Smith or Mcnabb? | Page 2 | 49ers Webzone Forum

Nov 25, 2009 at 2:59 PM

RonMexico
Moderator
Posts: 76,623
NFL Pick 'em

Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by Hollywood49er:
Smith is not a bad play.

McNabb is going vs Wash Def, believe it or not but Wash. ranks #1 in pass defense.

McNabb has a history of stuggling vs the Redskins he has only thrown 2 TDS vs the Redskins the last 4 Games.

Smith might be money in garbage time again....Im just saying.....

Thank you, obviously someone else here knows football and not just names Nice stat on the last 4 games though. I am going to start Alex, thanks

Lots of people know football here and anyone who knows football understands Alex Smith is capable of giving u 5 points against any defense. The redskins offense is so bad they will not move the ball and McNabb will have a lot of scoring opportunities.

Obviously someone here needs to wake up.

Nov 25, 2009 at 4:21 PM

#17

MadMartz
Member
Posts: 3,319

Originally posted by RonMexico:
Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by Hollywood49er:
Smith is not a bad play.

McNabb is going vs Wash Def, believe it or not but Wash. ranks #1 in pass defense.

McNabb has a history of stuggling vs the Redskins he has only thrown 2 TDS vs the Redskins the last 4 Games.

Smith might be money in garbage time again....Im just saying.....

Thank you, obviously someone else here knows football and not just names Nice stat on the last 4 games though. I am going to start Alex, thanks

Lots of people know football here and anyone who knows football understands Alex Smith is capable of giving u 5 points against any defense. The redskins offense is so bad they will not move the ball and McNabb will have a lot of scoring opportunities.

Obviously someone here needs to wake up.

Since Alex took over he has 91 fan points. Mcnabb has 111 in 2 extra qrts. Its a lot closer then you might think. Fantasy is a number game. Not the name game. Smith will out score Mcnabb this week. Just like he has done 3 of the past 5 weeks. Clearly someone hasnt been doing their homework.

Nov 25, 2009 at 5:02 PM

#18

AllTimeGreat
Veteran
Posts: 19,094

Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by RonMexico:
Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by Hollywood49er:
Smith is not a bad play.

McNabb is going vs Wash Def, believe it or not but Wash. ranks #1 in pass defense.

McNabb has a history of stuggling vs the Redskins he has only thrown 2 TDS vs the Redskins the last 4 Games.

Smith might be money in garbage time again....Im just saying.....

Thank you, obviously someone else here knows football and not just names Nice stat on the last 4 games though. I am going to start Alex, thanks

Lots of people know football here and anyone who knows football understands Alex Smith is capable of giving u 5 points against any defense. The redskins offense is so bad they will not move the ball and McNabb will have a lot of scoring opportunities.

Obviously someone here needs to wake up.

Since Alex took over he has 91 fan points. Mcnabb has 111 in 2 extra qrts. Its a lot closer then you might think. Fantasy is a number game. Not the name game. Smith will out score Mcnabb this week. Just like he has done 3 of the past 5 weeks. Clearly someone hasnt been doing their homework.

you seem pretty sure about starting Alex. Why create a thread about it then?

Nov 25, 2009 at 5:07 PM

#19

MadMartz
Member
Posts: 3,319

Originally posted by AllTimeGreat:
Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by RonMexico:
Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by Hollywood49er:
Smith is not a bad play.

McNabb is going vs Wash Def, believe it or not but Wash. ranks #1 in pass defense.

McNabb has a history of stuggling vs the Redskins he has only thrown 2 TDS vs the Redskins the last 4 Games.

Smith might be money in garbage time again....Im just saying.....

Thank you, obviously someone else here knows football and not just names Nice stat on the last 4 games though. I am going to start Alex, thanks

Lots of people know football here and anyone who knows football understands Alex Smith is capable of giving u 5 points against any defense. The redskins offense is so bad they will not move the ball and McNabb will have a lot of scoring opportunities.

Obviously someone here needs to wake up.

Since Alex took over he has 91 fan points. Mcnabb has 111 in 2 extra qrts. Its a lot closer then you might think. Fantasy is a number game. Not the name game. Smith will out score Mcnabb this week. Just like he has done 3 of the past 5 weeks. Clearly someone hasnt been doing their homework.

you seem pretty sure about starting Alex. Why create a thread about it then?

Hollywood49er made up my mind for me.

Nov 25, 2009 at 7:47 PM

#20

RonMexico
Moderator
Posts: 76,623
NFL Pick 'em

Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by RonMexico:
Originally posted by MadMartz:
Originally posted by Hollywood49er:
Smith is not a bad play.

McNabb is going vs Wash Def, believe it or not but Wash. ranks #1 in pass defense.

McNabb has a history of stuggling vs the Redskins he has only thrown 2 TDS vs the Redskins the last 4 Games.

Smith might be money in garbage time again....Im just saying.....

Thank you, obviously someone else here knows football and not just names Nice stat on the last 4 games though. I am going to start Alex, thanks

Lots of people know football here and anyone who knows football understands Alex Smith is capable of giving u 5 points against any defense. The redskins offense is so bad they will not move the ball and McNabb will have a lot of scoring opportunities.

