were wrong again. Kaplan was actually pretty positive through most of the Harbaugh era. Remember stuff like this?
http://www.49erswebzone.com/commentary/1243-look-out-seattle-niners-coming/
And nothing is good enough for him? Is what's going on right now good enough for you? I guess so. As for the article "slamming" Tomsula, you'll see that the article is really directed at York and Baalke. Your reading comprehension skills appear to be at the same level as your spelling. And which players are "slammed" in this column? I must have missed that part. Don't let the door hit you on your way out, Chris.
Jan 30, 2015 at 11:52 AM
-
Dallas Niner Fan
Chris P. To me saying that Niner fans are classless and whiners like you have stated, is getting your point across by being in your words "a jackass". But go ahead and take your toys and go home and good riddance.
Jan 30, 2015 at 8:11 AM
-
Chris P.
Terry, you and Dallas just don't get it so I'll leave you with this. Of course we all will agree and disagree with things that coaches, players, and people in the front office do and you're all free to express that I have no problem with that. But have some class. unfortunately, we live in the Skip Bayless shock jock era and Kaplan has succumbed to that. Go back and look at just about every headline over the last three years that he has put out and I'm willing to bet most of them have been negative. Nothing is good enough for Kaplan. And some of you come on here and applaud him for writing this stuff. If you didn't agree with Mike Singletary I'm fine with that but there is a way to get your opinion across without being a prick about it. Dallas, I don't agree with the Tomsula hire. And I hate what Jed and Baalke just did with Harbaugh. But, I can get my point across without being a jackass. Or writing some article that slams a head coach before he's even had a chance to prove himself. So, keep high-fiving each other for your little nicknames in here and keep trashing players. I'm outta here. Go Niners.
Jan 29, 2015 at 8:10 PM
-
K Wells
The Niners rise from the ashes has been steady since we went 2-14. BTW, here we go again but I want to show you a pattern. Niners hired Nolan and the guy he put In at General manager ( Scot McCloughan ) ended up getting Nolan fired. Scot promoted Singltary, Singletary got him fired. Singletary promoted Baalke and Baalke got Singletary fired. Had Harbaugh followed the pattern and had Baalke walked. We wouldn't have been in this mess. These are the rules of this dogss hit eat dogss hit organization.
Jan 29, 2015 at 12:35 PM
-
Lucky Phil
Reports are the Niners are making a big move bringing back one of the best coaches we have had in Niner forklore.....Mike Dingleberry. Jed "Flaccid" Cork confirmed it today, The Niners are happy to announce the return of Mike Dingleberry as the new OC. Why? The price was right. Mike doesn't work for money, he works for God.
Jan 29, 2015 at 11:51 AM
-
Terry B.
From Walter Football:
"It's amazing how incompetent the 49ers have become. They had one of the top three head coaches in the NFL, an offensive guru who has gotten the most out of mediocre quarterbacks, and the front office has transformed that into a line coach who is now calling all the shots and a new coordinator who has no positive experience at the position.
Geep Chryst was the offensive coordinator of the Chargers in 1999 and 2000. His offenses ranked 26th and 28th, and he was fired after the 2000 campaign in which San Diego went 1-15. Chryst has since had time off and served as a positional coach for various teams, including the quarterbacks' coach for San Francisco.
The 49er players are reportedly dismayed by this promotion, and it's easy to see why. The team made a cheap hire, as Chryst is another "yes man." Chryst has done nothing to deserve this job, as he failed to develop Colin Kaepernick. It's a shame to see this proud franchise decay into oblivion, but that's exactly what's happening because both ownership and the front office are so incompetent."
Jan 29, 2015 at 11:15 AM
-
Terry B.
Chris P.: I'm not mad because you called me out. I think it's kind of fun, actually. What's more fun than being called out by an idiot and a liar who spells below a third grade level? Look, go ahead and make up whatever lies you want. The Seahawks had the tenth most efficient passing offense, and Houston was nineteenth. And I love your "two eyes" argument. All of the stats blow you out of the water, so you rely on your eyes. Get a new pair of glasses. The Seahawks ran well and played great defense before making Russell Wilson the QB. Once he became the starter, they became the best team in the league. It's been proven over and over again that executing your passing game well is the key to winning in the NFL. Nothing is more strongly correlated to winning. And Seattle executes its passing game very well. Why in the world shouldn't SF go down the path that leads to success? Even an idiot like Greg Roman realizes this. He just said yesterday, in an obvious shot at Baalke, that the 49ers could have led the league in rushing every year, but that you don't win that way. But Baalke thinks you do, so here we are. I can't wait to watch this unfold next year.
Jan 29, 2015 at 8:45 AM
-
Dallas Niner Fan
So thank God we have Chris P to keep us honest. He is the Holy Grail of calling us out and keeping us in line. What a guy. Funny how he says he doesn't like the new coach or York or Balkke, but damn those others fans who feel the same way. So please oh mighty one clarify, which is it do you love em or hate em? Thank God we have the patron saint of football to keep us right. As for me Chris P I prefer to "call out" as you put it, people who say that Niner Fans have no class than to trash people who have a legitimate opinion.
Jan 29, 2015 at 7:45 AM
-
baakle must go
Predictions for this season:
The 49ers defense will give up more points and yards and rank outside of the top 12 in total team defense. Mangini will be gone after the season.
The 49er offense will continue to struggle as long as Kapernick is the starting QB. His passing accuracy will continue as his QB rating drops further. (He alone was the reason the 49ers struggled on offense this past season - just ask G. Roman.)
Kapernick will re replaced as the starter by mid-season.
Tomsula will be made the scapegoat for a losing season instead of Baalke.
Jed York will not have the guts to replace Baalke and the 49ers will continue to self-destruct.
The once proud 49er nation will become the laughing stock of the NFC West. The release of J. Haubaugh and the subsequent team downfall will continue to haunt York. York will start to sense that maybe just maybe he retained the wrong person(Baalke instead of Haubaugh) all too late. Baalke will not resign.
The 49ers will continue to struggle to acquire a decent coaching staff as long as Baalke is the GM.
The 49er Faithful are in for another dreadful and painfully sad season thanks to Jed York.
BAALKE MUST GO...PLEASE!!
Jan 29, 2015 at 2:57 AM
-
Chris P.
Alright, this is a lost cause there Skip Bayless. Ryan Fitzpatrick is ranked higher in passing efficiency than Russ so I suppose your going to come out with another stat to try and tell me he is a better QB. Anybody with two eyes can watch the Seahawks and tell you they do not win thru the air. Just like you can watch the Packers, Colts, and pre Week 14 Broncos and say they throw it everywhere and win primarily by throwing it. Do they all mix it up? Of course, but don't tell me the be all and end all of all successful teams is their passing when there are teams that have done it differently and had success with it. But your missing the point, holy crap, your missing the point. The point is you and your boys can't come on here and trash people, players, and coaches and have nobody call you out. Don't be mad because I've called you out.
Jan 28, 2015 at 6:18 PM
-
Ed
It's simple! The "boneheaded" decisions made by the two top ass clowns of this this organization this going to put my beloved 49er's back into the dungeon. But, who cares right Jed? You got what you wanted… the Faithful Fan's to buy into that piece of crap stadium with crappy parking and you not having answer to any of the problems. That's about par for the course. Another SB that the host city won't be in… Dumbass's!
Jan 28, 2015 at 11:43 AM
-
Terry B.
Chris P.: Better to keep your mouth shut and be thought a fool than to open it and remove all doubt. The true sign of a statistical moron: someone who uses counting stats rather than efficiency stats. What decade are you living in? Seahawks were top 10 in passing efficiency, and Wilson was a top 10 passing QB. Chris, please give it up. You are not worthy of this discussion, and every time you post you just dig yourself a deeper hole. However, I do appreciate that you've now given me solid proof of what I suspected all along: you simply have no idea what you're talking about.
Jan 28, 2015 at 8:51 AM
-
Chris P.
As for Terry here are your stats...Seahawks ranked 27th in passing this season. They are ranked #1 in rushing. So, no they do not win thru the air. They win by playing defense and running the football. That's the third time I've had to tell you that.
Wilson's rating of 95 was two better than Alex Smith of 93 and they both averaged 7 yds per completion. Wilson threw for 200 yards more than Smith. Look at the stats last three years...eerily similar. Wilson out throws Smith by about the same amount every year minus his half season when he was bounced by Kap. That's the same Alex Smith you guys trashed on this site and yet you're praising Wilson they're statistically very similar QB. Now before you freak out, I'm not saying Smith is better I'm merely comparing the two and trying to show you that your stats don't tell the whole story and the Seahawks have found a different and effective way to win.
Jan 27, 2015 at 11:14 PM
-
Chris P.
Dallas...this is literally the second article I've read all season by Kaplan. Don't know why really lol. But, what happens is Kaplan just writes trash. He trashes coaches and players and then guys like Terry B applaud him. They are so smug behind a keyboard and can't even throw a spiral. Just like most sportswriters which is why guys like Kaplan drive me so nuts. But, I can't stay away for some reason lol. So, I feel like calling him out and fans like Terry. Nothing is ever good enough for Niner fans. All I told Terry was I don't think Seattle is necessarily a passing team. They win a different sort of way which is similar to how SF was winning the first couple years of Harbaugh's reign. I don't hate Wilson but I don't think he's as good as people think. So, chill out and take a deep breath. I'm a Niner fan thru and thru who calls out fans like Terry and you and writers like Kaplan.
Jan 27, 2015 at 9:01 PM
-
baalke must go
What is Jed York thinking? Last year: Jim Haubaugh (best coach since Walsh) Fangio (top 5 defense) Roman(stuck w/ inaccurate passing QB & weak OL). This year: Tomsula (no NFL head coaching experience) Mangini (last def. coordinator job w/ Pats -team ranked bottom 10 in league)?? Off Coordinator - no decent coach wants the job w/ the the two bozos running the team. Can you all read the writing on the wall? York and Baalke have now created an environment that rivals the Redskins...And we all know what happened to the Redskins. Baalke must go!
Jan 27, 2015 at 2:09 PM
-
dallas niner fan
Chris P. So you say us Niner fans have no class? Your the biggest whiner on this site. You cry about Jeff, you cry about Niner fans being whiners. But I see you on this site all the time. Whats up with that? Not only that but as Terry B. has pointed out you have no facts to back up your ridiculous conclusions. We are the ones who admire the Walsh years when this team had some excellence and integrity and you say we have no class? Quite your whining and go log onto some Seahawk website.
Jan 27, 2015 at 11:46 AM
-
Mike
Hey Geoff, I used to loathe you, but this is the best article I have ever read. I am embarrassed to be a 49er fan right now. So, who's next in line for OC? Jimmy Raye still around?
Jan 27, 2015 at 8:25 AM
-
Terry B.
Chris P.: You are a moron of nearly epic proportions. You've failed to support your arguments with anything, because there's nothing to support them. Wow, one bad game undoes everything else a player has accomplished? I guess Peyton Manning is a terrible passer, too, just like Wilson. Your stupidity is so brazen and overwhelming, one barely knows where to begin.
Here are Wilson's stats. Notice all the marks of a great passer, the completion percentage, TD to int. ratio, yards per attempt. It's all there.
http://www.nfl.com/player/russellwilson/2532975/careerstats
ProFootballFocus has pointed out that Wilson is a top 5 QB when you include rushing, but only drops to no. 9 when you just include passing.
