Solomon Thomas, DT

Originally posted by KID9R:
If we sell low on this guy, I'm officially done with Lynch. I've never been a fan of the hire. I'm worried he's going to get Kyle fired. I honestly think Kyle is the best coach we've had since Seifert.

wow, jh brought us back to being relative again. oh well. i will just stop there

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by smithgdwg:
Lynch really screwed up that draft.

Yeah Kittle and Breida really suck huh

Hitting on a 5th rounder and an undrafted free agent doesnt make up for blowing two first round picks.

I agree with post somewhere back that this is just due diligence, should we get Q. If so, sure it is a good idea to know what his value is to other teams. If we have Q, Buck, DeeFord on the DL, that makes it hard on Solly....unless they put him outside where he does not play well. So sure, find out his value. But I hope we keep him ...because we get Bosa.

I really think Cards take murray...or Q. That is where there hole is...middle of DL. Q is ideal for Az.

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by susweel:
Lolynch sure screwed the pooch in 2017. First foster is gone and now Thomas is on the outs. What a complete waste of a first. Smh damn shame even baalke wasn't that inept.

Are you even trying anymore?

what did he say wrong. lynch whiffed on two first round picks. one is not here. and one may be gone in the next 24 hours. protect lynch if you must but he said nothing wrong.

Exactly cc dudes get mad at us for pointing out the ineptness of the front office but give them a pass.

Its still amateur hour in san fran.

to me it is really inexcusable to blow two first round picks at the start of a major rebuild project.. given that drat, it will be amazing if we get to 8 wins this year. there is just no way lynch can f**k up the next 72 hours?

Originally posted by SteveWallacesHelmet:

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by smithgdwg:
Lynch really screwed up that draft.

Yeah Kittle and Breida really suck huh

Hitting on a 5th rounder and an undrafted free agent doesnt make up for blowing two first round picks.

spot on

Originally posted by PowderdToastMn:
I'm ok with them moving on if they think Williams or Bosa will be better, but it makes no sense to me that you'd draft a guy because of what he showed playing inside, not play him there, and then trade him without really trying him in the position you drafted him to play.

This. It's not like this is a QB where you only have 1 and you need to quickly upgrade or hold your whole franchise back with them as a starter. He's a sunk cost but is still the same guy we drafted at 3 (no career ending injury) and it's not worth giving up on a guy with a top 10 skillset after just 2 years of being played out of position for a 4th rd pick. We can keep him as a rotational player on the inside and give him the best chance to develop while on a moderate contract.

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by BayToBrazil:
Don't trade him. He has more value on the team. Injuries happen.

he is like ward. he is not a good player when he plays.. why would you want that on our roster

Naw he's not like Ward. Ward never flashes. At least Solly showed some flashes even if it didn't get him in the boxscore. What's the most they can get for him, a 4th? Just keep him and see if he rebounds from his personal drama filled 2018.

Originally posted by pasodoc9er:
I agree with post somewhere back that this is just due diligence, should we get Q. If so, sure it is a good idea to know what his value is to other teams. If we have Q, Buck, DeeFord on the DL, that makes it hard on Solly....unless they put him outside where he does not play well. So sure, find out his value. But I hope we keep him ...because we get Bosa.

I really think Cards take murray...or Q. That is where there hole is...middle of DL. Q is ideal for Az.

Agree, Cards would be absolutely nuts to take Bosa. At this stage I think everyone agrees that QW is on the same caliber if not better than Bosa (safer with less injury history) and unlike us the Cards have an elite end and a total void at interior DL.

I also think they are absolute idiots if they don't take Murray simply bc they may have created a schism between their front office / fans / and Rosen in the process. You don't do that to your FQB for minimal trade leverage when you're the 1st pick.

After all, you can't have that much leverage since if Murray was truly your pick you wouldn't trade it. If they do legit try to trade it then that team immediately knows you're bluffing. Silence IMO is just to maximize Rosen's value leading up to the draft.