Obviously someone here needs to wake up.

Since Alex took over he has 91 fan points. Mcnabb has 111 in 2 extra qrts. Its a lot closer then you might think. Fantasy is a number game. Not the name game. Smith will out score Mcnabb this week. Just like he has done 3 of the past 5 weeks. Clearly someone hasnt been doing their homework.

Yes fantasy is a number game and you have alex on your team cause he is a 49er

you are asking this question because you are a 49ers fan

ANYONE who is not a 49ers fan would say start mcnabb it is a lot safer of a choice

btw, I hope alex does have an amazing game but to me the obvious fantasy choice is mcnabb

[ Edited by RonMexico on Nov 25, 2009 at 7:49 PM ]

Nov 25, 2009 at 8:00 PM

#21

crzy
Hall of Fame
Posts: 40,285

We had a similar thread before Alex Smith played the Titans, who btw were the 32nd ranked passing defense until Alex Smith faced them.

Nov 25, 2009 at 8:34 PM

#22

vrabbit
Veteran
Posts: 35,953

Originally posted by crzy:
We had a similar thread before Alex Smith played the Titans, who btw were the 32nd ranked passing defense until Alex Smith faced them.

you mean the same week he had 19pts in standard leagues? as many as .... hold on .... wait ... yeah, Matt Schaub?

you fail

Nov 25, 2009 at 8:36 PM

#23

vrabbit
Veteran
Posts: 35,953

Originally posted by Conejo:
Originally posted by crzy:
We had a similar thread before Alex Smith played the Titans, who btw were the 32nd ranked passing defense until Alex Smith faced them.

you mean the same week he had 19pts in standard leagues? as many as .... hold on .... wait ... yeah, Matt Schaub?

you fail

oh and while we're comparing him to Matty ...

this last week

Schaub: 25pts
Smith: 26pts

Now would you say Schaub is more of a sure pick at QB than McNabb?

Nov 25, 2009 at 11:16 PM

#24

crzy
Hall of Fame
Posts: 40,285

Originally posted by Conejo:
Originally posted by crzy:
We had a similar thread before Alex Smith played the Titans, who btw were the 32nd ranked passing defense until Alex Smith faced them.

you mean the same week he had 19pts in standard leagues? as many as .... hold on .... wait ... yeah, Matt Schaub?

you fail

Alex Smith had 19 pts against the Titans in your fantasy league. What kind of ridiculous settings does your league have?

Nov 25, 2009 at 11:18 PM

#25

crzy
Hall of Fame
Posts: 40,285

Smith 286 yards, 2 touchdowns, 3 INTs, 2 fumbles = 12 points against the Titans in a standard league.

Nov 26, 2009 at 12:33 AM

#26

toeknee
Veteran
Posts: 54,571

go with smith!

Nov 26, 2009 at 8:15 AM

#27

vrabbit
Veteran
Posts: 35,953

Originally posted by crzy:
Smith 286 yards, 2 touchdowns, 3 INTs, 2 fumbles = 12 points against the Titans in a standard league.

25 passing yards = 1pt
TD = 6pts
INT -1pt
Fumbles LOST = -2
10 rushing yards = 1pt

286 yards = 11pts
2 TD= 12pts
3 INT = -3pts
1 fumble lost = -2pts
11 rushing yards = 1pt

11+12-3-2-1= 19pts

Nov 26, 2009 at 9:12 AM

#28

crzy
Hall of Fame
Posts: 40,285

ESPN Standard Leagues
Passing Yards 25 per point = 11 points
Passing TDs 4 per point = 8 points
Passing INT -2 per point = -6 points
Fumbles Lost -2 per point = -2 points
Rushing Yards 10 per point = 1 point

12 points on ESPN Standard

Yahoo Standard Leagues
Passing Yards 25 per point = 11 points
Passing TDs 4 per point = 8 points
Passing INT -1 per point = -3 points
Fumbles Lost -2 per point = -2 point
Rushing Yards 10 per point = 1 point

15 points on Yahoo Standard

Nov 26, 2009 at 11:43 AM

#29

MadMartz
Member
Posts: 3,319

This might come as a surprise, but the Jaguars generate little pass rush (they have a league-low 10 sacks), Smith should get a lot of time this week.

Nov 26, 2009 at 7:51 PM

#30

vrabbit
Veteran
Posts: 35,953

Originally posted by crzy:
ESPN Standard Leagues
Passing Yards 25 per point = 11 points
Passing TDs 4 per point = 8 points
Passing INT -2 per point = -6 points
Fumbles Lost -2 per point = -2 points
Rushing Yards 10 per point = 1 point

12 points on ESPN Standard

Schaub: 14pts

Yahoo Standard Leagues
Passing Yards 25 per point = 11 points
Passing TDs 4 per point = 8 points
Passing INT -1 per point = -3 points
Fumbles Lost -2 per point = -2 point
Rushing Yards 10 per point = 1 point

15 points on Yahoo Standard

Schaub: 16pts

go on