Vince Young for Alex Smith Trade Rumour!

His contract is too big, especially with Alex's new cheap deal, so we shouldn't want this to happen.

As much as I don't like Vince Young, it's amusing for me to sit back and see all of the people afraid of losing Smith, when every other time most people are talking about how awful he is. Since when did he become a coveted prize?

Back on topic though, I think Alex has more upside. Even though he's been in the NFL for a few years now, I still feel like he's young and has the potential to prove his critics wrong. I don't think it's likely, but the upside's still there. Vince's mental instability is also a pretty big concern.

Originally posted by cNiner:
mental with ability vs potinial not reached !

BACK UP SALARY vs. 2006 top 3 DRAFT PICK SALARY

do we really want to spend that much money on a cry baby that has his mom speak for him!!!

[ Edited by ocjohnknee on Jun 10, 2009 at 17:49:36 ]

Originally posted by dobophile:
I think Vince Young would be happy to play for the 49ers.

Is Vince looking at someone's cock?

What the hell is this? A worthless rumor made up on a facebook page? This is never gonna happen... you can do this debate with any made up players. "I heard Leinart might be traded for Smith." Of course this idiotic trade won't happen... VY has a whole bunch of issues outside of football.

why would the Titans do that?

well I guess I could see their supposed motivation. Alex is more idealistic as a backup I suppose

Stooooopid.

dumbest rumor!

No reason to get him, and Coach Sing already said we won't.

I would make that trade straight up in a heart beat, one is a big time college QB from a big time program with a National Championship ring as well as a rookie of the year award and a playoff season under his belt.

VY is sitting behind a Veteran QB that has been very successful in the league in Collins (SB starter, pro bowls, division titles, etc).


The other is a bust from day one, former #1 overall pick that is sitting behing J. Hill & JTO type of players. Never done anything specail in his lifetime football carreer besides hand the ball off to Reggie Bush in High School. He played in the Mountain West very own Utah, and his carreer highlight is that he beat the Seattle Seahawks in Seattle .

Just keeping it real!

Originally posted by niners_guy:
I'll pass, unless they are throwing in a 2nd rounder or something of that nature.

ummm...we the ones who would have to throw in sumthing extra im sure...

Originally posted by 9er_84:

Originally posted by niners_guy:
I'll pass, unless they are throwing in a 2nd rounder or something of that nature.

ummm...we the ones who would have to throw in sumthing extra im sure...

s**t not for a QB who isn't right on the head. The guy just isn't a good QB and gets to much credit for the wins rather than his team playing well. There is no doubt he won them some games but Alex has also done that for us. Plus he still has that contract compared to Alex Smith contract.

Vince Young > Alex Smith

But they both suck.

Originally posted by mayo63:
Young is a terrible pocket passer, I'd rather just keep Smith.