DeForest Buckner Traded to the Colts

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by AB81Rules:

Originally posted by 9moon:
... coming from a guy who did cartwheels for 30 minutes after Baalke took the great Aweak Armhurts with the 17th overall pick instead of taking (RB) Gordon w/the 15..

don't get me wrong, Bucko is good, but he aint a SUPERSTAR... not yet at least.. but if he does ask for Donald type of money, heck I'd open the door to any team that would give us 2 first rounders..

Huh, not a superstar? The dude is perennial pro bowler if not for Donald, he's almost near Donald and he had no edge rushers, now he has 2 ELITE guys, and he(DeFo) is ELITE.

WHO does not make the PRO BOWL??

Do you still enjoy watching the Pro Bowl??

you just said it yourself, the guy is ALMOST near Donald.. if Donald is a Super Star, and Bucko ain't there yet, then how can he be a SUPER STAR/??

again, you said it for the 2nd time, he now has 2 elite guys (I'm assuming you're talking about Offside Ford and What's he done Bosa) so there should be no more excuses....

correct???

THIS COULD JUST BE THE SEASON HE BECOMES A SUPERSTAR...

Originally posted by AB81Rules:

Originally posted by 9moon:

Originally posted by AB81Rules:

Originally posted by 9moon:
... coming from a guy who did cartwheels for 30 minutes after Baalke took the great Aweak Armhurts with the 17th overall pick instead of taking (RB) Gordon w/the 15..

don't get me wrong, Bucko is good, but he aint a SUPERSTAR... not yet at least.. but if he does ask for Donald type of money, heck I'd open the door to any team that would give us 2 first rounders..

Huh, not a superstar? The dude is perennial pro bowler if not for Donald, he's almost near Donald and he had no edge rushers, now he has 2 ELITE guys, and he(DeFo) is ELITE.

WHO does not make the PRO BOWL??

Do you still enjoy watching the Pro Bowl??

you just said it yourself, the guy is ALMOST near Donald.. if Donald is a Super Star, and Bucko ain't there yet, then how can he be a SUPER STAR/??

again, you said it for the 2nd time, he now has 2 elite guys (I'm assuming you're talking about Offside Ford and What's he done Bosa) so there should be no more excuses....

correct???

THIS COULD JUST BE THE SEASON HE BECOMES A SUPERSTAR...

He doesn't need to be Aaron Donald to be ELITE, or a Star, what's next, you've already bashed Staley, now Buckner, what now, a former great, is Rice not the best WR and the GOAT in your opinion?

Originally posted by 9moon:

ok, lets make this easier for you..

Do you think Bucko is better than Donald??

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 9moon:
ok, lets make this easier for you..

Do you think Bucko is better than Donald??

WTF does that have to do with what you said about Buck? You don't have to be the best defensive player in the NFL to be a superstar.

When you're top 5 at your position, that makes you a star.

Originally posted by 9moon:

When did I say that he's NOT a star??? When when when??

All I said is the guy is GOOD, but he's NOT a SUPERSTAR ..

... and YES... if you're Top 5 at your position, that makes you a "star"... but NOT a SUPERSTAR..

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by Cisco0623:
The fact you'd put the offer out there for two firsts implies he's worth that in your mind. This guy has been the the best player on the team and the least of our worries yet you're willing to offload him because of dollar amounts? The truthful least of our concerns should be the cap. We haven't had cap trouble in ten+ years.

This...it's a joke of a comment imo.

When you're top 5 at your position (love for Moon to name 5 better DTs) that makes you a superstar. When you can get 12 sacks at the DT position and literally have Marsh and Thomas as your edge rushers, that's f**king impressive. It's not like we had lockdown corners either.

It's about has horrible as a take as him thinking I did cartwheels when we drafted AA. f**king ridiculous.

Originally posted by ninerjok:

Originally posted by 9moon:
... coming from a guy who did cartwheels for 30 minutes after Baalke took the great Aweak Armhurts with the 17th overall pick instead of taking (RB) Gordon w/the 15..

don't get me wrong, Bucko is good, but he aint a SUPERSTAR... not yet at least.. but if he does ask for Donald type of money, heck I'd open the door to any team that would give us 2 first rounders..

Buck is a superstar. Just not around the rest of the NFL yet because the team hasn't won enough for him to get superstar recognition nationally. But he is legitimately a superstar, any way you want to qualify that. He hasn't reached his ceiling yet, either.

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by 9moon:

When did I say that he's NOT a star??? When when when??

All I said is the guy is GOOD, but he's NOT a SUPERSTAR ..

... and YES... if you're Top 5 at your position, that makes you a "star"... but NOT a SUPERSTAR..

DeFo is a superstar if Donald is a superduperstar.

Originally posted by 9moon:

When did I say that he's NOT a star??? When when when??

All I said is the guy is GOOD, but he's NOT a SUPERSTAR ..

... and YES... if you're Top 5 at your position, that makes you a "star"... but NOT a SUPERSTAR..

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by 9moon:

When did I say that he's NOT a star??? When when when??

All I said is the guy is GOOD, but he's NOT a SUPERSTAR ..

... and YES... if you're Top 5 at your position, that makes you a "star"... but NOT a SUPERSTAR..

DeFo is a superstar if Donald is a superduperstar.

Originally posted by SFVNiner:

This argument star vs. superstar is the definition of "splitting hairs."

Let's just say he's bad-A$$ and call it a day .

Originally posted by SFVNiner:

This argument star vs. superstar is the definition of "splitting hairs."

Let's just say he's bad-A$$ and call it a day .

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by 9moon:

When did I say that he's NOT a star??? When when when??

All I said is the guy is GOOD, but he's NOT a SUPERSTAR ..

... and YES... if you're Top 5 at your position, that makes you a "star"... but NOT a SUPERSTAR..

DeFo is a superstar if Donald is a superduperstar.