There are 318 users in the forums

Crazy but "possibility true"!...but not really

So been trying to gauge the Jimmy Garoppolo trade (and learn to spell his name correctly), as well as our high number of IR players into account for our next year projections for a mock. Now, with enough information after the regular college football season complete and enough booze to finally start fitting the pieces together, here's my "Crazy but possibly okay but not really 49er Mock Draft":

Prediction for rest of season: Jimmy Garoppolo ignites belief amongst the team (much to the chagrin of John Lynch losing out on draft leverage) and leads to a 3-2 record shown here:

@Chicago [W]
@Houston [W]
Tennessee [L]
Jaguars [L]
@Rams [W]

Even with the 2 losses (which will be close losses of 10pts or less), teams build morale with a 4-12 record (3-2 w/Jimmy) having 25+ppl on IR and a full offseason to learn both playbooks. Most importantly, WE WILL HAVE A QB FINALLY!!!!! SWEET BABY JESUS YES!!!!!...err, I mean, well done.

With this in mind, based on our ridiculous cap space of over $100 million, stable coach/GM team, and a real QB, we begin our plans with resignings:

Resign:

Jimmy Garopollo, QB [Franchise Tag]
- Yes, he may be our next great QB, but a 5 game sample is only that, a sample. Shanny already hinted that we'd franchise for $23 million, which is a drastic uptick of pay for Jimmy and money we can be willing to spend to guarantee a chance with the next possible great SF QB...that and at least he'd make a killing selling Rice-a-Roni with those looks

Brandon Fusco, RG [3 year deal]
- He wasn't the best, but he is average, which is more than what we have with Tomlinson/Kilgore/Beadles. He can anchor while we build up some rookies (or find something better next season).

Dontae Johnson, CB [3 year deal]
- Fits mold for DB in Saleh's system, don't see him getting much out in FA, willing to take less to guarantee long term stability. Can start if/when needed.

Brock Coyle/Leger Douzable [2 year deal]
- Back ups who can fill in for a pinch. Won't cost much and Coyle can play ST very well.

With all resigns, unfortunately there are releases...

Key Releases:

Carlos Hyde, RB
- My friend explained to me that "The 49ers need name players to keep fans in the stands, which is why Hyde will stay and get paid". Yes, he is playing well, but he will command a high paycheck and the 49ers got their cap back by managing it well, not by throwing money for a position the HC is infamous for developing via lower draft picks. He will get paid very well, but just not with us. Wish him the best!

Eric Reid, SS
- Love this guy and want to keep him, but here are the problems keeping him:

1. Plagued by injuries (reason why we didn't extend him before), including some severe concussions
2. Plenty of depth (Ward, Tartt, Colbert) and Saleh seems to know how to find them, even in late rounds

Sadly, due to injuries (and with some teams his political stance, which is BS to dock a player on) he probably moves on and gets a good contract filed with incentives. Wish him the best as well!

Laken Tomlinson/Zane Beadles/Daniel Kilgore ("OL" depth?)
- Bon Voyage! Don't let the door hit ya where the good Lord split ya! No need for turn-style OL risking Jimmy G's career.

With these players and additional players gone, this leads to a fun an exciting FA rush to SPEND....THAT...MONEY!!!!

Key FA Signings:


Ryan Jensen, Center (5 year deal)
- Will be highest paid center in league after deal...welcome to "NFL overpay when you're 4-12"!!! But Jensen will be worth it. Young, great manager of the line, and can play in ZBS. Shanny needs veteran Centers to meet his complex schemes (ala Alex Mack), and Jensen fits the mold. Pay the man!

Bashaud Breeland, CB (5 year deal)
- We NEED CBs with actual talent, and Breeland fits the bill. We'll probably add depth with some lower tier vets, but with Breeland, Witherspoon, Ward (he's moving back), and Johnson, we have good nucleus that draft can add depth to.

Jeremiah Attachou, EDGE (2 year deal)
- Take a flyer on a guy whose athletic prowess at Georgia Tech showed high potential. Worst case eat the money like we did with Lynch.

We will add some DBs and LBs for fodder, but a lot of our IR will begin to fill in the depth as well. Now, we can move on to the fun part...the DRAFT!!!

Round 1: Bradley Chubb, EDGE, NC State

- If we were still in Top 3, I'd have us looking at Barkley for offensive weapon, but with the extra wins we move out to 5-6 range, and we get a steal in Chubb. The guy is a beast and will get into the LEO from day one and instantly improve us. Gets Thomas into correct position to maximize everyone's talent, and get us towards a functioning pass rush!

Round 2: Armani Watt, FS, Texas A&M
- Have to thank SteveYoung for introducing me to this guy on his mock (so I'm totally stealing his idea) and have to say he is exciting! In Saleh's system this kid has the skills to play the Earl Thomas-role and allow our CB depth to improve with Ward back at CB. We now have a pass rush to limit passing and center-fielder to play the deep pass. Fix the Defense and allow Shanny to do his offensive guru magic

[Trade: Use highest 3rd and a 7th to move into very end of 2nd]

Round 2: Simmie Coats Jr., WR, Indiana
- How we destroyed Ohio State's defense single-handedly was a thing of beauty. Size, speed, and hands will make him a true #1 to pair with Garcon and Goodwin. Add playmakers for Jimmy G.

Round 3: Micah Kiser, ILB, Virginia
- Guy knows how to make plays and can create a fantastic duo with Foster.