ColdHardFootballFacts noted that after his second season he was second all time in passer rating and average per pass attempt for a player's first two seasons. All time, Chris.
Chris, it's YOU who are a poor excuse for a Niner fan. What can possibly be worse than a homer who has to make up lies about Russell Wilson to make himself feel better? That sure is a classy thing to do.
Jan 27, 2015 at 8:24 AM
-
Chris P.
That article was before his 4 INT effort last week buddy, I'm sure that didn't help. Haha, wow you're a piece of work bro. Poor excuse for a Niner fan man. Which isn't a surprise because Niner fans in general...including the guy who wrote this article just have no class anymore.
Jan 26, 2015 at 10:20 PM
-
Terry B.
Idiot.
http://www.packersnews.com/story/sports/nfl/packers/goska/2015/01/16/wilson-tops-rodgers-starr-best-postseason-passer/21896791/
Jan 26, 2015 at 2:52 PM
-
Chris P.
See what I mean Terry? You get a little upset when people disagree with you. Calm down. You sometimes need to put your personal feelings for Kaplan aside and actually read what I wrote. I told you I don't like the Tomsula hire and I'm not thrilled about the direction he wants to take the offense. And I think Harbaugh knew that which is why he wanted to start going away from that and throw it more but this team is not the Packers. They aren't built to air it out and they've had success with being more smashmouth the previous three years. As far as Wilson goes, save the name calling and watch a Seahawk game. I don't care what the stats say, Russell Wilson is a mess. He literally runs arounds and chucks balls downfield and three or four times a game somebody catches it. The rest of the time his defense gives him great field position or Lynch gashes somebody. Now, I do agree that the more successful teams are or have been passing teams but you cannot tell me Seattle is one of them. They are run first, play great defense, and let Wilson make a play. That's how they win and they're doing it successfully so all I'm saying is there is another way to win in the NFL.
Jan 26, 2015 at 9:34 AM
-
K Wells
If you say this is the first time they betrayed you i have to call you out. You know that when they didnt pay Garcia, let rice go to Oakland, discredited T.O., signed a broken Ahmed Plummer to a bogus major deal while secretly dumping all of our roster, some of those players still play in the NFL on great teams. And the biggest fauxpaw of all... firing a 10-6 mariucci to hire a an all time 50% wpct coach in dennis erickson. I used to cry on this forum until oscar or some other sellout barred me. I am not a troll, I have more niners history and knowledge than 99% of these followers but i do tell the truth as you do. But to say that this is the first time..... nope. its been done before. 9 years winning hiatus. lets hope this one is shorter.
Jan 25, 2015 at 7:49 PM
-
Terry B.
Chris P., last weekend the team that outrushed the other lost 3 of 4 games. The stats show that nothing is more strongly correlated with winning in the NFL than passing well. You can look it up if you don't believe me. The list of the greatest passing teams in league history is a list of some of the greatest teams the league has ever seen. The list of the greatest rushing teams in league history looks like a list of average teams that you picked at random. So, what gives you the best chance of being a successful franchise, building a team that runs well or building a team that passes well? If you say the former, you're even dumber than you already appear to be. If you really want to just win, as you say, then build a team that is likely to do so. I don't know why you would somehow think that hiring an illiterate hedgehog is the way to get there. As for your nitwit comments about the Seahawks, Russell Wilson is the 10th highest rated passer in the NFL, and he's no. 8 overall in yards per attempt, which is the stat most strongly correlated with winning in the NFL, but, no, Wilson isn't a great passing QB. You have to be pretty bad to be a top 10 QB in the NFL. Idiot.
Jan 25, 2015 at 4:20 PM
-
Chris P.
Wow Terry B we already know you agree with anything Kaplan writes and if anybody disagrees then they're a bunch of misguided homers. For you to say check the analytics on how passing wins in the NFL is a bit ignorant when the Seattle Seahawks are about to win two SB's in a row. And don't try to tell me Russell Wilson is a great passing QB, he literally makes two or three plays a game in the air. The rest of the game he is getting bailed out by his defense and Marshawn Lynch. The Seahawks have found a formula that wins. Now, I'm not saying I particularly like it and I'm not thrilled about Tomsula. I don't like Baalke and Jed has no spine. I also think you and Jeff along with the rest of the front office live in fairytale land if you think Bill Walsh is out there. There is no, nor will there ever be, amother Bill Walsh so stop looking for him. Walsh said he thought the next great SF coach was Harbaugh...and he was right! Now he's gone and we are starting from scratch because they want to win a certain way...how about you just WIN!
Jan 25, 2015 at 12:40 PM
-
Flaccid Penis In Shoes
My Two Incher Is Dead
Jan 24, 2015 at 6:12 PM
-
Ed
I'm so... disappointed with the Senior Leadship of 49er's. A bunch of ass clowns with Jed York as the ring leader.
Jed York is full of crap. I want hold him accountable for being such a dumbass.
Jan 24, 2015 at 3:21 PM
-
tom
Mr. B you certainly do seem to like your fetish allusions. No doubt a big Pulp Fiction fan as well
Jan 24, 2015 at 9:35 AM
-
kd
I've always deeply respected your opinion... but it' a shame you drank the kool-aid (along with most everyone else) on this one.... I disagree 100%.... now ask me 12months from now, and maybe then, I will jump on the bandwagon... until then... WE SHOULD ALL WAIT AND SEE WHAT HAPPENS .... **** i don't get you guys.... IF the 49ers have a great season next year some of you folks need to forfeit your fan pass..... ohh well, time will tell
Jan 23, 2015 at 8:06 PM
-
Joe
your an idiot....
Jan 22, 2015 at 8:21 AM
-
mark
I didn't run upstairs thinking Joe couldn't do it... I watched in awe as he marched them down to victory, but that was also the moment I became a die hard. You are right, the niners made the dumbest choice they could have made. They wanted the YES man they could control and they let a lot of great coaches leave in the process. But they will never be dead to me and every year I will hope they regain their former glory no matter how dire it may seem. Good article... And good riddance to you if you abandon them this time.
Jan 21, 2015 at 10:50 PM
-
Dallas Niner Fan
OK, one more time for all you slow learners out there;
Here are the decisions the Niners could of made:
1. Give Harbaugh one of the winnest coaches in NFL history and most of his staff one of the best in the NFL another shot.
2. Hire Shanahan a offensive guru with a winning record while keeping the defense staff in place, again one of the best staffs in the NFL.
3. Hire a head coach with some level of NFL credentials either as head coach or coordinator.
4. Do what they did. Fire Hargaugh because as one ESPN commentator said because "Niner Management was not comfortable having a beer with him after work." and hire a coach with little head coaching experience and no coordinator experience even though position coaches with little head coaching experience at any level and no coordinator experience in the NFL rarely if ever are successful. Decimate the very successful coaching staff.
Now I challenge anyone given the options above can make a case that the Niners made a good decision. (#4) That's the bottom line folks.
Jan 21, 2015 at 11:28 AM
-
Terry B.
Tom, for someone who purports not to like Kaplan's articles, you sure spend a lot of time on this page. Me, I don't typically spend much time on webpages that I don't like. Perhaps you're a masochist? Since you seem poised to wear the ball gag and leather for Jed, that makes sense. If you like the ground and pound offense so much and don't care for explosiveness, I suggest that you spend some time reading the advanced analytics and learn for yourself which is strongly correlated to winning in the NFL, rushing well or passing well. I'll give you a hint: it's not the former. Oddly, you seem to identify the problem: "York and Baalke rolled the dice," but then you are strangely unable to understand the criticism.
Jan 21, 2015 at 8:38 AM
-
Tom
Putting an awful lot of words in my mouth there Mr. B. I don't think I actually said any of what you are attributing to me. Quite honestly to me it's just a game. I like to see them win but I don't particularly care how they do it. I really liked the ground and pound of Harbaugh's first couple of years. Run, the ball, play tough defense, control the clock and I thought it was a mistake to turn the team over to Kaepernick when the did. But for people like Kaplan, and you presumably, winning was never enough. He was always crying about a lack of "explosiveness" and saying how boring it was to watch them. As Steve Young once so famously said, playing in SF you can't just win, you have to earn style points as well. Which is why everybody refers to the team's fans as 40 whiners. I think it is well deserved. As for York and Baalke I don't really have an opinion of them either way. They're clearly rolling the dice with Tomsula and I hope it doesn't come back and bite the team in the ass. Only time will tell.
Jan 21, 2015 at 2:14 AM
-
Terry B.
Right, Tom, why in the world would Jeff, Dallas, Zach, or any other fan want to continue the legacy established by Bill Walsh? The fans who fell in love with the team because of its offensive innovations, true commitment to excellence, etc.,--why in the world should they want the team to adhere to THAT vision? You see, a true fan like yourself doesn't care about any of that. Hire your coaches out of monetary considerations only? Hire coaches who cannot articulate ANY vision? Sounds great to Tom! What a true fan Tom is. Those with no standards are the true fans! Tom will happily bend over and accept whatever Jed has to offer.
Jan 20, 2015 at 1:11 PM
-
Tom
Terry B. I think you are the one missing the point. If you have suffered through reading the majority of Kaplan's articles you would see that in his mind there is no difference between THE 49ers and HIS 49ers, in his mind they are one in the same. So unless the team adheres to precisely his vision of what they should be he will put on the hair shirt and start singing his songs of lament. It's actually really tiresome. I don't know why I bother to read him quite frankly.
Jan 20, 2015 at 12:21 PM
-
Zach Ameen
Don't buy season tickets. Balke and York should consider merging 49ers with Raiders with same ownership mentality. I predicted that next coach will be a 3 million dollar coach with cheaply paid assistants. York is all about money and not about pride.
Jan 20, 2015 at 11:18 AM
-
Dallas Niner Fan
Jeff, great article. Even though you and I don't agree about Harbaugh, I don't think that either of us in our worst nightmares could of predicted this disaster by the Niner front office nuthouse. You know, a lot of 49er fans just don't get it, this is not about jumping on and off the Niner band wagon, or about supporting your team thru thick or thin and winning or losing. Its about trying to support an organization that has a front office that is back stabbing, political and just plain makes bad decisions. How can I support an organization that fires employees because they are too old and won't make a good impression on Silicon executives? You kidding me? Jeff, you might not hear from me in a while, I may change my mind but I am looking for another NFL team to root for and for those of you that criticize fans like me, Jeff and other fans on this site for being fair whether fans I submit that we are the real fans. We love our team so much that we care about the direction the organization is going and we can't stand to bear more of the pain now and in the future. Its not about the players its about the lack of leadership and the ethics of upper management and ownership.
Jan 20, 2015 at 7:35 AM
-
Terry B.
Carolyn, you (and about 80% of the posters here) missed the entire point of the article. Read it again, starting with the title. Jeff didn't say THE Niners are dead, he said that HIS Niners were dead. The article is about loss of identity. Unless anyone here is prepared to argue that turning the franchise over to this man who no one else wanted as head coach and who cannot string two coherent sentences together is continuing the legacy established by Bill Walsh, then I don't see how anyone can disagree with the article's thesis. It does, however, require reading above a third grade level, which, sadly, few people here are able to do.
Jan 20, 2015 at 5:11 AM
-
Carolyn Padgett
I totally agree with your feelings about York and Baalke. They are much more concerned about how they are viewed and are not concerned about what is best for the 49ers or the fans. I do, however, disagree with your statement that the 49ers are dead.
What about the players? Is turning your back on the team the answer? Those men on that team continue to deserve our support.
