Justin Fields QB - Ohio State

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:

Originally posted by RishikeshA:

Originally posted by Jcool:
Guess you would of passed on Justin Herbert, Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, Russell Wilson & Lamar Jackson.

Look at my post I'm specifically speaking about Ohio State Quarterbacks and none making it in the Pros.

Before Justin Herbert, when was the last time an Oregon quarterback looked good in the NFL? I could name you 3 QBs that were top 3 picks in Marcus Mariotta, Joey Harrington, and Akili Smith that didn't do jack sh$t in the NFL before Herbert. Past history doesn't predict future success. I still remember that Aaron Rodgers fell in the draft because none of Jeff Tedford's quarterbacks succeeded at Cal before him and look where AR is at now? C'mon man give the kid a chance.

Originally posted by roasthawg:
That was the big knock on Rodgers that Tedford qbs bust in the nfl. Up until him they had. I agree, history of the program doesn't show much. Maybe not even history of the head coach.

You can even look at same program same hc with Carson palmer and Matt leinart. Similar college production, way different in the pros.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by TyCore:
quick question, is there a breakdown of JUST his bcs championship game?

i'm looking all over youtube and finding some mixed bags, but nothing dedicated to the bcs game vs bama.

i figure a lesser known youtuber probably did it, but I'm not seeing it on search results.

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:

Originally posted by roasthawg:
That was the big knock on Rodgers that Tedford qbs bust in the nfl. Up until him they had. I agree, history of the program doesn't show much. Maybe not even history of the head coach.

You can even look at same program same hc with Carson palmer and Matt leinart. Similar college production, way different in the pros.

This a career defining move for Kyle Shanahan just like it was for Nolan picking Smith over AR. One wrong move and our team is still searching for a franchise quarterback 16 years later

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:

Originally posted by roasthawg:
That was the big knock on Rodgers that Tedford qbs bust in the nfl. Up until him they had. I agree, history of the program doesn't show much. Maybe not even history of the head coach.

You can even look at same program same hc with Carson palmer and Matt leinart. Similar college production, way different in the pros.

This a career defining move for Kyle Shanahan just like it was for Nolan picking Smith over AR. One wrong move and our team is still searching for a franchise quarterback 16 years later

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:

Originally posted by roasthawg:
That was the big knock on Rodgers that Tedford qbs bust in the nfl. Up until him they had. I agree, history of the program doesn't show much. Maybe not even history of the head coach.

You can even look at same program same hc with Carson palmer and Matt leinart. Similar college production, way different in the pros.

This a career defining move for Kyle Shanahan just like it was for Nolan picking Smith over AR. One wrong move and our team is still searching for a franchise quarterback 16 years later

Keep in mind GB put Rodgers though QB School for 3 years. Completely rebuilt him. Do you think that happens in SF or do they throw him out day 1 and hope for the best?

Originally posted by roasthawg:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:

Originally posted by roasthawg:
That was the big knock on Rodgers that Tedford qbs bust in the nfl. Up until him they had. I agree, history of the program doesn't show much. Maybe not even history of the head coach.

You can even look at same program same hc with Carson palmer and Matt leinart. Similar college production, way different in the pros.

This a career defining move for Kyle Shanahan just like it was for Nolan picking Smith over AR. One wrong move and our team is still searching for a franchise quarterback 16 years later

Keep in mind GB put Rodgers though QB School for 3 years. Completely rebuilt him. Do you think that happens in SF or do they throw him out day 1 and hope for the best?

Sure looks like the plan is to sit the rookie for a year behind Jimmy. We'll see though, we should know by draft day. If they don't trade Jimmy then he's gonna play

Originally posted by RishikeshA:
Look at my post I'm specifically speaking about Ohio State Quarterbacks and none making it in the Pros.

Originally posted by RishikeshA:

Originally posted by Jcool:
Guess you would of passed on Justin Herbert, Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen, Russell Wilson & Lamar Jackson.

Look at my post I'm specifically speaking about Ohio State Quarterbacks and none making it in the Pros.

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:
I see Jones ceiling as a less mobile Ryan Tannehill. He might win you a playoff game or two but not the SB. To win the SB you need a transcendent star.

Originally posted by ImAlwaysRight:
I see Jones ceiling as a less mobile Ryan Tannehill. He might win you a playoff game or two but not the SB. To win the SB you need a transcendent star.

Originally posted by Heroism:
Transcendent.

Originally posted by Heroism:
Transcendent.