Trey Lance QB NDSU

If the rumors are true and we trade jimmy it can't be tray for day 1

Originally posted by NYniner85:

There are people smarter than myself who believe so, including JT O'Sullivan, who said why on the podcast we're dropping tomorrow. 🙃 https://t.co/JJNglFhr16

— Chris Biderman (@ChrisBiderman) April 29, 2021

Definitely think he can start week1. He played a prostyle offense and many are saying he is the smartest QB in the draft. With the talent 49ers would have around him, Lance should have the support to be successful. Starting young QBs too early usually happens when the whole team around them stinks. They end up with WRs who cant get open, lineman who cant block, and a defense that forces them to throw all game to catch up. Lance will be sitting pretty in the pocket, handing it off a great stable of RBs, running plays that make his life easy, throwing to capable receivers, and a defense that will keep him in the game.

Originally posted by RickyRoma:
So Lance should start, but we keep Jimmy to raise his trade value.....while sitting?

I'm saying Lance could start if that's the plan...I would prefer ALL the rookies sit for a little.

My ideal scenario is the Smith/Mahomes situation.

Originally posted by JustinNiner:
Definitely think he can start week1. He played a prostyle offense and many are saying he is the smartest QB in the draft. With the talent 49ers would have around him, Lance should have the support to be successful. Starting young QBs too early usually happens when the whole team around them stinks. They end up with WRs who cant get open, lineman who cant block, and a defense that forces them to throw all game to catch up. Lance will be sitting pretty in the pocket, handing it off a great stable of RBs, running plays that make his life easy, throwing to capable receivers, and a defense that will keep him in the game.

Against talent 5x better than he's ever seen. Nah he ain't ready. He needs to sit period. The speed is way different, Jones and fields saw 3x the talent he did

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by JustinNiner:
Definitely think he can start week1. He played a prostyle offense and many are saying he is the smartest QB in the draft. With the talent 49ers would have around him, Lance should have the support to be successful. Starting young QBs too early usually happens when the whole team around them stinks. They end up with WRs who cant get open, lineman who cant block, and a defense that forces them to throw all game to catch up. Lance will be sitting pretty in the pocket, handing it off a great stable of RBs, running plays that make his life easy, throwing to capable receivers, and a defense that will keep him in the game.

Against talent 5x better than he's ever seen. Nah he ain't ready

No matter when he first starts, it'll be against talent that is better than he has ever seen.

I don't understand why the competition stuff gets brought up. Didn't Wentz play at the same damn school?

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
No matter when he first starts, it'll be against talent that is better than he has ever seen.

Yes but not even close. Did he see any nfl talent at all?

Lol it's all about the burner accounts lol

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by JustinNiner:
Definitely think he can start week1. He played a prostyle offense and many are saying he is the smartest QB in the draft. With the talent 49ers would have around him, Lance should have the support to be successful. Starting young QBs too early usually happens when the whole team around them stinks. They end up with WRs who cant get open, lineman who cant block, and a defense that forces them to throw all game to catch up. Lance will be sitting pretty in the pocket, handing it off a great stable of RBs, running plays that make his life easy, throwing to capable receivers, and a defense that will keep him in the game.

Against talent 5x better than he's ever seen. Nah he ain't ready. He needs to sit period. The speed is way different, Jones and fields saw 3x the talent he did

Sure but neither of them blocked a field goal and threw a 50 yard td pass in the same game either. Kid is a phenom

Originally posted by NYniner85:
I'm saying Lance could start if that's the plan...I would prefer ALL the rookies sit for a little.

My ideal scenario is the Smith/Mahomes situation.

And that's fair enough. I take issue with 'could' vs 'should' narratives because every situation is different. Even the example you have noted is not really rooted in science, but it's just the latest 'greatest' example that people will point to.

Originally posted by Ensatsu:
I don't understand why the competition stuff gets brought up. Didn't Wentz play at the same damn school?

First off sec vs his level is way different. He thinks he can run over everyone, and he cannot. He needs to sit back see the difference in pace, and learn he really gets hit in this league. And anyone saying he can is just guessing. Not enough tape against good talent to show he can. Actually there's no tape lol

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
No matter when he first starts, it'll be against talent that is better than he has ever seen.

Yes but not even close. Did he see any nfl talent at all?

Hmm no. But in one game he rushed for a td, tackled a guy, blocked a fg and threw a 50 yard td. He's ready

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
No matter when he first starts, it'll be against talent that is better than he has ever seen.

Yes but not even close. Did he see any nfl talent at all?

My point is whether we start him in week 1 or week 10 or in his 2nd year, it's going to be an adjustment.

Can we Trade Minshew then make Trey number 2 while Minshew or Rosen start. One of those 2 could be a long term backup.

Originally posted by 49ersRing:

Originally posted by fan49:

Originally posted by 49ersRing:
No matter when he first starts, it'll be against talent that is better than he has ever seen.

Yes but not even close. Did he see any nfl talent at all?

My point is whether we start him in week 1 or week 10 or in his 2nd year, it's going to be an adjustment.

Definitely