There are 391 users in the forums

Sam Darnold

A play that might pique Kyle's interest. Darnold's accuracy on the move is elite.

[ Edited by Heroism on Sep 11, 2017 at 3:05 PM ]
  • PGENZ
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 95
QB1
I can tell you one thing he has to fix right now. Pre snap, you can always tell which side of the field he is going to go to. He always looks to that side and doesn't even bother to look at the side the play is going away from. I can literally watch his highlights and practically tell you which receiver he will hit on almost every play. Something that's easily coachable. He is fun to watch and plays a little more backyard Farve style. Watching him is reminding me a little of Utah Alex Smith for some reason. Lots of little dink passes that inflate his stats. Going to continue to follow him throughout the season since all signs are pointing to us needing a QB next year.
  • Geeked
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,057
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I can tell you one thing he has to fix right now. Pre snap, you can always tell which side of the field he is going to go to. He always looks to that side and doesn't even bother to look at the side the play is going away from. I can literally watch his highlights and practically tell you which receiver he will hit on almost every play. Something that's easily coachable. He is fun to watch and plays a little more backyard Farve style. Watching him is reminding me a little of Utah Alex Smith for some reason. Lots of little dink passes that inflate his stats. Going to continue to follow him throughout the season since all signs are pointing to us needing a QB next year.

Ummm, you must have not payed a whole lot of attention to what he did last year. There isn't a QB in the PAC that is more even with their receiver choice than Darnold; which includes Rosen.

Farvre comparison is accurate, but last time I checked, lock on and Farvre don't exist in the same dimension, let alone universe.
[ Edited by Geeked on Sep 11, 2017 at 7:11 PM ]
Originally posted by Geeked:
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I can tell you one thing he has to fix right now. Pre snap, you can always tell which side of the field he is going to go to. He always looks to that side and doesn't even bother to look at the side the play is going away from. I can literally watch his highlights and practically tell you which receiver he will hit on almost every play. Something that's easily coachable. He is fun to watch and plays a little more backyard Farve style. Watching him is reminding me a little of Utah Alex Smith for some reason. Lots of little dink passes that inflate his stats. Going to continue to follow him throughout the season since all signs are pointing to us needing a QB next year.

Ummm, you must have not payed a whole lot of attention to what he did last year. There isn't a QB in the PAC that is more even with their receiver choice than Darnold; which includes Rosen.

Farvre comparison is accurate, but last time I checked, lock on and Farvre don't exist in the same dimension, let alone universe.

I'm watching what he's done these past few weeks. Go watch his highlights and watch him pre snap and tell me if you can guess which side of the field he's going to try to throw to.
[ Edited by NTeply49 on Sep 12, 2017 at 4:20 AM ]
  • Geeked
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,057
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I'm watching what he's done these past few weeks. Go watch his highlights and watch him pre snap and tell me if you can guess which side of the field he's going to try to throw to.

I watched every game... so do the scouts... but you watch highlights... sooo, I guess you should provide Shanny and Lynch a resume
Originally posted by Heroism:
A play that might pique Kyle's interest. Darnold's accuracy on the move is elite.

Damn, if he'd have thrown to the guy in the back of the endzone, it would have been very similar to "the catch." Or intercepted.
Originally posted by Geeked:
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I'm watching what he's done these past few weeks. Go watch his highlights and watch him pre snap and tell me if you can guess which side of the field he's going to try to throw to.

I watched every game... so do the scouts... but you watch highlights... sooo, I guess you should provide Shanny and Lynch a resume

No, I am stating an observation. You must be riding his jock pretty hard right now to be this defensive. Can't handle a little criticism?
  • Geeked
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,057
Originally posted by NTeply49:
Originally posted by Geeked:
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I'm watching what he's done these past few weeks. Go watch his highlights and watch him pre snap and tell me if you can guess which side of the field he's going to try to throw to.

I watched every game... so do the scouts... but you watch highlights... sooo, I guess you should provide Shanny and Lynch a resume

No, I am stating an observation. You must be riding his jock pretty hard right now to be this defensive. Can't handle a little criticism?

Not really, I just don't understand how a guy who has distributed the ball better than every PAC-12 QB last year and this year is being accused of locking on. That's the one issue he doesn't have. I'd get on you for saying the same thing about Rosen. It's an observation not supported by stats or complete observation.

If you want to criticize his dumb throws... That's an issue. The guy plays like Farvre... Fact is, if Sam did Lock on, he most likely wouldn't have thrown two picks last week and the week prior.
Originally posted by Geeked:
Originally posted by NTeply49:
Originally posted by Geeked:
Originally posted by NTeply49:
I'm watching what he's done these past few weeks. Go watch his highlights and watch him pre snap and tell me if you can guess which side of the field he's going to try to throw to.

I watched every game... so do the scouts... but you watch highlights... sooo, I guess you should provide Shanny and Lynch a resume

No, I am stating an observation. You must be riding his jock pretty hard right now to be this defensive. Can't handle a little criticism?

