1st Round Pick (4th Poll, No Trade Downs)

Dec. 23, 2017
I think it's likely that we'll be either 4-12 or 5-11, and picking 5-7th overall.
NOTE: I've eliminated QB, DT, S, and OT from the list as I don't see how we would select one of these positions.
Results (141 total votes):
Quentin Nelson - 33%
Bradley Chubb - 17%
Saquon Barkley - 15%
Roquan Smith - 13%
Minkah Fitzpatrick - 9%
Harold Landry - 7%
Calvin Ridley - 4%
Courtland Sutton - 3%
Arden Key - 1%

Jan. 5, 2018
Niners will be picking either 9th or 10th (TBD).
NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT from the list, but added back in OT and S. I've also eliminated Bradley Chubb and Saquon Barkley as they are widely considered top-5 selections.
Results (168 total votes):
Quentin Nelson - 39%
Harold Landry - 16%
Joshua Jackson - 13%
Roquan Smith - 11%
Calvin Ridley - 8%
Arden Key - 5%
Minkah Fitzpatrick - 4%
Mike McGlinchey - 2%
Courtland Sutton - 1%
Clelin Ferrell - 1%

Jan. 23, 2018
Niners will be picking either 9th or 10th (TBD).
NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT. I'm adding Bradley Chubb back into the fray, but keeping Saquon Barkley off, and eliminating Clelin Ferrell as he's going back to school. The list now includes names from previous polls and recent mock drafts.
Results (97 total votes):
Quentin Nelson - 39%
Roquan Smith - 18%
Bradley Chubb - 13%
Joshua Jackson - 10%
Minkah Fitzpatrick - 7%
Marcus Davenport - 3%
Tremaine Edmunds - 2%
Courtland Sutton - 2%
Derwin James - 2%
Denzel Ward - 2%
Harold Landry - 1%

Feb. 14, 2018
Niners will be picking either 9th or 10th (TBD).
NOTE: I've eliminated QB and DT. I'm adding Saquon Barkley back into the poll.

nelson, or barkley. We need a cb through free agency not the draft. We need a vet! don't really want spoon being the mentor, hes too young.

• Nelson remains the favorite by a substantial margin
• Landry is the most volatile
• Fitzpatrick and Chubb (both considered top 10 guys) don't have a ton of interest
• I expect Roquan to jump with the Foster news

Nelson, Chubb and Barkley won't be there

Chubb allday if he's still available
A pass rusher is way more critical than a guard.

Originally posted by lamontb:
Chubb allday if he's still available
A pass rusher is way more critical than a guard.

I agree

Obviously everyone knows this is highly dependent on who we get in FA

But if the top 5-7 vote getters right now were all on the board at 9 (let's say) I would have them ranked

Chubb (impact position of need)
Smith (assuming we got one or two OL in FA)
Nelson (could be above Smith; depending on our FA signings and how FO feels about Garnett, Foster and Malcolm Smith...)
Jackson or Ward

Well, I forgot Barkley, if he was also there that would be a really tough choice. I think right now my preferred scenario would be something Phoenix mentioned in another thread — a trade down and Vander Esch + Ronald Jones would be cool..

But I think it's more likely that Chubb Barkley and Nelson are gone, in which case I'd probably take Roquan unless there was a crazy trade down offered