The 49ers do not cease to be just because two knuckleheads are in charge. If anything, this teams needs it's fans more than ever.
Your attitude suggests that it's all about you. Quite frankly, it is not. I also fondly remember the days of Walsh and Montana. The 49ers had a long dry spell before and after them. So what? Did you give up on them then? Apparently not. So why now?
Also, the laughing stock in the 49ers are the two clowns at the top. Please don't lump the players in with them. I think that you are doing a great disservice to the team.
I don't know what next season will bring, but I do know that I will be supporting my team as always and praying that the Yorks sell the team to someone who understands the game and supports the team.
Jan 20, 2015 at 12:52 AM
-
Nick S.
From here on out, I refuse to read any of your further articles where you write yourself into the story. This isn't supposed to be your autobiography Kaplan, and Bill Walsh isn't your late grandfather... last time I checked.
Jan 19, 2015 at 8:27 PM
-
Pump the Brakes
Mr. Kaplan, you never learned the lesson Joe taught you, we haven't even hired an OC and you've already decided our Offense un-imaginative? Don't run upstairs crying just yet. Tomsula might be exactly what we needed(along with Chud). This past year I watched some pretty un-inspired football, that's where Tomsula is perfect.
Jan 19, 2015 at 7:52 PM
-
Rfern
@steve terry Donahue was also smarter than you and me!! Rolling with Nolan baby!!
Jan 19, 2015 at 7:11 PM
-
snoopy
Shouldn't have gotten rid of Alex Smith
Jan 19, 2015 at 7:04 PM
-
Steve
Im with the group that is keeping a positive outlook and I'll tell you why. 1 There is still a lot of talent on this team. 2 Although Baalke has missed on a few draft picks I think he's a good GM who has drafted good players. 3 Why would he hire somebody to so call "control" and is just a puppet as you say. If Tomsula fails then Baalke is out of a job so why would he sabotage himself? 4 We had what 18 players on injured reserve? isn't that a 3rd of our team? 5 Shanahan employees light quick offensive lineman which is not how were built.. 6 Adam Gase and Josh Mcdaniels don't even use a fullback so what happens to a great player like Bruce Miller? 7Jed York makes more money when the Niners win so why would he intentionally make the team weaker? 8 This team clearly quit on Jim Harbaugh and Greg Roman. Don't believe it? Just check Joe Staley's comments of "dumb schemes". 9 Last comment! There's a reason why Trent Baalke makes 7 figures and I'm a plumber, because he knows more than me and you geniuses about football and were just fans so relax and enjoy our team. Niner fan forever here. Steve Fusco Bronx New York.
Jan 19, 2015 at 5:05 PM
-
Baalke Must Go
York needs to wake up & realize that the 49ers are in a tailspin with Baalke as GM. Tomsula,Tarver,Kiflin instead of Haubaugh, Vangio,Roman..seriously?? What's wrong with this picture? The Seahawks, Rams & Cardinals and their fans are doing high fives at this joke. Remember the Mike Singletary fiasco? It is insanity to keep doing the same thing over and over and expect a different result. York should have gone out and overpay if necessary to get Kubiak or Mora (UCLA) as the 49ers head coach. Baalke is the cancer that will ultimately lead to the complete downfall of the once proud and great SF 49ers. 49er fans can start praying that after the multiple looses next season York has the balls to can Baalke. "Win with class"...give me a fr..... break already. It's not how you win - You win or you lose - period. BAALKE MUST GO!!!
Jan 19, 2015 at 3:48 PM
-
steve
it seems kind of strange that Baalke has so much control over everything maybe he has a head coach fetish? it would seem the head coach would pick his staff and bring in the guys he thinks will fit his style and work the best together yet it seems Baalke is in the drivers seat on everything with team this is bad juju before 4 years ago he had no GM experience and still has no coaching experience it makes it seem like jimmy T his just his lap dog jed York said it is super bowl or bust I guess only time will tell is this a joke or a god send if it does not work jed needs to fire Baalke and bring a seasoned GM and start over and soon good rots of ruck go 9ers.
Jan 19, 2015 at 2:33 PM
-
Dave from BC
Certified laughingstock? Enjoy hyperbole much? You must be in soooo much agony. I can almost visualize you jumping ship the moment the poop deck is moist, or somebody farts at a rifle range. Put down your sword and let this play out.
Jan 19, 2015 at 12:50 PM
-
NinerRyder
I've seen a lot of smooth talkers who couldn't do squat...so I'm not worred about JT coming off with a bit of rambling. I think this was the classic "trying too hard" performance. He just needs to be himself as much as possible...he'll be that way...give him a few days and weeks to fill out his staff and do some reflection on his 1st presser. But really, I think his response regarding his philosophy and X's and O's was brilliant. Go back and read what he said, it's very thoughtful. Having to sit there being bookended by Baalke and York was tough...I think he would have been better standing up in front of a podium vs. getting the death stare from TB and JD over his right and left shoulders. Mike Nolan was a smooth talker...how did that work out for him? Go Niners!...fan since 1970.
Jan 19, 2015 at 9:48 AM
-
Montana1
It's not too late! All is not lost!! Kiffen can save the day! Gobble up all the Raiders coaches and you've got your Super Bowl!! Woohoo!
PS, NOT renewing season tix... Done, done and done.
Jan 18, 2015 at 11:42 PM
-
Zion Niner
York and Baalke have proven that politics are more important than winning. That is obvious now, and a sad testament to what this team has accomplished in the last few years. Sad.
With that being said I'm going to give Tomsula a chance. You never know what can happen... Agreed, Tomsula is a rambler on the mic, but he might turn out to be good for the team.
But, the fanbase should recognize that York and Baalke really don't care about the team winning, and just want a status quo.
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:10 PM
-
id1946
you are totally correct with the comments you have made, I have been a 49erss fan for some 60 years. this Management might be the worst than when Joe Thomas was GM.
Jan 18, 2015 at 7:17 PM
-
REB4
Our nemesis is going to the Super Bowl, and our team is hiring Lane Kiffin? What a joke! Thanks York/Baalke!!
Jan 18, 2015 at 6:17 PM
-
James Vidos
Great article. So true. As long as "baby" Jed and Parcells stepson are running the 49ers, they r going down! Great Franchise being destroyed by these imposters. Thank You Jeff.
Jan 18, 2015 at 5:41 PM
-
geofreedo
Bring Mike Shanahan back.
Jan 18, 2015 at 4:52 PM
-
Karihappy
Jeff, it seems as though you were drunk and depressed when you wrote this article. Please return to the wonderful writer I have come to love. Go 9ers!!!
Jan 18, 2015 at 4:39 PM
-
ChuckW
although this article is long winded, he is correct, Jed York is a rich kid fed with a silver spoon, never worked a day in his life and was given the CEO job by owner parents. He is not qualified to lead this franchise as exemplified by his "apology" Thanksgiving night. An immature move. Baalke is an egotist a power hungry individual that wants "yes" men and brown misers around him. Jeff is right as long as we have these clowns running the team expect a long championship drought. I'm selling my SBLs
Jan 18, 2015 at 4:23 PM
-
Solidg2000
Terrible article! You probably stopped watching during the saints vs NINERS playoff game too! You sir, sound like a true fair weather fan!
Jan 18, 2015 at 1:17 PM
-
Seattle49er
I would remind you that Saint Eddie D. was once ostracized by the faithful for hiring Joe Thomas as GM and Eddie was characterized as a carpet bagger from Ohio. The difference is Eddie knew how to listen and fired Thomas, then hired Genius Bill Walsh as GM, HC and OC. It is Bill Walsh who was a teacher, motivator AND offensive Guru. Coach Walsh identified good people to hire at a glance (exception to Hollywood Henderson). There will never be another like Bill Walsh nor a coach with that much control. The only issue with the 49ers is the prodigy of the Yorks. In stupidity, the Yorks are a class of their own and the hiring of Tomsula maybe another chapter in the vein of Dennis Erickson. The mention of Kiffen as OC goes a long way to confirm how badly York and Baalke are when it comes to football, not to mention Tomsula, as Kiffen continues to be the best example of a VI.
Jan 18, 2015 at 12:32 PM
-
Dont believe the hype
"Lane Kiffin is forerunner for OC job."
Trent will say 'No' and Jed will say 'Yes, dear'
Jan 18, 2015 at 11:54 AM
-
Sam
I'm no longer a 49er fan, likely no longer an NFL .... To NFL, fan=idiot!
Jan 18, 2015 at 10:36 AM
-
NinerGM
It's articles like to use it tries me absolutely insane. The reason is it because I don't believe everything has their own opinion about the team, it has more to do with people not even knowing what the future is forgiving the new coaching reaching a chance before making a summary judgment. It is absolutely read Dick you list me to presume that The GM in the past has consulted with the likes of Bill Parcells and others would make such a off-the-wall shit place without any concern about effectiveness. One has to think Trent was willing to speak to Purcells or any other coach out there confidant with all of his experience in The NFL, you have to presume and make projections based on what you've seen previously. That has been nothing but someone who makes sound judgment in Great decision-making.
Jan 18, 2015 at 9:48 AM
-
rdrsfn4lf
Good luck to the 9ners next season. Raider nation will prevail and might finally see the light at the end of the tunnel. Looking forward to a great season .
Jan 18, 2015 at 9:06 AM
-
crabcon
When the 49ers left San Francisco they died....
I hope the York`s are happy with themselves..
I hope Gavin is happy...
Insiders know who distroyed this team and when...
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:37 AM
-
Hassan
I too became a Niners fan the same year as you. This offseason has broken my belief in Baakle and York, I read your words and it mirrored my thoughts. I don't know how not to be anything but a fan of my beloved Niners, but I don't feel we win again until Baakle is gone.
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:29 AM
-
Marty
I was more disappointed with the Harbaugh selection. When he stated in his very first press conference he promised Bo he would always have a FB on the field i knew what he meant. He was taking the 49ers back to the 70's Big Ten offense. It was always about being the bullies. Never about winning. The players won the games. In 2014 when all the players were out the Harbaugh became an average coach. Harbaugh blew his chance for a SB in 2011 & 2012. I doubt he will ever get another opportunity like those seasons.
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:28 AM
-
mrwoodz
What a horrible article. What a horrible excuse for a fan.
This is one of the most unfounded, senseless articles I have ever read on the webzone, so much so, it is the first one I have ever commented on. But that is maybe what you are going for.
The team really don't need your type of fan, and at least if "your" 49ers are dead we maybe won't read anything by you on here in the future.
You might rightly think that Jed never earned his position, but Tomsula has always worked hard, and has always produced results. Yes, his head coaching and coordinator experience is at lower levels, but it is his 8 years of getting amazing performance from our defensive linemen that really justifies at least a promotion for him.
He got Justin Smith to be the player he is (no probowls before he played for Tomsula) and several low round picks or UDFAs have been productive for us, and have earned big contracts elsewhere under Tomsula's tutelage.
I could go on, and pick fault with each word in your post, but I have other things to do today. But I am looking forward to the draft, and to September. Good luck to whatever unfortunate team has your support next season.
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:21 AM
-
kray28
After 26 years of being a devout, diehard fan...good times and bad, this is the worst I have felt about the team. The front office has no respect for the fans. And they don't care, Jed got his precious stadium filled with the NFL's quietest fans. A great metaphor for the state of the organization where money and power are more important than winning. Winning needs intelligence and integrity, which neither York nor Baalke possess. Management has demonstrated to me that the franchise is not worth the concern I might otherwise give it. If a fan like me stops caring they should worried...they too tone deaf to get it. The karmic outcome is coming though.
