LISTEN: The 49ers Get Snowplowed In Buffalo →

There are 318 users in the forums

Solomon Thomas, DT

Shop 49ers game tickets
Originally posted by T-9ers:
Originally posted by ArmchairQB:
I am not upset at Lynch for Solomon or for Foster.

The Solomon pick was, at the time, labeled the safest pick in the draft. High motor, high character, smart kid. Almost all the mock drafts had him going to us including ESPN. Don't be history revisionists. It was deemed a smart, widely accepted pick at the time.

The Foster pick was unanimously labeled the steal of the draft and early on we thought it too. He had Pro Bowl written all over him.

Sometimes picks don't work out. Sometimes people flake out. That's the name of the game. Do I wish they would both have turned into All-Stars for us? YES!

Am I mad at Lynch because they didn't? No. Neither was a reach or considered, at the time, a bust.

Now moving forward...DO BETTER LYNCH! Let's go!

Nonsense. Their job is to get it right and not pick the Solomon Thomas and Fosters of the draft. You're the one revising history, I'm saying they got it wrong and I expect results and accountability.

Just out of curiosity what did you think of the picks when they were selected?
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.
NO TO BO!!!
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.

This is pretty much revisionist history. Adams was in the mix, but the majority of mocks had Thomas going to us.
Originally posted by 9moon:
NO TO BO!!!

Stop.
Originally posted by AB81Rules:
And how many 1st rd picks and draft picks overall did the last regime blow? Pretty much all of them except Buckner are gone. So he missed on Thomas and Foster, he has hit more than he has missed so far.

Wait what? We have had 3 first round picks since Lynch got here. How can you say that he hit on more than he missed so far when he blew his first 2 of the 3?
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.

This is pretty much revisionist history. Adams was in the mix, but the majority of mocks had Thomas going to us.

You said it wasn't a mistake picking him? I guess passing on Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers weren't mistakes either?
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.

This is pretty much revisionist history. Adams was in the mix, but the majority of mocks had Thomas going to us.

You said it wasn't a mistake picking him? I guess passing on Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers weren't mistakes either?

Tom Brady went into the 6th round and was passed by everybody multiple times.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.

This is pretty much revisionist history. Adams was in the mix, but the majority of mocks had Thomas going to us.

You said it wasn't a mistake picking him? I guess passing on Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers weren't mistakes either?

At the time it wasn't, now it is.
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.

This is pretty much revisionist history. Adams was in the mix, but the majority of mocks had Thomas going to us.

You said it wasn't a mistake picking him? I guess passing on Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers weren't mistakes either?

Tom Brady went into the 6th round and was passed by everybody multiple times.

I'm just saying it clearly was a mistake picking Thomas. It wasn't seen a huge reach if that is what you mean.
Trading ST at this stage for anything less than a 2nd is just as big of a mistake as drafting him at 3 in the first place. How do you give up so soon a player you took 3rd overall after playing him out of position (the position every analyst and his own college coach said was his natural position) his entire NFL career. I will lose all faith and respect for John Lynch and honestly can't fathom how he can escape being fired after f**king up that badly in that draft with Thomas and Foster.
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by VaBeachNiner:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Originally posted by Waterbear:
Originally posted by KittleSkittle:
Lots of people had Thomas highly rated going into the draft. The mistake wasn't picking him, it was trying to play him out of position.

Wrong. He wasn't even close to BPA with Adams on the board.

This is pretty much revisionist history. Adams was in the mix, but the majority of mocks had Thomas going to us.

You said it wasn't a mistake picking him? I guess passing on Tom Brady and Aaron Rodgers weren't mistakes either?

Tom Brady went into the 6th round and was passed by everybody multiple times.

I'm just saying it clearly was a mistake picking Thomas. It wasn't seen a huge reach if that is what you mean.

This is an argument of perception of the question. You guys are arguing two different things.

Yes, the selection of Solomon Thomas could be considered a mistake in light of how his NFL career has gone to date.

No selecting him wasn't a mistake because based on all information he was not only the best player according to the 49ers ratings, but just about everyone else's as well.

Both statements are true at the same time based on perception
Originally posted by WINiner:
This is an argument of perception of the question. You guys are arguing two different things.

Yes, the selection of Solomon Thomas could be considered a mistake in light of how his NFL career has gone to date.

No selecting him wasn't a mistake because based on all information he was not only the best player according to the 49ers ratings, but just about everyone else's as well.

Both statements are true at the same time based on perception

This is why you simply don't give up on him after 2 seasons. Especially given he was played out of position on crap losing teams and nothing has changed health/character to make his eval change. I'd fire the entire defensive coaching staff (notably Saleh) over give up on ST at this stage, way more replaceable than the 3rd overall pick.
  • VDSF
  • Veteran
  • Posts: 5,971
Originally posted by Geeked:
I say the most the 49ers get for Thomas is a late 2nd and possibly a mid level player in a contract year.

AJ Green
Share 49ersWebzone