Which WR would you choose in the 2nd?

Ok this is getting worked over pretty hard in a lot of threads. But I would like to see some real data.

Let's assume that Metcalf and Hollywood Brown go in the first. So with our second pick we have all these WRs to choose from.

Which one would you take?

My personal rankings after watching them

1) N'Keal Harry
2) Butler
3) Harmon
4) AJ Brown
5) Deebo
6) Campbell
7) Isabella

I would take Butler because I like the combination of size, athletic ability and where I think Shanahan can take him with coaching.

However I'd probably rank them overall

1. Harry
2. Butler
3. Brown
4. Harmon
5. Deebo
6. Isabella
7. Campbell

Where's the none wait for 3rd round.

3rd round

1A. Antoine Wesley
1B. Emanuel Hall
3. Riley Ridley

Originally posted by Ensatsu:

My personal rankings after watching them

1) N'Keal Harry
2) Butler
3) Harmon
4) AJ Brown
5) Deebo
6) Campbell
7) Isabella

So you went tallest to shortest

Originally posted by krizay:
Where's the none wait for 3rd round.

3rd round

1A. Antoine Wesley
1B. Emanuel Hall
3. Riley Ridley

I thought about adding that, but I didn't want to open it up so much with too many branching options. Take a G then Ridley. Take Adderly then take Arcega-Whiteside. Wait until the 6th and take Lil'Jordan Humphrey. It just goes on....

So I just left it at, "if you're taking a WR in the 2nd and these guys are there, which do you want?"

Nice and simple.

If you'd like though, I can add a "None" option.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
My personal rankings after watching them

1) N'Keal Harry
2) Butler
3) Harmon
4) AJ Brown
5) Deebo
6) Campbell
7) Isabella

So you went tallest to shortest

Ha! I tried to go random, but you are right... Except Butler is taller than Harry... But otherwise yes. Funny accident

Originally posted by NYniner85:
So you went tallest to shortest

I got deebo over campbell and butler beneath harry.

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
My personal rankings after watching them

1) N'Keal Harry
2) Butler
3) Harmon
4) AJ Brown
5) Deebo
6) Campbell
7) Isabella

I think that's pretty much my rankings as well.

Deciding between Harry and Butler is tough for me though.

I'm sure OP knows this but it's unlikely that all three of Harry, Butler, and AJ Brown will be available at 36 but I see those three as a bit above the rest.

I'd put Deebo next... then between Harmon, Campbell and Isabella I'll be honest, I really can't tell who's gonna be best. It's really hard to tell from just watching their highlights 🤷🏻‍♂️ If we got any of the first three or Deebo I'd be really excited.

Harmon, Isabella, or Campbell I would still be excited... lol. Definitely a good year to be needing a WR and picking top of the 2nd.

Only thing is we need DB and OL too... decisions, decisions. At least IMO and assuming we go Edge (hopefully Bosa or Burns) with our first pick, those are our three clearcut top needs after that, in whatever order you want to rank them: WR, OL, FS/CB. Just depends how the FO evaluates and sets their board and who they have highest. It's gonna be a tough decision because it's gonna be tempting to wonder which WRs will still be there at our 3rd pick. Especially if a Lindstrom or Risner or Adderly is there at 36. But I still think it seems most likely that a WR is the pick at 36.


Edit: Harmon I've watched the least of, I see you guys have him above Deebo, I'll have to look again..

Who should i want?

1. AJB
2. Butler
3. Deebo
4. Harry
5. Harmon
6. Campbell
.
.
7. Isabella

I'd probably take Ridley somewhere in there. McLaurin and JJ AW too before Isabella for sure.

Originally posted by 91til:
I'm sure OP knows this but it's unlikely that all three of Harry, Butler, and AJ Brown will be available at 36 but I see those three as a bit above the rest.

I'd put Deebo next... then between Harmon, Campbell and Isabella I'll be honest, I really can't tell who's gonna be best. It's really hard to tell from just watching their highlights 🤷🏻‍♂️ If we got any of the first three or Deebo I'd be really excited.

Harmon, Isabella, or Campbell I would still be excited... lol. Definitely a good year to be needing a WR and picking top of the 2nd.

Only thing is we need DB and OL too... decisions, decisions. At least IMO and assuming we go Edge (hopefully Bosa or Burns) with our first pick, those are our three clearcut top needs after that, in whatever order you want to rank them: WR, OL, FS/CB. Just depends how the FO evaluates and sets their board and who they have highest. It's gonna be a tough decision because it's gonna be tempting to wonder which WRs will still be there at our 3rd pick. Especially if a Lindstrom or Risner or Adderly is there at 36. But I still think it seems most likely that a WR is the pick at 36.

Edit: Harmon I've watched the least of, I see you guys have him above Deebo, I'll have to look again..

Yes, it is definitely unlikely that ALL of those guys are available for our second pick. I expect at least one to get picked late first or before us in the second. But since it's impossible to tell which of them would not be there, I decided to assume they were all there. This way we can really see how our priorities lie.

Originally posted by susweel:
Who should i want?

N'AJ Deebutlermon of course!

Hard pass on Butler, WR with questiable hands.

I would love Brown, Harry, or Deeebo.

Harry being my draft crush. Huge WR with good speed and incredible hands.