There are 204 users in the forums
Originally posted by tjd808185:
Originally posted by genus49:
Stop saying this crap. When has a rookie DT ever became the main reason an NFL team went from a 4 win season or even a losing season to a SB participant?
But Q is so dominant he single handedly shut down Clemson and led Bama to a title. This ain't no ordinary pick.
Oh wait. I guess you can still lose with a tackle.
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Glad we passed on Frank Gore back in the day because of those two ACL repairs. RBs need good knees or they never last in this league.
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Glad we passed on Frank Gore back in the day because of those two ACL repairs. RBs need good knees or they never last in this league.
im glad you picked out an anomaly of a draft pick in Frank Gore, which was a 3rd round pick 14 years ago. How have the 49ers fared after 2005 when it comes to injured players....
Originally posted by genus49:
You guys are grasping at these straws so hard.
Yes QW doesn't have the injury history of Bosa...but he really only played one full season as a starter and fact is right now Nick Bosa is 100% healthy and Quinnen isn't.
Injuries are a concern with Bosa but right now as mentioned he's 100% healthy which means his concerns are no different than anyone else. I've thrown around the Frank Gore vs Reggie Bush comparison many times. Frank had awful injury history in college. Reggie Bush had 0 concerns. How did their NFL careers go?
And if you watch the video....he didn't say he'd take Williams over Bosa for us. That discussion wasn't part of it. And guess what...which team is picking does matter.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by Rathof44:
Glad we passed on Frank Gore back in the day because of those two ACL repairs. RBs need good knees or they never last in this league.
im glad you picked out an anomaly of a draft pick in Frank Gore, which was a 3rd round pick 14 years ago. How have the 49ers fared after 2005 when it comes to injured players....
JImmy G was a four yr starter in college, never got hurt.....clearly that doesn't mean s**t because it's football and players get hurt
Originally posted by KamLeon:
I remember that time when people thought Taylor Mayes was going to be better than Earl Thomas when Thomas was drafted first and I barely remember that draft when people said Alex Smith was going to be better than Aaron Rodgers.
I just hope we are on the right side of history this time
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by genus49:
You guys are grasping at these straws so hard.
Yes QW doesn't have the injury history of Bosa...but he really only played one full season as a starter and fact is right now Nick Bosa is 100% healthy and Quinnen isn't.
Injuries are a concern with Bosa but right now as mentioned he's 100% healthy which means his concerns are no different than anyone else. I've thrown around the Frank Gore vs Reggie Bush comparison many times. Frank had awful injury history in college. Reggie Bush had 0 concerns. How did their NFL careers go?
And if you watch the video....he didn't say he'd take Williams over Bosa for us. That discussion wasn't part of it. And guess what...which team is picking does matter.
No, we're not. Bosa has a history of injuries. Does that not concern you?
Originally posted by pdizo916:
so you expect that Bosa will have a healthy nfl career while his fragile body cannot handle the college and high school game? Wow. SMH.
Originally posted by genus49:
Would I rather he have no injury history? Of course.
Am I worried about his play because of his injuries? No.
The ACL injury he had was in HS, it was a partial tear and healed fast enough that he didn't have to redshirt the following season as a true freshman.
The core injury is fully healed and is probably stronger as a result.
Injuries in the NFL are part training and mostly luck. As I've said we've seen guys who were dealing with serious injuries in college come into the league and not have anything serious ever again and have HOF level careers and we've had players who didn't miss any games come in and never play a full season.
If Bosa was coming off an ACL injury and couldn't work out then I would have way more concerns.
Originally posted by NYniner85:
Originally posted by pdizo916:
so you expect that Bosa will have a healthy nfl career while his fragile body cannot handle the college and high school game? Wow. SMH.
He had one injury in 3 yrs at OSU....anyone can and will get hurt at some point it's f**king football dude. Having a partial ACL tear or having a core injury in no way means he can't "handle" football. that's the dumbest post.
I guess Adrian Peterson can't "handle" it because he had the same s**t (ACL and core injury). Last I checked he's going into his 13th yr as a RB.
Originally posted by genus49:Clearly you missed the memo and Bosa is the only guy to have injuries in HS and college. Anytime this happened in the past those players were done for.
Originally posted by genus49:
Originally posted by TheXFactor:
Originally posted by pdizo916:
Originally posted by 4ML:
Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:
Glad that I'm not the only one that made the QW/Quenton Nelson comparison.
"I have Quinnen Williams as the highest rated player in this draft."@AaronTaylorCFB tells @AdamSchein why he would take Alabama's Williams over Nick Bosa in the upcoming NFL Draft. #T2S pic.twitter.com/BX2bm3EVMN
— CBS Sports Network (@CBSSportsNet) April 15, 2019
"Why pick williams over bosa?"
Analyst: "injuries"
It's so funny to me that the same fans that hate why Lynch signs injured players they have a meltdown. Now they all want Bosa lol
You guys are grasping at these straws so hard.
Yes QW doesn't have the injury history of Bosa...but he really only played one full season as a starter and fact is right now Nick Bosa is 100% healthy and Quinnen isn't.
Injuries are a concern with Bosa but right now as mentioned he's 100% healthy which means his concerns are no different than anyone else. I've thrown around the Frank Gore vs Reggie Bush comparison many times. Frank had awful injury history in college. Reggie Bush had 0 concerns. How did their NFL careers go?
And if you watch the video....he didn't say he'd take Williams over Bosa for us. That discussion wasn't part of it. And guess what...which team is picking does matter.