Not really, I just don't understand how a guy who has distributed the ball better than every PAC-12 QB last year and this year is being accused of locking on. That's the one issue he doesn't have. I'd get on you for saying the same thing about Rosen. It's an observation not supported by stats or complete observation.

If you want to criticize his dumb throws... That's an issue. The guy plays like Farvre... Fact is, if Sam did Lock on, he most likely wouldn't have thrown two picks last week and the week prior.

Well I am not going to say I've been following him as a fan of his since last year. As I said, from the 2 games I watched, I could tell you which side of field he was going to. Go watch a video of all of his throws this year so far and tell me you don't see it. If he looks over to the right side of the field, then half ass glance left not even selling it all, you can safely bet he's going right with the ball. Like I also said, it is something that is easily coachable.

Now you're saying if he locked onto his receivers he wouldn't throw picks too? Your example of him not locking onto receivers is the fact he threw 2 picks. I am confused
  • Geeked
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 10,057
Originally posted by NTeply49:
Well I am not going to say I've been following him as a fan of his since last year. As I said, from the 2 games I watched, I could tell you which side of field he was going to. Go watch a video of all of his throws this year so far and tell me you don't see it. If he looks over to the right side of the field, then half ass glance left not even selling it all, you can safely bet he's going right with the ball. Like I also said, it is something that is easily coachable.

Now you're saying if he locked onto his receivers he wouldn't throw picks too? Your example of him not locking onto receivers is the fact he threw 2 picks. I am confused

Watch the game. That's all I can say. I watch a lot of college football and I can tell you how not locking on to receivers may result in a pick. Locking on and throwing it into coverage will get you in trouble but locking on and throwing to the play that is designed to exploit a zone or coverage approach may result in a lot of yardage or a TD.

Locking on itself isn't the issue. It happens a LOT in College and to some extent the NFL. It's when you lock and the play has predictability. In the NFL, guys are too smart to be fooled by a play selection... soo, that's it.

Sam looks around too much. You see this when he holds onto the ball too long or when he's extending a play. He's usually looking at a specific side of the field but he's not locking onto a specific target... unless he's in the process of shedding coverage. That may be what you're detecting in the highlight reels. I'm a PAC guy and I went to USC. I'm not a homer as I'm more down on SC players than most others. Especially over the past couple of years. They are the guys I see most, and I know exactly where they'll fail.

I've been more impressed with non USC QB's since the Leinart era... Sanchez had good year but proved to everyone why drafting a guy with 13 starts may not be a good idea.
Originally posted by Geeked:
Originally posted by NTeply49:
Well I am not going to say I've been following him as a fan of his since last year. As I said, from the 2 games I watched, I could tell you which side of field he was going to. Go watch a video of all of his throws this year so far and tell me you don't see it. If he looks over to the right side of the field, then half ass glance left not even selling it all, you can safely bet he's going right with the ball. Like I also said, it is something that is easily coachable.

Now you're saying if he locked onto his receivers he wouldn't throw picks too? Your example of him not locking onto receivers is the fact he threw 2 picks. I am confused

Watch the game. That's all I can say. I watch a lot of college football and I can tell you how not locking on to receivers may result in a pick. Locking on and throwing it into coverage will get you in trouble but locking on and throwing to the play that is designed to exploit a zone or coverage approach may result in a lot of yardage or a TD.

Locking on itself isn't the issue. It happens a LOT in College and to some extent the NFL. It's when you lock and the play has predictability. In the NFL, guys are too smart to be fooled by a play selection... soo, that's it.

Sam looks around too much. You see this when he holds onto the ball too long or when he's extending a play. He's usually looking at a specific side of the field but he's not locking onto a specific target... unless he's in the process of shedding coverage. That may be what you're detecting in the highlight reels. I'm a PAC guy and I went to USC. I'm not a homer as I'm more down on SC players than most others. Especially over the past couple of years. They are the guys I see most, and I know exactly where they'll fail.

I've been more impressed with non USC QB's since the Leinart era... Sanchez had good year but proved to everyone why drafting a guy with 13 starts may not be a good idea.

Let me try and clarify a little better. I am not saying he is LOCKING onto ANY receiver specifically. I never even used the word LOCK in my original post.I am stating that from the 2 games I have watched every one of his throws and runs. I have noticed a PRE SNAP tendency to look the way the play is going to go, and then not even really look at the other side of the field.

After the snap, he does a good job of finding another receiver if it isn't there.

You said, "Locking on itself isn't the issue. It happens a LOT in College and to some extent the NFL. It's when you lock and the play has predictability. In the NFL, guys are too smart to be fooled by a play selection... soo, that's it."

I am saying he has a tendency to be predictable, which as you also stated, will consequently make you less effective at the pro level. We agree on that
This QB class today
Originally posted by Heroism:
This QB class today

Give me Rosen all day
Originally posted by Heroism:
This QB class today

Let me repeat:

Gonna LOL if the "garbage" 2017 QB class turns out to be better than the ridiculously hyped 2018 class.
Share 49ersWebzone