Jan 18, 2015 at 8:08 AM
-
9er 4 life
Jeff you were a pussy when you were nine and still are. If you gave up on Joe Montana and ran upstairs crying, you had no clue who he or the 49ers were, or what they were capable of. This is still a solid, talented group of football players with a desire to win. Why not stick around this time, give JT and management a chance. Haven't even hired a staff yet. For whatever reason, and it's to bad, JH lost the locker room last year. Why not stick around and see how this plays out. Or do ya just wanna hide in your room and cry?
Jan 18, 2015 at 7:35 AM
-
Terry B.
Phil C. You seem like a smart enough guy. It shouldn't be necessary to have to explain this stuff to you. How do you know Tomsula is a good Xs and Os guy? Wouldn't you think he could answer a basic question about his philosophies without sounding like a blithering idiot if that were the case? We've heard that he's a good teacher, but so what? He wasn't going anywhere; you could have kept him on staff. Hell, make him assistant head coach if you want. But to take this man and make him the face of your franchise shows such a complete lack of common sense that you have to question Jed's and Trent's fitness for their jobs. This man CANNOT be the face of your franchise. Tell me, did they swing for the fences and put together their best staff? How about Shanahan HC, Fangio DC, Tomsula assistant HC/DL. Think that might have been better? From everything we've read, that staff could have been had. You're not faithful; you're an apologist. There's a big difference. Faithful fans want what's BEST for their team. They don't just bend over for ownership and take it. We now have the worst HC in the division, but you predict great things for this franchise? Get your head out of your ass.
Jan 18, 2015 at 7:15 AM
-
Webzone Commenter
I'd like to put Kaplan in a room with Tomlusa and see him say these things to his face.
Jan 18, 2015 at 6:23 AM
-
Terry B.
Yeah, James, how is a mere fan to know that getting rid of Vic Fangio is a bad idea? You have to be a football expert to know that. Moron.
Jan 18, 2015 at 6:18 AM
-
Alex
Wish I could get back the time I wasted reading this poor editorial.
Jan 18, 2015 at 5:06 AM
-
James
I gotta be honest, reading this kind of garbage makes me sick. It is amazing how many experts there are in these forums that seem to know more about football than those who do it for a living. So, you have a crystal ball and know exactly how this is gonna go down huh? To compare this to Singletary or Nolan or anyone else is just ridiculous. It comes down to players on the field. Walsh didn't win every game or have winning seasons every year - why? the talent of the players on the field. You people need to sit back and quit acting like the sky is falling. Maybe you will be surprised
Jan 18, 2015 at 2:59 AM
-
jeff
So what happened during the Ericson, Nolan, Singletary days..we weren't dead then? What a piece of crap article.
Jan 18, 2015 at 1:46 AM
-
Mitch Tropila
Dear Jeff:
Would you please run your original 49ers story about running up to you room and your father coming up to talk you down? I LOVE that story and cry every time......
Mitch
Jan 18, 2015 at 12:47 AM
-
Demi Santiago
It is what it is. This is Jerry Jones all over it, meaning he is the alpha male its my way or bye way. We just have to sit back and wait it out. Go Niners
Jan 18, 2015 at 12:30 AM
-
ddeon
I never knew why people would call niner fans whinners.Now I see ive never seen a bunch of whinney b@$$hes in my life..Quest for 6 GO9ERS
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:21 PM
-
ray
I have already started to feel the pain and the utmost misery of being a niner fan in the coming years... Couldn't agree anymore with each n every single word of the column
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:16 PM
-
Keith M
Can anyone imagine working for Baalke and York. People have said how hard Harbaugh was to work with. But put yourself in his shoes. Baalke wants this team to play a certain way even though he is not the coach. He wants the direction of this team on the field to be his vision. York put unreal pressure and expectations on the coach even though by everyone elses eyes he exceeded them by a fair amount. Then when things got tough this year mainly through injuries they leak and backstab the coach and leak information that not only hurt the coach but also the team. My thoughts are that Harbaugh should have been there a long time to see if he can win the Superbowl. And the recent selection of the new coach shows they now have problems attracting anyone good because of their treatment of the last coach, and who would want to work in this environment anyway but someone like Tomsula?
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:15 PM
-
Dean
I agree with you Jeff. My niners are dead! I became a 49er fan about the same time as you. During their hay days back in the glorious 80's. Why? Because of our HC... the GENIUS, Bill Walsh. A cerebral leader who brought us the west coast offense. Who brought in and groomed future HC's. Who had an eye for talent and was a master motivator, leader and speaker. We were a FIRST CLASS organization with an owner in Eddie D who was willing to spend the money for players and on his players. The niners were different than all the other NFL teams... and that's why I was a niner fan. That was our legacy! And it's dead! Now, we have as the HC and err... leader ... the guy who lived in the van down by the river. An owner who speaks of class but looks and acts like the loser kid that always sat at the back of the class. And lest we forget... the organization that passed on Aaron Rodgers who wanted to be a 49er. OMG!
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:05 PM
-
Phil C.
Who are the lemmings? The ones who are heeding what a lot of current and former players and people in the NFL world say about Tomsula, which is mostly positive, or the ones who agree with what some fanboy just spewed out of his fingers? The man just got hired 3 days ago. Okay, so the transition from Harbaugh to Tomsula was handled awkwardly. So what? All that matters is what happens on the field. People are comparing this to the Singletary hire, but Tomsula is a much better X's and O's guy, and unlike Ditka disciples Singletary and Harbaugh, he won't run the team into the ground and rely on guts more than brains. This team will continue to play hard but also will play a lot smarter. Rathman remains, and if the Niners can get Chudzinski that could mean Frank returns, and there's still a 50-50 chance Cowboy returns with Tomsula as the head man. I think we're seeing who the real fans are now; all these bandwagoners are fleeing the scene because their boy Harbaugh is gone, and the Faithful remain.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:01 PM
-
Terry B.
Someone explain this to me. When it was in the air that the Harbaugh era might be ending, this board was in total meltdown. Stewart's open letter to Jed York was the most supported article in this site's history. Everyone was screaming bloody murder about what would happen if Harbaugh was let go. Jed was being vilified. So then, not only does Jed go through with it and can Harbaugh, he ALSO let Fangio go, and then hired someone totally unfit for the job. He doubled down and tripled down. So, shouldn't the reaction be three times as bad as when letting Harbaugh go was just "in the air"? Instead, the idiot homers here are actually DEFENDING these ridiculous decisions. Answer me this, homers. If you really support this and think it's a great idea, then how come you were up in arms about the Harbaugh thing? Why weren't all of you saying, "hey, no big deal if we get rid of Harbaugh, because we can just elevate Tomsula"? Is it because you are all just lemmings like Casey says below? Is there any possible interpretation other than that all of you are just full of crap and defend every single move this franchise makes?
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:31 PM
-
Baalke Must Go
Baalke must go. Look at his drafts over the years - AJ Jenkins - really? Anthony Davis #1, Joe Looney, Vance McDonald - really? Who cares about winning with "class". Just win period!! The 49ers are dead thanks to York.
Baalke wanted a coach that he could dominate and York is a fool to think Baalke can bring a SB victory to the 49ers. The problem is Baalke and it wasn't Harbaugh (more wins than any other coach under York)
Any coach will have problems with Baalke & York. All 49er fans should pray that someone hires Baalke away from the 49ers. This is our only hope.
Jan 17, 2015 at 6:12 PM
-
GrizzlyAdams
Typical WZ overreaction. There are a lot of football people saying Tomsula will do great things. Stop listening to the Cohns & Damon Bruce.
Jan 17, 2015 at 6:06 PM
-
Lucky Phil
Jed York should be honest with the fans. "Winning with class" is not whats important. We are supporting a team that is focused on "Losing with Cash". I'll make him a T-shirt. I'll send it to you for free, Jed.
Jan 17, 2015 at 6:02 PM
-
James
We don't even have coordinators yet. Think it might be a little early for this?
Jan 17, 2015 at 5:58 PM
-
Casey
Some of you fans out there criticizing Jeff for writing what he feels and telling him to shut the door on the way out should wake up. Some of you who just blindly follow York and Baalke remind of lemmings happily marching their way over the ledge. The mark of a good fan, of an intelligent fan, is someone who constantly questions leadership and the moves the team makes. I'd rather have fans like Jeff than some of you who say, "YAY, we hired ______, we're going to the Super Bowl!!" without any constructive criticism or instructive and useful feedback than a bunch of "yes men" who never question moves the team makes. One can be a strong supporter without being a blind idiot.
Jan 17, 2015 at 5:57 PM
-
Monsterniner
Jeff Kaplan, I was reading you and I was feeling like I had wrote this article. I´m a longlife Niners fan. I lived the Montana´s glory days. I lived the Young´s glory days. I cried for 3 hours when we lost the 1990 Championship Game with the Craig´s fumble. I enjoyed like crazy when we finally defeated the Cowboys in the 1994 Championship Game. Then I suffered with the Eddie D´s departure and the darks ages that came later. I saw our resurrection with Harbaugh and I thought that the real Niners have came back. Like you, I was ok with Harbaugh leaving because I thought that we were going to look for a better offensive mind. But you see, during the glory days and the dark ages I was always proud of being a Niners fan, I always wore mir Niners gear even in the 2-14 season. Now this is the first time in my life that I feel ashamed of my team. I feel ashamed of being a Niners fan. Don´t get me wrong, I love our players that go to war every sunday but this ownership is killing my love for this team and honestly I don´t know if I can still be a Niners fan after all this circus.
Jan 17, 2015 at 5:48 PM
-
Darrell Brantingham
Give me a break! I have been a 49ers fan since 1969 and I have obviously seen a ton of success and failure over that timeframe. The fact is that Harbaugh had to go:
- Difficult for everyone to work with.
- Players stopped playing for him.
- Horrible clock management.
- Finished 3rd in the division this year and in obvious decline from the first two years.
- Wanted to keep a horrible OC where no one got open.
- Could never stop the play clock issue which constantly rushed Kaepernick in getting the ball snapped.
On the bright side, the man running the team York and his GM Baalke brought in Harbaugh in the 1st place and if the right Offensive Coordinator is hired like Chudzinski we will once again be a great team.
So get over it---were you a fan in the late 70's when every 9er fan really did have a reason to give up? These are not the worst of times---in fact York and Baalke did the right thing and York does not need to explain anything to whiner fans like you or the media whose bias against the Yorks is off the charts. Stop reading and listening to the sports media in the Bay Area. Most of them hate the 49ers and York because he is rich. My 9ers aren't dead yet!
Jan 17, 2015 at 5:29 PM
-
Anthony bejarano
Wow,as an unwavering 49ers fan that hurt my heart to hear a supposed true niner fan write that. To me its seems as if you were ready and willing to give up on them since that first time you ran up to your room. Truth is in your heart you have never been a real niners fan. Yea we have alot of issues to resolve before next season as with any new hc, but being a diehard niner fan I will sit and watch tomsula and see how he brings it together. As for coach harbaugh, he brought the niners back from disgrace to at least close to winning. I'm kno everyone remembers watching as Alex smith argued with singltary on the sidelines and how harbaugh turned it around the very next season and took us to the NFC championship. All I can say to you article is go ahead and move on cause all of us REAL niners fans and the 49ers team don' t need no quitters who give up so easily. We overcame adversity before and we' all do it again.
