Jimmy Garoppolo-QB-EIU

Originally posted by susweel:

This pipsqueak won't last half a season.

Originally posted by WRATHman44:

Originally posted by tjd808185:
NE seems to be preparing to trade JG. When they activated Brissett from IR just so he could a few weeks more practice that's a pretty good sign what their intentions.

If the Rams hire Josh we've already seen him try to bring in Cassel opposed to working with the previous coach's pick. I guess Goff could be available but would they trade him in division?

I agree. Brissett wouldn't be the next guy to go into a game this year, so his extra work must be geared toward next year. It's not definitive evidence that they are preparing to trade Garoppolo, but it's a pretty clear suggestion that they're going to trade someone.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by tjd808185:
If the Rams want McDaniels they're going to have to play ball with him. He's got options. He's already chased out a Pro Bowl qb you know he's going to position to get his own guy. Rams will know that going in.

They're missing a 1st this year but JG is only going to garner a 2nd rounder and some change.

It's so far fetch that it's really not even worth debating at this point...didn't josh get fired already once in St Louis?

The Rams are all in on Goff, they won't be trading him and the next HC needs to be all in on Goff as well IMO.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Making assumptions/comparisons on a guy 6 games into a season with hot trash coaching him and playing with him

We will see who comes to LA there's been reports of Sean Payton and Kyle shanahan as well. Payton bringing Brees and shanahan bringing Ryan too?

I mean why couldn't goff fit McDaniels system?

The whole passing judgment on Goff after 6 games absolutely boggles my mind. I don't see them having trouble finding a coach that thinks he can work with Goff and Gurley and develop an offense around both of them. Rams will definitely have to invest in their OL and at WR and TE.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by susweel:
This pipsqueak won't last half a season.

6-3 225

Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:

He's 6'2, not 6'3, but he's still probably bigger than Watson. There are plenty of smaller QBs than Garapollo who don't get hurt all the time. Sus is exaggerating.

Originally posted by eastcoast49ersfan:
He's 6'2, not 6'3, but he's still probably bigger than Watson. There are plenty of smaller QBs than Garapollo who don't get hurt all the time. Sus is exaggerating.

Originally posted by WRATHman44:

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by WRATHman44:
What if the Rams hire McDaniels, and he trades for Garoppolo (3rds or 2nds)? Suddenly, the Rams don't need Goff anymore, and his struggles this year (though completely common for a rookie QB), make him no longer worth a 1st round pick in trade. We could essentially get the 2016 #1 overall pick for the same trade we'd consider for Garoppolo...

Not saying I'd do it, and I'd wanted to hear the HC's plan for clearing up his processing speed and accuracy under duress, but's interesting to think about...

Trading a #1 for a bust !

thats not a path to consider

WHO. THE. HELL. SAID. TRADE. A. #1??????

I said, consider trading the same value we'd look at giving for for Garoppolo which is somewhere around a 2nd and a conditional 3rd/2nd or a 3rd and a conditional 3rd/2nd for a guy who went #1 overall in 2016. Calling a Rookie QB a bust because he struggles is beyond foolish and impatient. Who are the best QBs in the NFL? How many of them are under 25? How many are under 30? Why do you think that is? Look at all of those QBs and their QB ratings as rookie, if they even played. Listening to the Shefters and Rappaports around the NFL, a lot of coaches and FO guys still think really highly of Goff, and the implication is that many think Fisher was a dope in developing Goff. Is that such a big surprise?

Originally posted by NYniner85:
Didn't he get fired once already in St Louis as the OC?

I mean I guess anything is possible but the chance they trade Goff off of 5 games after giving up so much for him ONLY to trade away more picks and pay Jimmy G is kinda far out there lol. (I think all they have is a 2,3,4,6 round pick this upcoming draft). I wouldn't be surprised if someone offers NE something better than they can offer.

It will be interesting to see who's coaching LA next yr...I'm praying we firing everyone and bring in the shannys personally

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Making assumptions/comparisons on a guy 6 games into a season with hot trash coaching him and playing with him

We will see who comes to LA there's been reports of Sean Payton and Kyle shanahan as well. Payton bringing Brees and shanahan bringing Ryan too?

I mean why couldn't goff fit McDaniels system?

FYI I don't want you to feel like I'm always trying to argue with you lol...I just don't see that happening

Originally posted by tjd808185:

It wasn't me who suggested it all I said was would the Rams trade him in division assuming they hired McDaniels.

Peyton and Shanny have been brought up since the Rams look to be going offense. It's way too early for the coaches to be expressing interest especially Payton who still has a job but no I don't think they'd get any of those people with Goff. I could argue this with you like always to the cows come home but it's Rams football and has no effect on us. If they hire McDaniels we'll talk again on this one.

Originally posted by WRATHman44:

In a perfect world, DeAndre Smelter plays well on Sunday, the 49ers sign Terrell Pryor in FA and Kevin Zeitler, and they trade for Jimmy Garoppolo, giving up a 3rd this year and a conditional 2nd next year. They use their 2nd rounder and a 4th to go get Corey Davis or John Ross.

On defense, they 49ers sign Brandon Williams to hold the nose, and they draft Myles Garrett at #2, after Cleveland takes Trubisky at #1.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by tjd808185:

It wasn't me who suggested it all I said was would the Rams trade him in division assuming they hired McDaniels.

Peyton and Shanny have been brought up since the Rams look to be going offense. It's way too early for the coaches to be expressing interest especially Payton who still has a job but no I don't think they'd get any of those people with Goff. I could argue this with you like always to the cows come home but it's Rams football and has no effect on us. If they hire McDaniels we'll talk again on this one.

No your right you weren't the one who brought it up....yup we will see who goes there then discuss

Originally posted by WRATHman44:

I'm the one who brought it up. COME GET SOME!!!