There are 178 users in the forums

Kirk Cousins

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Throws a pretty ball in the regular season. Then folds in the playoffs. A deep run is more likely with Jimmy G than him.

Lol nope. Kirk opens up the entire field unlike Jimmy. I agree they're in the same tier (middle of the pack), but Kirk has lot more to offer and if Kyle had stuck with his guns and waited for Kirk instead of trading for Jimmy, we'd have 2 Super Bowl rings to our name.

Garbage playoff QB. Folds quickly under the big lights and big time pressure of the playoffs. Jimmy G makes deep playoff runs regularly.
  • DrEll
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 8,262
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Throws a pretty ball in the regular season. Then folds in the playoffs. A deep run is more likely with Jimmy G than him.

Lol nope. Kirk opens up the entire field unlike Jimmy. I agree they're in the same tier (middle of the pack), but Kirk has lot more to offer and if Kyle had stuck with his guns and waited for Kirk instead of trading for Jimmy, we'd have 2 Super Bowl rings to our name.

Garbage playoff QB. Folds quickly under the big lights and big time pressure of the playoffs. Jimmy G makes deep playoff runs regularly.

Please. The TEAM makes deep playoff runs despite Jimmy. The TEAM could do the same with Kirk, except Kirk has a higher upside and opens up the field more. Jimmy does everything in his power to f**k things up in the playoffs (see Vikings, Chiefs, Cowboys, Packers, Rams games post season). He's lucky that the defense and special teams bail him out and the few instances he had to be a hero, he royally botched it.
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Throws a pretty ball in the regular season. Then folds in the playoffs. A deep run is more likely with Jimmy G than him.

Lol nope. Kirk opens up the entire field unlike Jimmy. I agree they're in the same tier (middle of the pack), but Kirk has lot more to offer and if Kyle had stuck with his guns and waited for Kirk instead of trading for Jimmy, we'd have 2 Super Bowl rings to our name.

Garbage playoff QB. Folds quickly under the big lights and big time pressure of the playoffs. Jimmy G makes deep playoff runs regularly.

Please. The TEAM makes deep playoff runs despite Jimmy. The TEAM could do the same with Kirk, except Kirk has a higher upside and opens up the field more. Jimmy does everything in his power to f**k things up in the playoffs (see Vikings, Chiefs, Cowboys, Packers, Rams games post season). He's lucky that the defense and special teams bail him out and the few instances he had to be a hero, he royally botched it.

It was a botch by Lynch going for Jimmy instead of Cousins. Not a bad shot, but Kirk already was familiar with the Shanahan's playbook. Good chance we have a SB if we went that route.
Jimmy is no scrub though him getting hurt seems to be his biggest vice rather than play. Most of us forget his constant 3rd down conversions in the clutch with quick release in tight windows when he was 100% in rhythm.
[ Edited by Since07 on Nov 17, 2022 at 11:01 AM ]
Chances are if we didn't get Jimmy and went with Kirk, then we might not have Bosa. Jimmy was hurt in 2018 and if we had Kirk instead, he might have played thru that entire season. That team may have been good enough to barely make the playoffs.

If you are a fan of Bosa then you should ve glad we went with Jimmy over Kirk
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
Chances are if we didn't get Jimmy and went with Kirk, then we might not have Bosa. Jimmy was hurt in 2018 and if we had Kirk instead, he might have played thru that entire season. That team may have been good enough to barely make the playoffs.

If you are a fan of Bosa then you should ve glad we went with Jimmy over Kirk

What if jimmy didn't get hurt though never ended up with bosa anyway? Maybe Kirk leads us into a deep playoff run that same year? We don't trade a 2nd and keep the 3 1st round picks we traded for Lance?

The "if" gets complicated and messy when you go that far back its not as simple as Cousins or Bosa.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by DrEll:
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Throws a pretty ball in the regular season. Then folds in the playoffs. A deep run is more likely with Jimmy G than him.

Lol nope. Kirk opens up the entire field unlike Jimmy. I agree they're in the same tier (middle of the pack), but Kirk has lot more to offer and if Kyle had stuck with his guns and waited for Kirk instead of trading for Jimmy, we'd have 2 Super Bowl rings to our name.

Garbage playoff QB. Folds quickly under the big lights and big time pressure of the playoffs. Jimmy G makes deep playoff runs regularly.

What did I say here?
Typical Kirk CRAP_sins. Bounced in the 1st round of the playoffs. Also lost late in the year to drop from 2 to 3 seed. I have no idea what you guys see in this guy?

[ Edited by SanDiego49er on Jan 15, 2023 at 4:53 PM ]
Kirk Cousins is durable though, I've seen him take some hits this year that some of our qbs would be out for atleast a few weeks lol
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Kirk Cousins is durable though, I've seen him take some hits this year that some of our qbs would be out for atleast a few weeks lol

LOL. He throws incomplete and loses games. Especially in the playoffs.
Originally posted by SanDiego49er:
Originally posted by DRCHOWDER:
Kirk Cousins is durable though, I've seen him take some hits this year that some of our qbs would be out for atleast a few weeks lol

LOL. He throws incomplete and loses games. Especially in the playoffs.

yeah he definitely does lol, but he is durable which is my point.

=overrated
Guy just seems to not be able to get it done in prime time or playoff games
Originally posted by birdie2bogey:
Chances are if we didn't get Jimmy and went with Kirk, then we might not have Bosa. Jimmy was hurt in 2018 and if we had Kirk instead, he might have played thru that entire season. That team may have been good enough to barely make the playoffs.

If you are a fan of Bosa then you should ve glad we went with Jimmy over Kirk

But we would probably still have Buckner.
they took his chainz
Share 49ersWebzone