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by KID9R:

If we sell low on this guy, I'm officially done with Lynch. I've never been a fan of the hire. I'm worried he's going to get Kyle fired. I honestly think Kyle is the best coach we've had since Seifert.

wow, jh brought us back to being relative again. oh well. i will just stop there

Ya he's a good coach but I think JH was better suited to be a college coach, that Rah Rah crap kind of gets old with the players. He's also pretty weird and has an abrasive personality. So I don't think he was ever going to be around for very long. Kyle IMO has a much higher ceiling. JH had a stacked roster while Lynch has busted on 2/3 of his first rounders and will more then likely go into the season with Pettis as our best WR.

Originally posted by Jcool:

Originally posted by susweel:
Lolynch sure screwed the pooch in 2017. First foster is gone and now Thomas is on the outs. What a complete waste of a first. Smh damn shame even baalke wasn't that inept.

Are you even trying anymore?

Can't be. Been spewing negativity about the picks for months and then if this rumor is true, the team is moving on from a mistake, spouts the same negativity that has been said for months.

Originally posted by thl408:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by BayToBrazil:
Don't trade him. He has more value on the team. Injuries happen.

he is like ward. he is not a good player when he plays.. why would you want that on our roster

Naw he's not like Ward. Ward never flashes. At least Solly showed some flashes even if it didn't get him in the boxscore. What's the most they can get for him, a 4th? Just keep him and see if he rebounds from his personal drama filled 2018.

I'd agree, more so in the sense that we KNOW Ward is not a good player. Solomon Thomas might not be a good one. He's going to get more time at DT than he did in previous seasons so we will know beyond that shadow of a doubt. I don't believe the rumor, but if it is true, my guess is that the new D-line coach gave Thomas a thumbs down after looking at all the film.

Originally posted by KID9R:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by KID9R:

If we sell low on this guy, I'm officially done with Lynch. I've never been a fan of the hire. I'm worried he's going to get Kyle fired. I honestly think Kyle is the best coach we've had since Seifert.

wow, jh brought us back to being relative again. oh well. i will just stop there

Ya he's a good coach but I think JH was better suited to be a college coach, that Rah Rah crap kind of gets old with the players. He's also pretty weird and has an abrasive personality. So I don't think he was ever going to be around for very long. Kyle IMO has a much higher ceiling. JH had a stacked roster while Lynch has busted on 2/3 of his first rounders and will more then likely go into the season with Pettis as our best WR.

How can anyone say kyle is a good coach he's won 10 games in two years. It seems he's better off being an oc.

Originally posted by susweel:

How can anyone say kyle is a good coach he's won 10 games in two years. It seems he's better off being an oc.

Yeah let's not have any context here.

Originally posted by Waterbear:

Originally posted by Dman11:
He played phenomenally well at DT next to Buckner down the stretch last year. Quinnen is great, but we've played solly out of position for almost his whole career. Kick him inside and we have a potential pro bowler on our hands. If anybody disagrees, watch him against the bears and their talented guards struggling to handle him inside.

If he played phenomenally how well did Buckner play last year? phenomenally x infinity + 2?

By that definition, Reggie McGrew was one of the greatest depth DTs in NFL history.

Originally posted by susweel:

Originally posted by KID9R:

Originally posted by cciowa:

Originally posted by KID9R:

If we sell low on this guy, I'm officially done with Lynch. I've never been a fan of the hire. I'm worried he's going to get Kyle fired. I honestly think Kyle is the best coach we've had since Seifert.

wow, jh brought us back to being relative again. oh well. i will just stop there

Ya he's a good coach but I think JH was better suited to be a college coach, that Rah Rah crap kind of gets old with the players. He's also pretty weird and has an abrasive personality. So I don't think he was ever going to be around for very long. Kyle IMO has a much higher ceiling. JH had a stacked roster while Lynch has busted on 2/3 of his first rounders and will more then likely go into the season with Pettis as our best WR.

How can anyone say kyle is a good coach he's won 10 games in two years. It seems he's better off being an oc.

Because the roster he was given was garbage. But even with that garbage he's put functional offences on the field. I would much rather have a excellent OC learn to be good HC. We struggled for years cycling through OC's every year and players having to learn a new system every year. Kyle's biggest mistake imo was letting Lynch talk him into changing the defence after Kyle couldn't get Fangio from the bears and hiring Salah.

And Hall of fame coaches never start their first two years with less then 10 wins. Walsh, Noll, Levy, Jimmy Johnson.