LISTEN: Looking For The 49ers' New DC With Jason Aponte →

There are 256 users in the forums

2024 Free Agency

Carr is being shopped around 1 more time. Would trading for Carr and saving $6 million on cap space next 2 yrs be an upgrade from Jimmy G?? Jimmy doesn't have anymore guaranteed money on contract so restructuring his deal will also help with cap space needed to resign free agents and maybe a good center or guard. Which option would you take??
[ Edited by danielrod1008 on Feb 18, 2021 at 4:25 PM ]
Originally posted by danielrod1008:
Carr is being shopped around 1 more time. Would trading for Carr and saving $6 million on cap space next 2 yrs be an upgrade from Jimmy G?? Jimmy doesn't have anymore guaranteed money on contract so restructuring his deal will also help with cap space needed to resign free agents and maybe a good center or guard. Which option would you take??
Only upgrades, not downgrades

carr lol
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by danielrod1008:
Carr is being shopped around 1 more time. Would trading for Carr and saving $6 million on cap space next 2 yrs be an upgrade from Jimmy G?? Jimmy doesn't have anymore guaranteed money on contract so restructuring his deal will also help with cap space needed to resign free agents and maybe a good center or guard. Which option would you take??
Only upgrades, not downgrades

carr lol

Seriously Carr is horrendous under pressure and is extremely inconsistent. No way. He's also got a great rb and OL and good coach.
Originally posted by elguapo:
Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:
Originally posted by danielrod1008:
Carr is being shopped around 1 more time. Would trading for Carr and saving $6 million on cap space next 2 yrs be an upgrade from Jimmy G?? Jimmy doesn't have anymore guaranteed money on contract so restructuring his deal will also help with cap space needed to resign free agents and maybe a good center or guard. Which option would you take??
Only upgrades, not downgrades

carr lol

Seriously Carr is horrendous under pressure and is extremely inconsistent. No way. He's also got a great rb and OL and good coach.
Rather swap OL, but we keep our Trent and they Keep theirs
Originally posted by danielrod1008:
Carr is being shopped around 1 more time. Would trading for Carr and saving $6 million on cap space next 2 yrs be an upgrade from Jimmy G?? Jimmy doesn't have anymore guaranteed money on contract so restructuring his deal will also help with cap space needed to resign free agents and maybe a good center or guard. Which option would you take??

You sound like Carr's brother on nfl.com
My top not too expensive FAs to replace some vets who might be leaving.
(OC) Alex Mack (W.Richburgh)
(ED) Haason Reddick (D.Ford)
(CB) DJ Hayden/Xavier Rhodes (R.Sherman)
(NCB) Mike Milton/Brian Poole (K.Williams)
(DT) Kevin Givens (DJ Jones)
(RB) Jeff Wilson (T.Coleman)

Can't depend on all rookies to fill all holes, should be a mixture of both FA & Draft.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 64,641
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
My top not too expensive FAs to replace some vets who might be leaving.
(OC) Alex Mack (W.Richburgh)
(ED) Haason Reddick (D.Ford)
(CB) DJ Hayden/Xavier Rhodes (R.Sherman)
(NCB) Mike Milton/Brian Poole (K.Williams)
(DT) Kevin Givens (DJ Jones)
(RB) Jeff Wilson (T.Coleman)

Can't depend on all rookies to fill all holes, should be a mixture of both FA & Draft.

I can dig this list.
[ Edited by mayo49 on Feb 20, 2021 at 6:45 AM ]
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
My top not too expensive FAs to replace some vets who might be leaving.
(OC) Alex Mack (W.Richburgh)
(ED) Haason Reddick (D.Ford)
(CB) DJ Hayden/Xavier Rhodes (R.Sherman)
(NCB) Mike Milton/Brian Poole (K.Williams)
(DT) Kevin Givens (DJ Jones)
(RB) Jeff Wilson (T.Coleman)

Can't depend on all rookies to fill all holes, should be a mixture of both FA & Draft.

Rhodes is gonna get payed
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
My top not too expensive FAs to replace some vets who might be leaving.
(OC) Alex Mack (W.Richburgh)
(ED) Haason Reddick (D.Ford)
(CB) DJ Hayden/Xavier Rhodes (R.Sherman)
(NCB) Mike Milton/Brian Poole (K.Williams)
(DT) Kevin Givens (DJ Jones)
(RB) Jeff Wilson (T.Coleman)

Can't depend on all rookies to fill all holes, should be a mixture of both FA & Draft.

Haason Reddick is coming off a season where he had 13 sacks after the Cards finally stopped trying to make him play MLB. He's about to get PAID. In retrospect the Cards blew it by not picking up his 5th year option.
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Haason Reddick is coming off a season where he had 13 sacks after the Cards finally stopped trying to make him play MLB. He's about to get PAID. In retrospect the Cards blew it by not picking up his 5th year option.

He'll get his share but it won't be as much as most big named players who are going to be available this offseason.
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
He'll get his share but it won't be as much as most big named players who are going to be available this offseason.

$13-15 mil isn't a lot? Arizona is considering tagging him.
  • mayo49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 64,641
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
He'll get his share but it won't be as much as most big named players who are going to be available this offseason.

$13-15 mil isn't a lot? Arizona is considering tagging him.

Yeah, even his share will be a lot.
With all this movement/veterans getting cut need to add another edge rusher to pair w/ Bosa - has to be a priority!

Webzone article has SF getting Mack (no surprise), resigning Trent Williams, and adding Breshard Perriman and Desmond King

Every FA seems like Shanalynch target 1 player heavily on day 1 (ala Richburg in 2018, Kwon in 2019) - wonder who they go for this year?
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Originally posted by 808niner4lyphe:
He'll get his share but it won't be as much as most big named players who are going to be available this offseason.

$13-15 mil isn't a lot? Arizona is considering tagging him.

I doubt he gets that much in the open market unless franchised tagged by the Cards.
Search Share 49ersWebzone