Jeff Garcia: Overrated or Underrated?

Underrated. I didn't appreciate him until the s**t storm that came after his departure.

Originally posted by verb1der:
Overrated!!!!!!!!!!!!!! First off, I hate his jump-throws, and how often he would throw it to the WRs feet..omg. Second....he's SUPER lucky he had TO (who at the time was an absolute beast!).

What happened when Garcia when to the Browns?! His wackness was validated.

you can have all the nice parts in the world but unless you have a good quarterback they do not mean jack. Yes of course he was lucky to have owens and hearst who were at the top of their games but he also made plays with his feet and mind. when Ck came along and did some things in the pocket to buy time and help make plays... i think you have to agree we had not seen that since garcia. If those sorts of things are positive when Ck does them, I do not understand why they are negative when garcia did them. I think at the time alot of quarterbacks would have failed when they went to the browns. The only complaint I ever had with jeff, is that at times he acted like he was not having fun playing for us and he let that joe and steve shadow bother him and he turned that into a negative.

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by verb1der:
Overrated!!!!!!!!!!!!!! First off, I hate his jump-throws, and how often he would throw it to the WRs feet..omg. Second....he's SUPER lucky he had TO (who at the time was an absolute beast!).

What happened when Garcia when to the Browns?! His wackness was validated.

you can have all the nice parts in the world but unless you have a good quarterback they do not mean jack. Yes of course he was lucky to have owens and hearst who were at the top of their games but he also made plays with his feet and mind. when Ck came along and did some things in the pocket to buy time and help make plays... i think you have to agree we had not seen that since garcia. If those sorts of things are positive when Ck does them, I do not understand why they are negative when garcia did them. I think at the time alot of quarterbacks would have failed when they went to the browns. The only complaint I ever had with jeff, is that at times he acted like he was not having fun playing for us and he let that joe and steve shadow bother him and he turned that into a negative.

should have drafted Tom Brady

Originally posted by blunt_probe:
Underrated. I didn't appreciate him until the s**t storm that came after his departure.

hurt his back I think in his last year which did not help matters. owens by then was a trainwreck,., we had clueless dickless hopeless erickson on board as well. sigh

post season records starting QB

Montana 16-7
Young 8-6
Garcia 2-4

I feel Jeff never got enough credit for doing a pretty good job following two hof guys. He also didn't do enough to demand greatness credit either.

It's ok to be good and not great. Thank you for your service Jeffrey

Originally posted by NineFourNiner:
I think that I speak for just about no one when I say that this place has really, really missed Mr. Taber.

It's his calling card to forever bash Garcia and love TO's nuts.

Jordan, it's 2013. Been nearly an entire decade. Get the f**k over it already.

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by blunt_probe:

Underrated. I didn't appreciate him until the s**t storm that came after his departure.

hurt his back I think in his last year which did not help matters. owens by then was a trainwreck,., we had clueless dickless hopeless erickson on board as well. sigh

And Cedrick Wilson refusing to go down.

2003 was just a year of incompetence all around.

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by verb1der:
Overrated!!!!!!!!!!!!!! First off, I hate his jump-throws, and how often he would throw it to the WRs feet..omg. Second....he's SUPER lucky he had TO (who at the time was an absolute beast!).

What happened when Garcia when to the Browns?! His wackness was validated.

you can have all the nice parts in the world but unless you have a good quarterback they do not mean jack. Yes of course he was lucky to have owens and hearst who were at the top of their games but he also made plays with his feet and mind. when Ck came along and did some things in the pocket to buy time and help make plays... i think you have to agree we had not seen that since garcia. If those sorts of things are positive when Ck does them, I do not understand why they are negative when garcia did them. I think at the time alot of quarterbacks would have failed when they went to the browns. The only complaint I ever had with jeff, is that at times he acted like he was not having fun playing for us and he let that joe and steve shadow bother him and he turned that into a negative.

Yes he did make plays with his feet, I give him that. That's why I think he's overrated, because really...that's all he did.

Originally posted by blunt_probe:
And Cedrick Wilson refusing to go down.

2003 was just a year of incompetence all around.

that was against the rams, cedrick wilson wanted to be a hero 20 yards away from the end zone lol

Very good QB. Not nearly great but very solid.

Ran very well, good mid-ranger passer and LOTS of guts.

He did well for us considering the circumstance.

At the end it was time for him to go.

Duck throwing Garcia never did sh$t before TO and never did sh$t after TO.

I think he's where he needs to be. Not under or overrated. Our 4th best ever QB.

Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:

I think he's where he needs to be. Not under or overrated. Our 4th best ever QB.

The 3rd being Brodie? Tittle? Albert?

Originally posted by English:

Originally posted by TheG0RE49er:

I think he's where he needs to be. Not under or overrated. Our 4th best ever QB.

The 3rd being Brodie? Tittle? Albert?

i'm gonna guess the 10 game wünderkid

3X Pro Bowler