Nkemdiche is the ultimate boom-or-bust player.
He's easily the most dominant defensive player in the draft.
Easily. I've literally never seen one guy move him very much at all, and when he's doubled, he hardly moves either. He explodes into his guy off the snap with the kind of power I can't even remember seeing in college football. His upper-body strength is insane; O-linemen do absolutely nothing to him with their hands.
Basically, this guy could be the next
Aldon Smith as a DL. The problem is that he could also be the next
Aldon Smith upstairs. Falling out of a friggn' hotel makes me think of
Sergio Kindle; something is not right with this dude's mind.
However, he's the perfect compliment to
Ian &
Arik. He'd play LDE, and
Arik would play RDE because he's more of a pass rusher. And
Dial provides good depth (
Tank does too; he can play DE in pass-rushing situations). The D-line would probably be as good as it was with
Ray &
Justin. It's EXTREMELY tempting to take a chance on this monster.
The other thing is that I really, really like
Deforest Buckner too. He &
Arik would be the second pair of former teammates playing the same position on the defense (
Ward &
Tartt). And
Buckner is a great player; I like him even more than
A'Shawn Robinson, who's also a great 5-tech guy.
Buckner is the safer pick, but
Nkemdiche could be the next
Bryant Young. What does a GM do?