Jan 17, 2015 at 5:10 PM
-
Lance C. Johansen
WOW. It's impossible, for even
a Seahawks fan (which I'm not),
not to empathize. Yikes! Where
to start? Not a sparkling lump
of brevity but quite understandable. Word choice;
adequate. Don't get the print
change relevance. I think the
"deceased equine" got his/her
message. Liked your variety of
whip strokes, though. Do you
have the ph# for the suicide
prevention folks?
Robert, I've been a 9er fan
since starting college at DeAnza
college in 69. Coming from HI
my addiction to the 9ers has
lasted to this day.
I'll spare you & readers tear
stained recollections. Suffice to
say, I have them.
Clowns like you've described
in the 9er office are only like
yeast infections. They come and go in those you love.
BELIEVE ME
Don't dignify them by using
their legal names. If you must,
grievously misspell them!
Robert, in your dissertation,
you are kicking no one's ass
but your own.
Prove your a Niner fan. Go
to all the games you can.
Extend your spport and empathy
to the players. Most of whom
walk around with a emotional
erection in disbelief that they're
actually wearing the colors we
both love so much.
Jan 17, 2015 at 4:37 PM
-
tim
The York's have set the 49ers back another 10 years at least.Pathetic,I can't be a fan any longer to a team who has a cancerous management.Goodbye
Jan 17, 2015 at 4:32 PM
-
Audick
Webzone Commenter:
All football teams are bellicose right-wing war machines like you by nature.
The 49ers in their prime were different. They were Woody Allen getting all the chicks while John Wayne swung and missed. The league was baffled. How did those pansy glasses-wearing hippies win football games? They did it with brains.
But that day is over. You can be happy that the knuckle-dragging neanderthal right-wing era is back. You can feel secure again that no arrogant effete librull-media loving white-wine drinkers will make you question your manhood again.
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:59 PM
-
Louie
The 49ers have been dysfunctional since the Yorks took over. The only lapse came when they were foolish enough to hire a highly touted coach with a great football resume. He proceeded to lead the 49ers out of the other bottom feeders all the way to an NFC championship. So the Yorks tried to trade him and when that didn't work out they fired him and tried to slander him by saying he didn't win with class and he wasn't 't a teacher. Even those of you who disagree with Kaplan's rant know that every word that York has spoken about this is a lie. The truth is that he dislikes Harbaugh and has Balke, his butt boy, to assure him that that they can win "with class", whatever the hell that means.
The truth is that there are 25 ,or so, teams in the NFL that never sniff the kind of success the 49ers have had with Harbaugh. They would LOVE to have Prince York's problems.
Well, like it or not, Jed's problems have become our problem if we enjoy rooting for a top team.
I don't need to restate the reasons most fans think this is a real mess,but thinking that a D-line coach with no experience as even a coordinator can put together a staff as good as the ONE THEY JUST FIRED ..........
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:58 PM
-
Lucky Phil
For those of you bashing Jeff, give him a break. He wants what we all want a Super Bowl. He supported a coaching change because he believed Baalke & York would bring a OC with experience and creativity in the passing game. We didn't get that and to make matters even worse, we negotiated a "mutual separation" with Fangio. York is great at getting coaches to leave (He doesn't want to pay). So let this be clear York decided to dump his entire coaching staff because they were making far more than he wanted to pay. We hired Tomsula who will work for peanuts compared to what JH was being paid and Fangio and his 2 mil a yr. contract, so long, goodbye. But this is why I'm upset, If York came out and said I'm a business man and I love money than winning, I would respect his honesty. I wouldn't like it but I would respect it. But whats worse than driving this franchise into the ground is treating the fans like dumb shits. That I will never forgive. I will always be a Niner fan, I can't live without a heart, but York won't get another nickle from me.
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:50 PM
-
Pete
Tell baalke that all victory is fleeting. If the niners aren't winning next year he is next to go!
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:49 PM
-
Webzone Commenter
Lol. Kaplan you make me laugh. You and your friends in the liberal mieda like Kamawaki couldn't wait to run Harbaugh out of town and now you bitch about the results. Get another team looser, go cry and become a steelers fan. WE don't want bandwagon fans like you anyway. You told us to trust Ballke and now he's hired Jim Tomslua and we have to trust him and see how this is going to turn out. There are three reasons why you don't like Tomlusa: (1) he wants to run and you don't understand that running is what wins games in the NFL because you never played football, (2) he used to live in his car and you liberal elites can't stomache that; (3) he looks like Ron Jeremy. Well I"m here to tell you that Ron Jeremy is a fine actor and an American legend no matter what you liberals think. Get over yourself whiny little baby. He's not here to win press conferances.
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:44 PM
-
Robert Bradsahw
Right on !!!!! Love everything you hit the nail on the head
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:26 PM
-
allen
So then leave and go find some team that won't break your heart. Good luck with that though, cause they all do at some point. You are the classic forty whiner. They got a new HC, haven't played a game yet, and your crying about how horrible the team is. Step back and look at what your saying. You whole rant is based off of nothing more than your butt hurt feelings. LOL. Get over yourself. The sun will come up tomorrow and the 9ers will take the field in the fall prepared to make another run at number 6. Every summer hope springs eternal for football fans. You can jump back on the bandwagon when things are going well, but please, don't bash what hasn't even happened yet (and probably won't)!
Jan 17, 2015 at 3:14 PM
-
The Reaper
I knew it! This, coming from the guy, who wrote the article: "Dear Webmaster, We Can Do Better."
No, we can't, Jeff. THAT'S why I didn't want to see Jim Harbaugh gone. Eat your words, Jeff.
...You reap what you sow.
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:46 PM
-
WTF
I feel bad for those ticket holders. The fans should show there discussed by not attending the home games. We the Fans are the consumer, we are part of the game.
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:37 PM
-
Montana1
Words not associated with Tomsula:
Genius
Smart
Not saying he's dumb.
Popular with the ownership? Yes.
Matt Millen
Back to me OCs every year, unless they're terrible.
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:35 PM
-
Donovan
So what Jimmy T can't talk in a presser...Harbaugh never could either. Now If we can at least get Shannahan, I'll be as happy as the players are.
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:32 PM
-
TorontoTom
Jeff, you do tend to overreact badly at times. However, I must admit that there's more than a kernel of truth in what you say. I don't think Jim Tomsula is the issue. By all reports, he is a grounded, well-respected, indeed beloved, man AND coach. I wish him well and will hope against hope that he is a rousing success. However, I agree that these Niners are different in kind than the Walsh/Siefert Niners and even the Niners of Harbaugh's first year or two. We were both better and smarter. We dazzled. I grew up watching not just Montana and Young, but also Tittle and Brodie. They dazzled with their artistry as well. Harbaugh brought the pride back, not only because he won but also because we were both tough and innovative. Somehow we lost that in the last two years of Harbaugh's time as coach. I'm not upset that we fired Harbaugh, because he was getting thoroughly outcoached and our offense was almost unwatchable. Both bad and boring. So, here's hoping that Coach Tomsula is able to attract a brilliant mind as an OC that will bring the excitement back. Jury's o
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:19 PM
-
JT
Baalke will be gone in 2 years. Jed York is a clueless, spoiled loser. If you claim to be a true Niners fan and really think Jim Tomsula was the best candidate for the job, then you deserve York! Last place in the NFC West for the next 5 years.
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:10 PM
-
DIsgruntled 50 year fan
THe yorks are losers and have proven the only thing they know is how to make losers out of winners. THEy screwed the faithful with a horrible stadium in a worse area and are the new laughingstocks of the NFL. Good riddance to the dip sheet dentist and his ignorant silver spoon twit son
Jan 17, 2015 at 2:00 PM
-
fortyninerglory
"My Niners are gone, permanently."
Bye, Jeff! Don't let the door hit your ass on the way out!
Jan 17, 2015 at 1:12 PM
-
Marcos Salazar
Jeff Kaplan should be ashamed of this piece of fiction u have thrown together to some how bash your own team I have one thing to say ...JEFF Kaplan leave your 49er stuff at the door on your way the faithful DO NOT need a loser like you WE stay faithful no matter the odds no matter what this game throws our way we stand together as 49er faithful and you Jeff Kaplan have just spit in the face of that I swear if I saw you wearing 49ers gear I would make you take it off your a sorry excuse of a fan take a hike and when we win the super bowl I better not hear a word from you you disloyal piece of trash
Jan 17, 2015 at 1:08 PM
-
zach amen
supporter for 25 years but 49ers is dead now. lets offer prayers and hope that Dork sell this team to someone like Eddie DeBartolo.
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:50 PM
-
zach ameen
There is no chance that 49ers going to be better than 8-8 next year or years after that. Dork, Baalki, doomed 3 years of doomed drafts and now every loser coach from entire NFL will sink the 49ers ship. I wouldn't be surprised if Dork let go of players like Lupati and replace them with 1 million per year player or undrafted players. everything is getting cheaper from the owner to the last player
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:45 PM
-
Alex Narcise
I read this article several times bc it hit to the core of my following of this team for all my life. Power hungry guys looking for a "boss" man. You heard the press conf jt calling these guys boss. Jt probably a great guy but can't be a leader with marbles in your mouth. Let's hope it works. Jersey 9ers fan est 1980.
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:44 PM
-
andre
Jeff, you are absolutely right I have been a proud ninerfaithful since 1981 from (Louisiana) you no how hard that is. I was embarrassed last week when we hired JT so angry I couldn't sleep...every year me and my family attends a game in California but not this year...simply because I feel like York and Ballke could care less how we feel as fans...offense has been the problem for years yet they choose to ignore. So no more food out my kids mouth..I'm keeping my money until we get serious about winning again....
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:30 PM
-
audick
Those of you who accuse Jeff of being pessimistic: it's all in the title: MY niners are dead. He is not writing about just making the playoffs, but about a lineage that has been BROKEN. Teams have identities for their fans. Our identity under Baalke is "smashmouth."
That is not the identity of this franchise. We were wrongly accused of being a finesse team back in the day because we were so much SMARTER than anyone else.
We had style, flare.
We had cool.
We were elegant.
We were, yes, ARROGANT!
Above it all.
Now we want to "pound the rock". That's not the red and gold I can identify with. That's the Chicago Bears and all those other neanderthals.
THESE ARE NOT MY NINERS.
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:23 PM
-
Puro Niner
Seriously... Over reacting much? You sound like a kid crying because Stone Cold Steve Austin threw up the middle fingers to the WWE and straight walked off into retirement. The NFL is rigged to a certain extent, doesn't matter who's at the helm. But dude seriously it's just a game, teams get good and bad... Drink a beer or take a shot, life goes on aside from football "entertainment".
Tomsula will be fine. NINERS will be fine, maybe even cheap tickets hahah
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:07 PM
-
Wizolman
so if they appoint Shanahan as OC is Jed a hero?
