Originally posted by genus49:Originally posted by GMniner805:Lol there's a reason the Patriots traded a first round pick for him and then received another first round when they decided to get rid of him. You don't trade 1st round picks for non elite receivers and the rest of what you said can be attributed to only being in that system for one season. Obviously the rams think he's an elite deeper threat WR I mean look at his average per reception last year. Imagine if they had targeted him more? Even with "the ton of plays he left on the field" still managed to go over 1000 yards Pretty damn elite to any non subjective thinker.
The point was you called out other people for not watching the games and yet clearly it shows you're just looking at his numbers.
The games showed a lot of inconsistency and his talent alone should get him big numbers and so does the offense and QB named Brady. Playing with Brees in Payton's offense and with Brady in Belichicks/Mcdaniels' offense is a pretty nice QB/system mashup for Cooks. We'll see how the Rams use him. McVay is a very smart playcaller but is Goff on the level of Brady and Brees? Certainly not at this point.
And maybe to you elite WR means someone who can put up a lot yards but that's not what it means to me. He's a very good WR but his play in those games you told us we weren't watching was not elite play.
I expect elite WRs not not drop as many passes as he dropped, to not be in the wrong spot as many times as he was. And putting up 1000 yards with Tom Brady isn't a huge accomplishment as long as you're healthy and he's getting you the ball.
Terrell Owens dropped a lot of passes, I'm guessing he wasn't elite to you either You're entitled to your opinions, clearly the professionals think he's elite. That's all that matters.
And btw I never "called out anyone for not watching games" If you reread what I actually posted all I said was if you watched the games you can tell he's a difference maker, which any expert will tell you is true. Why do you think so many people think the outcome of the super bowl might've been different had he not been knocked out with a concussion so early?? Because he's a difference maker, end of story.
[ Edited by GMniner805 on Apr 4, 2018 at 11:51 AM ]