Round 4: Mason Cole, OG/C, Michigan
- OL depth, can develop into starting OG (in case Garnett or Fusco fall flat), but will provide strong depth at both OG and C positions.

Round 6: Allen Lazard, WR, Iowa State
- Stud #1 in college, slow but great at using size for separation. We don't have any RZ threats so he automatically jumps up the list...pun intended

Round 7: Ralph Webb, RB, Vanderbilt
- Showed great work ethic and produced even for a talent-deprived offense. Give him a creative OC and stud RB coach and let's see if we can get that Shannahan family magic.

Overall goal is to keep Jimmy G upright, and the defense up to Top 15. With this offseason, I can see them achieving that.


After a full year, we get the offensive specialists (RB and slot WR) to pair with our QB of future and begin the fun

GO NINERS!!!!!
[ Edited by Crazy49er1313 on Dec 3, 2017 at 1:32 AM ]
So Brieda or Williams is our starting RB? That's a scary proposition
Hey Crazy, whilst I would prefer to keep Hyde I understand the argument about not re-signing. But not re-signing, not picking up a replacement in FA and not drafting a running back until the 7th? Sorry but that is insanity. Breida as our starting back? The untried Morris as his depth?

Not sure I want to spend a 2nd on a safety either. And I think we need more investment in the O line.

But it is an interesting mock.
Love it.

Chubb, Kiser and Watts are 3 of my favorites in the draft.

I'm not sure how Chubb would fit at LEO as he seems to be a better fit on the strong side but I think he is a better edge player than Thomas. Regardless it's a toss up for best defensive player between him or Georgia's Roquan Smith. Either player would work for us IMO.

RB is still a concern but like you said Shanahan always finds gems later on.

Nice work.
I like tha guys u resigned except for Leger Douzable he's old may have shown a little something but nothing special...

I think Laken Tomlinson stays he's on a cheap rookie deal and with more time in our system he can get better ...

Not a fan of Chubbs just something about him and his play I just dont see him becoming anything special...

I dont like Hyde so I'm hoping we dont resign him and I like u didnt but u didnt replace him with another FA or a high we draft pick big mistake IMO ...

So nice FA signings especially
Ryan Jensen ...

Overall not to bad
  • jimrat
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 23,655
Simmie Cobbs
Not sure Chubb is a good fit for this D. I think I'd go Smith, too.

I have to believe they don't go in with just Breida and Williams. They praised Hyde, but that we've heard that on a number of players that are no longer on the team.
im a little skeptical of Chubb because i dont think he compliments our other lineman. I feel like we need someone with alot of speed, like Landry. but i wouldnt be mad.

Im a firm believer that our FS is either Colbert or Ward, so i would be a littl disappointed if we spent another pick on a FS.

I love Cobbs! i think he is going to be a star. He has it all and is flying under the radar. Wouldnt be surprised if he sneaks into the first and ahead of Christian Kirk.
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,257
I would say two issues here because I'm sick and tired of Defense in the first round. Let the way you dressed it in free agency makes it okay. but here is the one problem. WARD is not a safety, he showed it. Ward needs to play corner. Our safety depth needs to be tarrt, Reid, colbert
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,257
Originally posted by JustinNiner:
im a little skeptical of Chubb because i dont think he compliments our other lineman. I feel like we need someone with alot of speed, like Landry. but i wouldnt be mad.

Im a firm believer that our FS is either Colbert or Ward, so i would be a littl disappointed if we spent another pick on a FS.

I love Cobbs! i think he is going to be a star. He has it all and is flying under the radar. Wouldnt be surprised if he sneaks into the first and ahead of Christian Kirk.

Lol ward was not good
Originally posted by fan49:
I would say two issues here because I'm sick and tired of Defense in the first round. Let the way you dressed it in free agency makes it okay. but here is the one problem. WARD is not a safety, he showed it. Ward needs to play corner. Our safety depth needs to be tarrt, Reid, colbert

Honestly he didn't show anything horrible when he was our FS...his issue is he simply can't stay healthy.

I don't think he stay on with the 5th yr option either....just too much cash for a guy that's always on IR.
who is our RB I mean if Hyde isn't resigned I don't see how they don't draft someone.

I can't stomach another DE (that's 4 yrs in a row)...I'm on the Colbert bandwagon so I'm gonna say no to FS ( I don't mind Watts think he's a 3rd round pick though). Tarrt can play FS as well (and I'd resign Reid depending on cash).

I still think we end up with a top 5 pick (we aren't beating the Rams) which is still very valuable trading piece. I'd rather we go after a quick twitch edge rusher that can play the SAM as well (Vic Beasley/Bruce Irvin type).

like the Jensen signing and the Cobbs pick OH and only way DJ stays is for backup money IMO

thanks for the mock!
Like Jensen but not Breeland.

Like the re-signings

Don't think I would take Chubb over Harold Landry or Roquan Smith.

Would rather take a CB or TE with the 2nd round pick than another safety. A good pass catching TE is an under rated need
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,257
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by fan49:
I would say two issues here because I'm sick and tired of Defense in the first round. Let the way you dressed it in free agency makes it okay. but here is the one problem. WARD is not a safety, he showed it. Ward needs to play corner. Our safety depth needs to be tarrt, Reid, colbert

Honestly he didn't show anything horrible when he was our FS...his issue is he simply can't stay healthy.

I don't think he stay on with the 5th yr option either....just too much cash for a guy that's always on IR.

Tarrt and colbert played better....
  • fan49
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 6,257
Not to mention you added 0 playmakers on offense and released Hyde...
Search Share 49ersWebzone