Jan 17, 2015 at 12:06 PM
-
Marco
I totally agree with you Jeff. Im not going to be sucker in to this horridness move and I'm with Shemp.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:58 AM
-
NinerF8ful
Dumb and Dumber, and the puppet... That's Baalke becos he is Dumb, that's York becos of Dumber decisions as he goes (he does not learn from his Mike and Mike era, does he?), and Tomsula as the Puppet in all the fallout. Wish Harbaugh and Fangio the best!!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:58 AM
-
Guy Marker
Every time I look at at every angle it makes me sick. Some body tell when did the GM President become the football coach. I'm sorry but the new Jim is nothing more then a yes man to Baalke, I have been a 49ers fan from the age of 8 and I am now 60. All my life the 49ers have been my team. I don't see another supper bowl for the 49ers for a long time maybe for every as long as the a York owns the 49ers. All I have to say about Baalke are you kidding me, a blind man could see through all this BS and that is what it all about Baalke BS. I'm done with the 49ers as long as Baalke and the York's run the team. I'm go back to Collage Football. I sick of the media and the Baalke and Jed loss lips leaks to the media. This last year was a total and complete set up and now look at what we got. A yes man coach. Great guy good teacher not a head coach. this will be one or two year loss and then what are you going to do. Watch and see who fills in as the ast. coaches. This party is over.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:53 AM
-
Terry B
Folks, this is how bad it's gotten. Mbniner below compares Tomsula to Pete Carroll. If that doesn't show how pathetic and ignorant 49ers apologists are, what does? York and Baalke fire coaches like Harbaugh and Fangio and hire coaches like Singletary and Tomsula, and 80% of the fans on sites like this make excuses for them. The whole country is laughing at us, but the moron fans don't notice or care. Fans get the coach they deserve; 49ers fans deserve JT. Jed asks us to bend over, and we ask how wide we should spread our cheeks.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:52 AM
-
chantos
Jeff, what are you going to write when Jim Tomsula makes the playoffs next year? I was not and I am still not convinced with Tomsula either, but come on, going from there to saying the Niners are dead is waaaaay too much... I think this team has the talent, and will have the motivation to make the playoffs next year. For starters, It is likely Gore and Smith are back next year after Tomsula's hiring... that would speak volumes of this guy's leadership.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:52 AM
-
Tom
Jeez, it's just a game. Get over yourself
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:50 AM
-
REB4
The only fair question without attacking a nice guy like Tomsula is, "Did the team get better?" And that question is a big, resounding NO!!!! Nothing in Tomsula's resume points at him being better in anything as a Head Coach then Harbaugh. NOTHING!! That's not being negative, that's looking at the facts. Someone please point at ANYTHING in his vast experience as a head coach that says he's better then Harbaugh? So you fanboys need to put your money where your mouth is if you are going to disparage the other fans that have lost faith in this FO. We have facts on our side, do you?
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:44 AM
-
Paul B
My sentiments exactly with regard to York, Baalke, and this train-wreck of a hire. Lets start getting used to the fact that this I-dont-wear-a-tshirt-under-my-jacket neanderthal will be roaming the sideline for the next year (or two?).
Perhaps Im still bitter about the Harbaugh firing, but I think some of your attitudes toward Harbaugh and his offense are a bit misplaced. Your entire argument presupposes that the west coast offense - and only the west coast offense - is the be all, end all. That just isn't true. Did harbaugh run walsh's offense? Other than some of his concepts, no. But not a lot of offenses, in todays NFL, do. To suggest Shanahan would bring back 1994 production under 2015 NFL conditions with Kaeps skillset and personnel is ridiculous.
Also, the notion harbaugh - or even roman, for that matter - isn't a teacher doesn't seem to bear with reality. Alex smith raved about his development those last few years, as has Luck and his predecessors. Sure, the offense didnt develop as we all hoped, but thats a product of a number of moving variables and functions, not just harbaughs alleged teaching shortcomings. Enough with that manufactured narrative.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:43 AM
-
Gene18
Don't worry God is too.
Jesus said the end would come in his day, Chicken Little said the sky would fall. Now a mere mortal, Jeff Kaplan, proclaims " . . . he most admired franchise in all of sports is now a certified laughingstock, as it will be for years to come."
Makes one wonder who gets to certify laughingstocks.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:37 AM
-
Wizolman
This is hilarious. So-called fans are crying in their beer while the players are ecstatic and can't wait to play for someone who makes it about the TEAM and not his own egotistical and immature self. Thankfully, it will be the players who play the game and all the hypocrites posting here will conveniently forget what they said...
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:26 AM
-
CA4949
At the end of the day everyone has a choice. Be a loyal fan or adopt another team. Vince Lombardi's only head coaching experience was at St. Cecilia High School, following a couple assistant jobs prior to becoming the head coach of the Green Bay Packers, where he won the 1st 2 super bowls and the only coach to win 3 straight NFL championships. You do not have head coach experience until you get a head coaching job! Seifert proved this can be done. Jed just built a new stadium does it really make sense to put a losing team on the field? We can all hope Jed has learned from the Nolan/Singletary experience. These men know more than any of us, if your a true fan, you have to believe they know something we don't. Finally, did you ever watch a Harbaugh interview/press conference?
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:09 AM
-
Montana1
The Great Ripoff:
Folks, let's be clear that the terms "Faithfull" and "Authentic Fan" are terms propagated by a corporation to keep you mortgaging your children's future to pay for PSLs and season tickets. These badges of "honor" are for suckers. I've been a 49ers enthusiast (ni, a fanatic is also a suckers badge) all my life, but there has to be a point where we say, "NO!." There is nothing about Tomsula, who is above guy, that screams "class," or "genus." So stop with the corporat mantra of "faithful," because you sound like suckers. Pay for the product when it's good, criticize it when it's bad. I can imagine in my wildest dreams how this could possibly go well. Brains win football games this days....
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:09 AM
-
Eric S
I think you just proved why your not a coach just one who writes about them. Jimmy T's players will run threw a brick wall for him and that's more powerful then a word smith at any press conference. From one born and raised 9er fan to another I know the water looks merky rite now but don't be so quick to jump ship.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:06 AM
-
RR
Dude, chill out. I mean, it's professional sports ... this happens. "your Niners" ... what are you talking about? This isn't your team, or anyone elses. It's a damn business, and if you're going to tie all this emotion to a business that really doesn't give two bleeps about you, or anyone else ... you probably shouldn't be watching sports, let alone writing about it.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:04 AM
-
Frank
Jeff...waaay too much drama. I've been a Niner faithful since 1957 and I'm sure not giving up on this team. You're beginning to sound like some other doomsday Bay Area sportswriters...don't go down that road. Coach Tomsula will be fine...give the man a chance. The players love him and that's half the battle. Baalke will supplement an already strong roster with a heckuva draft. Jed's still young and has a lot to learn. Again, don't be a doomsday writer...you're better than that.
Jan 17, 2015 at 11:02 AM
-
Brian M
First of all we are all Niner faithful otherwise we wouldn't be here checking for updates and feeling very strong emotions due to the chain of events. I bleed for the Niners and have been so since 78' when OJ came to town. ( ugh ). Bottom line, not since the Dorks fired Mariucci after our NFC play off loss have I felt this uncertain about their judgement or lack their of. But this is worse, this is deception and the Doeks discount the devotion and intelligence of their fan base. Ericsson, Nolan and Singletary were rough. Jimmy Rae, rough. Mike Rump, rough. They were all rough but understandable. This is feels underhanded. All we can do is ride it out. In my bones I know there is more to the story. Vic with Kyle was a no brainer. Wtf? Something is up. Losing Ed? Wtf? Seriously?? Jed please, sell the team. You are no Ed and you are certainly no Paul Allen. Congrats, you screwed us all! That includes your players limited careers. You don't even get. Will someone please get some local financing and buy the Niners!! Someone out there right the ship!
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:56 AM
-
Erec
'K bye. Have fun being a Steelers fan again, I guess. Or maybe you can write a letter to all 32 teams (31 I guess since you're done with my Niners) asking them who you should root for now.
Tomsula is a guy who loves the game. Been coaching his entire adult life. Worked multiple jobs SO that he could coach. Crafted one of the best D-lines ever. Absolutely beloved by his players. Been a head coach. Great character guy.
But I guess none of that matters to you. He's not an arrogant prick. And we equate arrogance, and a total lack of social decorum, with merit. Well I don't. I want to see a guy like this win. I want to see a GAME be made fun for the players. That's what Tomsula will do. I'm fired up. This is MY 49ers coach and I can't wait to see how we play next year.
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:53 AM
-
Kauaiguy
As much as some don't want to admit, the main man behind the scene is John York. I'm sure that there is a limitation on what Jed York can spend.
His ultimate goal is to make money, and no matter how displeased the fans maybe ... the majority of them WILL keep coming.
Let's face it, the York's don't know diddly squat about football and it's operations. So ANYONE with experience (Baalke) can impress the heck out of them.
Baalke pretty much writes his own ticket and Jed York is just along for the ride. But eventually, all good things comes to an end ...!
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:50 AM
-
Biz
It doesn't look pretty but I'm faithful. I've went through dark times with my other teams as well: SF Giants and the Warriors. i've been faithful with them and now I'm reaping the benefits. 49ers, Giants and Warriors for life. REGARDLESS
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:36 AM
-
AyeJayVee
I have never met Tomsula so i have no idea what kind of a man he is. Is he a "yes" man? What is a "yes" man? Would you go up to him and talk all the crap some people on these boards and forums say about him to his face? I'm willing to bet most wont and if you won't say it to his face what kind of "man" are you. This has a lot to do with what kind of a football coach he is, period. He has proven to be a pretty good coach over the years so let's let him prove it first before we right long articles like a high school girl that got dumped by her boyfriend before she commits suicide. And, if "your" 49ers are dead then GTFO
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:35 AM
-
ac
@fd...really, who do you think ran that offense, Adam or Manning? Are you really that dumb, what did he do before Manning...MORON!!!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:35 AM
-
MrU5h3r
This article describes my viewpoint throughout this clusterf* pretty well. I have been the antithesis of fair weather fan my entire life. Corporate greed is eating into that mentality pretty quickly however.
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:31 AM
-
mbniner
I too grew up with the Niners. My first game was their first game in 1946! They were in the old All American Football Conference. This is not the disaster that many are panicking over. I remember another motivating coach who was not noted for x's and O's named Jimmy Johnson who was very successful. He surrounded himself with talented coaches and players. Tomsula has the leadership qualities you want and he knows defense very well. A current coach with similar strengths is Pete Carroll. The player talent is there. Let's wait to see who is chosen to fill the coaching staff and then maybe things will be looked at in a more favorable light. Tomsula will not win media presentation awards but that shouldn't matter to anyone except our local "journalists".
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:23 AM
-
Kauaiguy
I've said all along that this NEW coaching search was just to make fans feel good that the 49er's were really looking for someone good, when indeed they already had someone in mind.
Having worked in a large corporation for umpteen of years, I seen this happen time and time again. They just go through the motions to more or less satisfy some rules.
I've also said this: Baalke DOESN'T want ANYONE to have control of anything (job security?), Any good candidates who would want more control of players and other coaches would be out. So now I rest my case.
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:19 AM
-
sportman9
People he is just expressing his feelings. Man your overreacting commenters.. I remember York saying that we can hold him accountable for the future, maybe if this does not pan out, we can call for the head of Baalke which is the reason that Harbaugh left.. I am sure that it was just another empty gesture by York!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:17 AM
-
Dexter
I appreciate the true believers. Baalke & York want you to continue to drink the koolaid.
Tomsula may make a fine coach someday, but he is not a top five coach like the one they kicked out the door.
I expect the Niners will see a worse record next year, and the true believers will wait for the next season, then the season after "for sure."
Keep drinking the koolaid and make sure you buy season tickets--that's really all Baalke & York care about--football on the field not so much.
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:13 AM
-
Peter akers
This article reflects exactly how seasoned niners fans feel. I have watched football for the last 45 years and this by far was the worst move an owner can make.
