Originally posted by IrishCrnjo:
I think we need to start looking for a replacement for Staley and Richburg. Staley is obviously at the tail end of his career and Richburg is a huge ? due to injury.
We only have 1 pick in the first 4 rounds though, so we better make it count. The 49ers seem to be as cursed at drafting interior lineman in the early rounds as they are at receiver.
Agreed, with a couple of provisos.
I think Brunskill may well be Staley's replacement. Skule will surely be worked on as a future OT and Shon Coleman is probably, when he returns from I/R, the swing tackle. Happy to pick up another OT for development.
I do not agree that Richburg is injury prone. A torn tendon last year. Getting his leg bent underneath him this year. These are happenstance, they do not indicate any kind of tendency towards injury. I would like to see Ben Garland play a few times before I judge the need for drafting another center, but also bear in mind that Brunskill can play center.
Your comment about being cursed at drafting interior linemen in the early rounds puzzles me. The only O linemen that the current management have drafted are Skule and McGlinchey, neither obviously interior and both, I would suggest, successes. Garnett was a failed pick in 2016 with a 1st, Martin likewise in 2014 with a 3rd and before that, Looney in 2012 and Iupati in 2010 neither of whom were disastrous. Bearing in mind that no pick is guaranteed, I don't think that this is a bad record and certainly the track record for current management is fine.
Regarding being cursed at early rounds drafting at receiver, I do not think that this is easy to justify, either. Deebo looks like a terrific pick. Hard to judge Hurd but I thought he looked really good in the pre-seasons. Early days to write off Pettis but things could look better here. The only other receiver taken by current management is Trent Taylor in the 5th and I think he looks like good value for a 5th rounder. Previous management took Smelter in the 4th, Ellington in the 4th, Patton in the 4th and A J Jenkins in the 1st. I don't think 4th round picks can be classified as the early rounds but Jenkins was undeniably a bust. But A J Jenkins and the possibility of having to dump Pettis does not justify being cursed. Drafting is a lottery and expectations need to be realistic.
That all being said, I would like to see activity on the O line next draft. I totally believe that you start with the two lines. Having built them, you need to upkeep them.