You have successful coaches in house specifically on defense who were able to elevate it top 5 over the last 4 years, what do you do? You get rid of them. What logic prescribes this action is beyond comprehension.
Good coaches don't come around often and when they do good teams keep them and reward them, Jed and Trent will see to that niners lose for the next 5 years with these unreal idiotic moves.
A n intelligent coach does not simply make an ass of himself in front of national cameras.
A yes man does, players love him, oh well that's it Super Bowl here we come, forget about x and o's that stuff will take care of itself just like it did when singletery was the coach.
With Jed York my niners are dead, breaks my heart but it's the truth and have to live with it.
Wake me up when this nightmare is over.
Jan 17, 2015 at 10:00 AM
-
Matt
such a faithful fan!...... Not. I'm good with the hire the players love the guy and really?!?!? Dead?!?!? So we may have a couple bad seasons while they get things figured out or we could even go straight into another run for the Super Bowl. No one knows how it's going to turn out. That's the point real fans are always fans. We don't wine about moves made before we even know the outcome, we support our team and players when they are down, and at most we go e constructive criticism after failures but never before. Harbaughs time in San fran was done correction is done and I don't think it was a bad move at all. His staff is gone which who really wanted another season of Greg roman??? Dick being let go burns a bit but we still have the players that make our defense what it is. I should add that same defense completely backs our new HC. Those guys know what goes on behind closed doors more then any of us. So how about write positives about the team you claim to be a fan of or write nothing at all. The best thing about all that's going on with coaching changes would be how many bandwagon fans seem to be jumping off. Please stay off and don't come back when this team is winning.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:59 AM
-
Darrell
Jeff, we have similar beginnings with franchise fandom. My first game was the Saints comeback the year prior to "the catch", and I've seen every moment since from afar. I'm from the East Coast, and the only time I've ever seen the 49ers play live was the '94 Championship game. When Young and company jumped out 21 points early. A once in a lifetime experience along the backdrop of failing the first two tries to get past Dallas for the 5th ring.
I'm not ready to give up on them just yet, but I no longer have the delusion of a dynasty reborn from the ashes.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:59 AM
-
Nick
who cares!!!!....liked Harbaugh...but he's gone....GO NINERS!! Quest for Six!!!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:55 AM
-
Josh
How about you give the guy a chance before you label him a dumpster fire. People scrutinized hiring John Harbaugh and Mike Tomlin because of lack of experience, but they are both great coaches. I don't trust York anymore, but I do like Jim Tomsula. He doesn't have to be a great X's and O's guy, he just needs football knowledge, leadership, and motivation. You can hire great coordinators. In fact, reports are Shanahan may come on as OC
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:50 AM
-
Richard
The owner is like the owner of the Raiders he is now al Davis jr. I've been a 49ers fan since 1976 n he hires a coach that will not help kap. He is tearing this team up wat is he thinking? AL Davis like, Shannon should have been the coach. N not a defensive minded coach we needed offensive coach r defense was stout. N I been reading he Jim might change r defense to a 4, 3 how is that going to help our 4 stout line backers jed I mean al Davis jr wake up n don't destroy this team who is a great team please
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:49 AM
-
demarco2080
Is Jimmy Raye available to be our OC?
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:47 AM
-
cNiner
Well said. The York's are cheap ,Ballake is a yes man & HC.
Jim was his own man that's why he was let go. We are back to sing , Nolan days , weather you like it or not . Winning with class, it's a joke there is no such thing. Owners got us a duck and want us to believe its a stallion.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:36 AM
-
49ermike
@Rfern You really think, after watching the press conference, that we hired a motivational speaker? Have you ever heard a motivational speaker present? Maybe you're the one that doesn't get it.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:35 AM
-
Niner for life
Living in Seahawks country. I get more crap then most niner fans! So it makes me stronger and even more faithful to the red and gold! All I can say is bla, bla, bla! You sir are a fortywiner! That's right! Go Now! The seahags need you! With all your sorrys and apologies! Jesus it's football! All the rest of us faithfuls will man up and let them right the ship! Well bye!
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:33 AM
-
billb49
What a huge load of whiny panic. Here's a thought - let's see what happens before we pronounce the team "dead." They get back a bunch of pro bowl starters on defense next season and the offense can't get any worse - it's bound to get better. The team will be back in the playoffs next season and all these whiners will pretend they never had any question about that.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:32 AM
-
Michael
Good...LEAVE! Go root for another team because the 9ers don't want you Jeff 'Fairweather' Kaplan...GOOD RIDDANCE!
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:32 AM
-
49ermike
So "we're dead" before a single snap has been played or even a single TC session? "We're dead" based off of ONE press conference? Ok makes a whole lot of sense.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:26 AM
-
Rfern
Totally agreed, they wanted a puppet and they got it. And all these idiots saying that players love him! We need a head football coach not a motivational speaker, for f!?@:&!! Sake, does anybody get that?!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:24 AM
-
FD
@AC
SO when Denver's offense was rolling it was Manning, but when the lose it's Gase?
Seattle gained 30 pts off of 4 turnovers and a ST TD and Gase produced 2 3 in out's the WHOLE game! Give me a break
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:20 AM
-
Pete
I totally agree "we are dead" and we must learn accept the situation as it is. Don't be in denial. The 49ers are toast for about 3-4 years. We might as well shoot for 0-16 next season. I am not a bandwagon fan. I was born in SF and have lived with them in my heart for 50 years. I am embarrassed to be a fan after listening to this man being interviewed and him not being able to say anything intelligent or motivating. We must accept our situation. It wont be fun for several years.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:17 AM
-
ac
Why are all these MORONS infatuated with Adam Gase, did you see what he did a against the Dead hawks last super bowl, and yeah that was with arguably the best qb ever, WTF was he gonna do...please KINDLY EXPLAIN
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:11 AM
-
james mayberry
I understand how you feel, i understand that Tomsula isn't the flashy guy, but understand this...the players love this guy. He is a teacher. He's learned many facets of the game. The players play the game and they will play thier hearts out for this guy. I truly hope people just give him a chance and come Sunday watch and be amazed! But the more criticism he receives will just further fuel the fight and desire of the players to win for him because they believe in him and want to give him what he deserves thru all the hard work and dedication he has given them as thier teacher. I'm so pumped for this coming season! Jim nobody from nowhere will be Coach Tomsula of San Francisco. The man who brought the Lambardi back!
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:10 AM
-
NinerTico
Dude!!! It really hit you THAT hard huh? My deepest and sincerest condolence. Will you be wearing black for a year? Do you burn your 49er gear, at least the current stuff, you know, from when the Yorks owned the team?
I respect your feelings, they're oozin' w disdain, anger n hopelessness. Shame. Really. But, I have to let you know something... I was waiting for this from you. Not as doom and gloom, but something close. Your POV merits careful and considerable attention because I believe that most of our fan base feels the same way.
Still, it is only one POV and they're many along side that merit consideration as well. Mine? I am actually on the other side waving on my nice big boat of hope. Had it since my Dad was screaming at the box in 1971 hoping Dallas wouldn't come back. Hope brought me through 70's after that to be jubilant during the 80s n 90's while my resolve was tested in the 00's.
Then came Harbs like a white knight. I, again, was proven that hope has it's merits. Well, I'm back at it again, sippin' on my yummy glass of Margarita, listenin' to Jimmy Buffet n watchin' the sunset over my nice big boat of hope. Say hi, Jimmy T. My captain says hi
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:09 AM
-
49ermike
And this, my fellow diehards, is why we're referred to as the "Forty Whiners"
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:07 AM
-
PE
I love this "real fan" unconditional loyalty, Lmao! SOME (Not all) of these fans are cheating on their spouses, backstabbing their friends... But, Hey, I never walked out my Niners! It's funny, What we truly choose to be loyal to...
-Just a thought!
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:01 AM
-
Jerry
Just because we criticize these coaching decisions does not mean we aren't good football fans. It justs means we think the team is going in the wrong direction. I'm not worried about next year. Anything can happen but the future looks bleak when you view the decisions and comments made by mr. York. I hope I'm wrong because I am a true fan just like many who criticize York.
Jan 17, 2015 at 9:00 AM
-
alan earl
the owner that we have doesnt know the true meaning of faithful and championship, he is all for greed!! rest in peace my forty niners i will never see any superbowl with this ownership!!
i hope nobody will to his stadium so he will know our dissapointment!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:58 AM
-
YorkIsATool
Stating the obvious: Shanahan is too head strong for baalke/York to hire. He clashed w Washingtons ownership and will prob do the same here. However, he would be a perfect fit.
With that said, York is trying to be like Jerry Jones/ Al Davis. He really should leave the football decisions to the professionals he hires. He fires the winningest coach he's had in two decades because Harbaugh's [football winning] philosophy clashes with that of his and Baalke's?!?! Keep in mind, Baalke is the genius that wasted a first round draft pick on AJ Jenkins, and York is an owner that is so a tuned to football great minds and was responsible for the Singletary hiring, who didn't even have any coordinator experience prior to being a HC. We all know how that experiment went. This is déjà vu all over again.
The York-baalke duo will soon remember what it's like to have talent but not be able to utilize them (49er roster circa 2010.)
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:58 AM
-
Lulucaliente
Yes this column is 100% the absolute crystal clear truth.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:56 AM
-
Jake Longenecker
I still have hope. York wants a ring soon. How long do you think Baalke and jT have. I think after we go 4-12 and york learns coaching is important we will have a real coach next year.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:51 AM
-
Kyle Drake
Hmmm...Jason Garrett has been a yes man, but with the right talent in place, it seems they had a pretty damn good year.
I complain about some of the Niners moves and performances, and consider myself probably more critical than most. But this "Niners are Dead" article is a bit much.
Nobody knows how this next season will play out, so give the 8 year, player respected veteran a chance. Hounding even know the OC yet, or what their draft plans are. Baalke has done pretty well with the drafts under his tenure.
Harbaugh is not immune from taking some responsibility in how things played out in his departure, so Niner fans need to get the f--k over it, and accept moving on.
Everyone seems to think they know better on what coaches and moves should be made. Only this fall will we be able to tell. Too many EA "Head Coach" game players on here.
We have a healthier roster coming back this coming season, and while I dont have a crystal ball to tell you all how it will play out, I'm still going to be looking forward to seeing thisnteams New identity and watch them compete.
The only thing In know about the front office is that I'm very relieved none of you work in it.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:49 AM
-
9er4life or not
I'm trying to look at this with a "glass half full or empty". And I keep coming up with an empty glass, wondering who drank my water. I don't have an idea where the next 2 seasons is going to be like. But my hope was he (JT) would keep the defense staff intact. But no that didn't happen, (my glass is 1/4 full now). So then his press conference came and went, the interviews came and went. And in wondering does he have any idea he is a head coach. Because hid conversation in the press conference wee remedial at best. Then the interview his gritting stumbling can't form a thought into a sentence. So is this a joke, did I wake up to a bad dream? Is this the person that's suppose to lead us to a SB... This is Singletary all over again. He was asked what's your offensive philosophy? He answered "run the ball" sounds so familiar. And on top of it the puppet master had to clarify it what he said. I know championships are not with words but the play on the field. But I'm sorry "I've lost all confidence" in this ownership and management. Now my glass is empty, who drank all of my water?
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:44 AM
-
Matthew Crandall
You will eat your words when we win the Super Bowl this year. Tomsula is a great coach. Harbaugh wears out his welcome every 4 years, it was time to move on. You can't have the GM and the head coach on different pages. Baalke is a draft wizard, I support him 100%.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:39 AM
-
RishikeshA
I go back to the 50's and have seen some poor teams to say the least. In the darkest of times I'd watch every game till it was over and hope for one more score, one more first down even though we were being blown out. The Tomsula hire was a minor league move. To hire someone with no experience reeks of Dr. John York. Slowly but surely the curtain is being pulled aside and the true colors are showing. This move is all about money, saving 10's of millions. Maybe the team is going to be sold, why go down the dark path? As a die hard fan I'll go through this and hope we come out of it sooner rather than later.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:39 AM
-
Alister
Enough with all this sky is falling melodrama. It's pathetic! I survived the post-Mariucci era, and we'll survive this. It's far too soon to count of JT; for God's sake, at least let the man coach one game before we decide our franchise is dead! Jed is an impatient man, so if this doesn't work, he will fire Baalke and Tomsula in two short years. We are called the Faithful for a reason. If you run for hills in this moment, then it all meant nothing to you up to now.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:38 AM
-
FILTHpig
This might be one of the most defeatist, pathetic, embarrassing "articles" I've ever read about the 49ers in my life. You should be ashamed. Really, you actually think we're worse off now than the John York/Nolan years? If you've truly lost hope then this should be the last thing you ever write about the Niners. Thank goodness. We'll all be better off for it.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:36 AM
-
Terry Helms
Being a puppet HC, doesn't have to be bad. If the puppet hires great coaches underneath him.
But, the front office can not win games. They need to let him live or die by his decisions. Only time will tell if this was the right decision and we will know sooner than later too.
I will give the puppet HC a chance. All be it a short one.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:34 AM
-
Richard
Jerry, I Had Planned On Adding A Good Script For The Team I've Cheered For For 46 Years Only I Don't Feel I Need To. Your View On This Mess York And I Will Also Add Balke Have Created Was Explained 100% On The Dot!! Until They Let The Coach Run The Show We Are Going To Look Identical Like The Raiders! That Is An Assumption And Hopefully Making This Assumption Will Be Totally Opposite Cause I Will Be Happy To Have Made An "ASS" Out Of Myself By Being Wrong!! God Bless You 49ers, You Need Every Prayer You Can Receive!!
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:31 AM
-
ryan
There is a difference from being a faithful fan & being a homer, if you aren't concerned about the direction of the franchise than you are a total homer & yes man just the type of GM Coach & fans York wants.
You want points?? The 49ers just fired a HC that had one of the highest win percentages among active coaches, we also just fired a DC that had the 49ers defense in the top 5 4 years running. The team & defense especially will be taking a step back next year.
Then the 49ers go & hire a HC with no experience to speak of as a coordinator, purely because hes well liked amongst the Organization & players. Then these homers will tell you "You don't know Tomsula isn't going to work out" well yes actually I do. The 49ers have gone down this road once before with Singletary, a well liked figure with very little coaching experience. The results speak for themselves & history really does repeat itself. Get ready for 4 years of being 7-9/ 8-8 & not making the playoffs.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:30 AM
-
lalo
Jeff, I just don't get it, why is having a "puppet" is good for the front office? IF we were talking about government and power then it will make sense, people in government love dummies to move around and make money out of it. In sports what is the benefit of that? There is no money out of it, unless you consider his low salary. Baalke´s Job is to set up the best roster and Tomsula´s is to coach them and WIN. Why will Baalke want a complete control on personnel decisions? Doesn´t this increase the amount of pressure for him? Having someone to consult, share ideas and most importantly share blame will be more logical? .... I don't know maybe i am not getting the right angle in "The Front Office wants a Puppet".
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:25 AM
-
daniners
Good, leave. Bandwagon fans not welcome!
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:22 AM
-
Bill
Kaplan showed his colors in the first couple of paragraphs. The part where he "left the room" because he "just couldn't bear to watch?" He's got his head stuck in the sand again. He believes the 49ers made a foolish error. And they might have done just that. But -- see Kaplan -- I'm a real fan. I'm not going to "leave the room." I'm not going to stick my head in the sand. I'm going to continue to be a fan and follow this team. Will they win? Will they suck? We'll find out in September, now won't we. Now, do us a favor, leave the room and don't come back. We won't miss you. We won't call you back downstairs.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:19 AM
-
Exninerfan1652
Bunch of typos on my first send: The issue isn't Tomsula, it's a front office that thinks they can run the team. Balke will be gone in two years , maybe even one after we go 4-12 this year. Jed will apologize and we will all be praying he sells the team. We have a bunch of idiots running the Niners. I am also embarrassed to be a Niners fan.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:19 AM
-
Exninerfan1652
The issue isn't Tomsula, it's a front office that thinks they can run the team.
Balke will be great be in two years , maybe even one after we go 4-12 this year. Jed will apologize and we will all be praying he sells the team.
We have a hynde of idiots running the Niners. I am also embarrassed to be a Niners fan.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:16 AM
-
Jerry
We are definitely in for some hard times. Not because they hired Tomsula and not because Baalke is he GM, but because York is the owner. He is a young man with limited life experiences. You don't learn things so much from your successes as you do from your failures and it is hard to have failures when born with a silver spoon. A smart owner would hire the very best football person he could find to run the organization and then step back and enjoy what is built. I don't think it matters if that is the GM or the coach, but that person has to be in charge. You let that person build the organization. Owners who get overly involved are destined to failure because they are not experts in football. Ownership is the critical part here. Owners who leave the management up to the experts are the most successful in the long run. Look at the Packers. The owners are the fans. They have a solid management structure and run the organization for the long haul. They know that no team can win the super bowl every year and there will always be down periods because you have 32 competitors. My only hope for the future is that York grows up and realizes he is not qualified to run the football side.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:14 AM
-
Terry B.
On sports radio in Chicago yesterday, they spent the entire afternoon replaying parts of Tomsula's press conference and laughing about it. The 49ers are being laughed at by the rest of the country. Tomsula may be a good DL coach, but he would have been kept on staff anyway. To make this man the face of the franchise shows such an utter lack of judgment and common sense, that there are no words to describe it. I notice that the homers here have nothing to offer but "give him a chance." Pathetic.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:12 AM
-
Niner
Funny how people have such pitiful memories. In the kezar days people said the moribito brothers couldn't financially compete. Mr d buys the team and Eddie d hires coaches until Bill walsh cones along because " he hates to lose". Then the yorks come who fire our last 3 playoff coaches. They say right out the 49ers are a business gut the team and the owner admits she likes soccer more than football. After 8 years of humiliation, they turn from first time d clowns to a hc who brings back the playoffs. ( see alex smith under nolan sing vs Harbaugh reid) now they go on the cheap and do it all over again. Good grief they hire this kiss butt and he has no idea what offense he is bringing in.how do they fix kaep, tell him to lift more weights? ( remember nolan and sinfg instead od mcarthy or carrol?) Shanahan means we keep fangio, but Montana young jones the fans don't mean sheet to the yorks. In 2 years the Warriors became a contending team after the miserable Cohan and Rowell left. Honestly I think they were smarter than the 49er ownership.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:11 AM
-
wonderboy
you have nailed it......your words are straight to the heart of this dirty deed... how can Jed and Trent actually think that Jimmy T will bring them anything but millions of extra dollars that will be given to them from disheartened loyal fans.
Oh that is their master plan make money first then maybe win with class or is it, WIN WITH THE DUMBASS
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:10 AM
-
Wizolman
Poor Jeff. Grow a pair. Crybaby. You are now the laughingstock. When JT brings in either Chud or Shanahan, puts a Super Bowl quality defense on the field and is still in the playoffs next season, you can enjoy a huge bowl of CROW SOUP. Grow up. John Harbaugh was never a coordinator and how has he done? Don't want a DL coach as HC? Buck Shaw, the first coach in Niner history, was a former DT for Knute Rockne at Notre Dame. He also put the greatest offensive teams in 49er history on the field and introduced the T-formation to pro football. You guys call Tomsula a "yes man". What's wrong with a smooth running front office and a team concept that runs throughout the organization. Tomsula is a tough Italian who understands the meaning of "family" and "team". He will be one of the great coaches in Niner history...
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:10 AM
-
Heath
This article should have never been on the headline. There is nothing but assumptions and unjustified opinions. I agree with many other posts I read. Fans like this can all leave and I'd be much happier for it. They give the real fans a bad name.
Jan 17, 2015 at 8:06 AM
-
funk U
tang ina nyo lahat!! gago!
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:58 AM
-
Terry B.
If the posters such as Derek, Garry, and Graham will apologize for this, what won't they apologize for? How low are we willing to go? Pathetic.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:55 AM
-
Faithful
You make good points. However, just like your childhood self, you're going to miss greatness while you're upstairs giving up too soon!
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:54 AM
-
Terry B.
Shemp, they hired a motivational speaker? Please tell me you're joking. Click the link above, or watch the press conference. Are you motivated? As a motivational speaker, Tomsula is an even worse choice than as a head coach.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:52 AM
-
Garry
This worse than the crap Grant Cohn and Tim K write. If "Your" niners are gone don't let the door hit you on the way out. I canot believe this is the head line piece on the front page. This site has officially become a certified laughingstock.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:52 AM
-
Donald
Man....I know the press conference was not good. But as a Niners fan you have no choice but to give this a shot.
My list of candidates was Shanahan, Fangio, Hue Jackson and Gus Malzahn. Jim Tomsula was not even at the bottom of the list. But there must be something there. Because Tomsula gets a ringing endorsement from every non fan and media personality.....Including every player in the building
Why is that? Only time will tell. I'm a Niners fan first, last and always. I have no choice to give Coach Tomsula a fair chance.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:51 AM
-
NinerF8ful
Thanks for writing the article. True to the core about Jed York and Baalke. They were handed the positions, did not earn it. Kids with a new toy, dont know what to do with it. Like you said, they want puppets, and Harbaugh wasnt.
Best thing ever happened under York... Hiring of Harbaugh.
Worst thing ever under York... Firing of Harbaugh
As a Niner fan, i am disappointed in the whole organization.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:50 AM
-
Jeff
???? so true...at least Nolan started from ground zero and Singletary offered one of the greatest defensive players of all time. Smaller pills to swallow. Sucks
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:49 AM
-
Derek
Really man? I know nobody wanted to hire from within, but to not even wait to see who the guy hires as coordinators before going chicken little is weak. Maybe this is why other fanbases call us fortywhiners.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:47 AM
-
Graham
Another rush to judgement, another poster who can't be bothered to wait to see how it turns out.
So "your Niners are gone permanently". Really? Your hope is gone for good? Shut the door on your way out then.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:47 AM
-
Shemp
All leaders in history have been hard to work with. Steve Jobs was an ass. Andy Grove used to stomp his feet on tables during meetings and throw staplers. Bill Parcells, Bill Walsh, Lombardi, Cowher, all are difficult to work with, and aren't looking for the players to be their friends. But these people win in whatever they do.
The 49ers have decided that peace and harmony is more important. We have once again hired a motivational speaker (Singletary part 2) as a head coach, in the hopes that inspiration alone is what is going to get us to the next level.
I've yet to read one article stating how good Tomsula is at game planning. Or at strategizing. Or at attacking an opponents weaknesses. Or at leading staff members of an organization. Or anything. All we know is everybody loves him. We now have a cheerleader for a HC, and that is a recipe for disaster.
The good news is, we will have great draft picks for the next 3 years, and the new coach that comes in around then will be the beneficiary.
Jan 17, 2015 at 7:45 AM