Jimmy Garoppolo, QB, Los Angeles Rams

Originally posted by 9moon:

it isn't a surprised to me if they tried to sign him again 3 years ago.. no one knew then how good Brady will still be..

This is not a shot to you bro, but look what the 49ers did w/Montana... had Steve Young the one that got traded to KC, and we end up with Derek Thomas, no doubt in my mind that we would have beaten Dallas in 91 and 92... and the two GB defeats would have never happened if Joe was our QB.

Bill realized now that Brady can still be around for at least 2 more year, (2018 & 2019) and like I said before, why not collect picks and keep on collecting players that would help him and Brady win a couple of more SUPER BOWLS.. ..

Yeah I think the trade works for both sides...I just don't want people to misconstrue the fact that Bill most certainly didn't want to get rid of jimmy g, but really had no choice.

Originally posted by jays9ers:
Am I the only one skeptical of this trade? I'm excited but just don't know if Jimmy G is 'The Man'. If he is, then we're in a better position this off season. We're staring at the first or second pick in the draft. If we can trade back and get a boat load of picks then we could really do some damage.

Any trade is gonna have questions. There was no guarantee when the Packers traded for Brett Favre back in the day. We'll just have to wait and see how it works out. In reality, I don't expect amazing things from Garoppolo this season. Now, next year, after he's had a chance to absorb the playbook and be around K.S. for an offseason he should produce. Honestly, I don't even want the guy to start until after the bye week. Give him a chance to learn some of the playbook and let the OL heal. Don't want him getting killed.

Just my opinion.

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by socalniner:
Worst case, we blow a 2nd round pick. Glad it wasnt a 1st

We've blown a 2nd rounder before (lamichael james )

Baalke has blown picks in every round! That's why this team is in the position its in.

Originally posted by Phoenix49ers:

Originally posted by NinerGM:

This trade has skepticism built into it. If they were 100% sure, NE could have asked for their 1st given what it was rumored the Browns offered last year.

I dont buy that a 1st rounder was ever on the table for New England and certainly not in October. It came down to them taking the best offer available or watching Garoppolo walk at season's end.

That was just what NE started with. Adam S. said it was a 2nd and 3rd and change. We hit him for just a 2nd.

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by slowriot:
Andrew Siciliano‏Verified account
If you connect trade dots on 4 SF deals, you'll find 49ers got Reuben Foster and Jimmy Garoppolo simply for moving down 1 spot last April.

Did we trade the 2nd round pick we got from the Saints?

No it's our own pick. Which imo is a steal

Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 9moon:
it isn't a surprised to me if they tried to sign him again 3 years ago.. no one knew then how good Brady will still be..

This is not a shot to you bro, but look what the 49ers did w/Montana... had Steve Young the one that got traded to KC, and we end up with Derek Thomas, no doubt in my mind that we would have beaten Dallas in 91 and 92... and the two GB defeats would have never happened if Joe was our QB.

Bill realized now that Brady can still be around for at least 2 more year, (2018 & 2019) and like I said before, why not collect picks and keep on collecting players that would help him and Brady win a couple of more SUPER BOWLS.. ..

Yeah I think the trade works for both sides...I just don't want people to misconstrue the fact that Bill most certainly didn't want to get rid of jimmy g, but really had no choice.

He as much as said that.

Traded him across the nation and in NFC. Basically wish you best and we shouldnt cross paths often unless its the end game buddy lol Now we really gotta get a few interior lineman for next season!

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by socalniner:

Worst case, we blow a 2nd round pick. Glad it wasnt a 1st

We've blown a 2nd rounder before (lamichael james )

We'be blown PLENTY of 2nds. This is the best value we've gotten for a 2nd in a really really long time

Originally posted by glorydayz:
Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

joking ?

I wish Jimmy Garoppolo & CJ Beathard the best of luck. Best case is that 1 pans out as the immediate future & the other is the project that will grow given time.

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Originally posted by slowriot:

Andrew Siciliano‏Verified account
If you connect trade dots on 4 SF deals, you'll find 49ers got Reuben Foster and Jimmy Garoppolo simply for moving down 1 spot last April.

Did we trade the 2nd round pick we got from the Saints?

No it's our own pick. Which imo is a steal

Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

Clearly sarcasm, right?

Originally posted by 49AllTheTime:

Originally posted by glorydayz:
Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

joking ?

No, this isn't a joke!

I have really grown a thirst for picking D-linemen every year and don't want that to change at all. In fact I want to start using 1st & 2nd rounders on D-linemen every year no matter what! Preferably more interior D-linemen, but even taller!!!

Originally posted by NYniner85:

Originally posted by 9moon:

it isn't a surprised to me if they tried to sign him again 3 years ago.. no one knew then how good Brady will still be..

This is not a shot to you bro, but look what the 49ers did w/Montana... had Steve Young the one that got traded to KC, and we end up with Derek Thomas, no doubt in my mind that we would have beaten Dallas in 91 and 92... and the two GB defeats would have never happened if Joe was our QB.

Bill realized now that Brady can still be around for at least 2 more year, (2018 & 2019) and like I said before, why not collect picks and keep on collecting players that would help him and Brady win a couple of more SUPER BOWLS.. ..

Yeah I think the trade works for both sides...I just don't want people to misconstrue the fact that Bill most certainly didn't want to get rid of jimmy g, but really had no choice.

Except the Pats now have to waste a draft pick again (10th time) on a QB in a class that has no Derek Carr or Jimmy Garoppolo in it, most likely, and invest two years of developing him while hoping Brady stays healthy and/or doesn't retire.

We win.

Originally posted by Antix:

Originally posted by DonnieDarko:

Originally posted by socalniner:
Worst case, we blow a 2nd round pick. Glad it wasnt a 1st

We've blown a 2nd rounder before (lamichael james )

We'be blown PLENTY of 2nds. This is the best value we've gotten for a 2nd in a really really long time

Yeah, I agree - best 2nd round selection in a long time.

Originally posted by glorydayz:

Our pick will be 1st or 2nd overall, the Saints have been winning so how is that a steal?

If Jimmy G sucks we gave up a high second rounder, which could have been another D-linemen!!!!

This Sucks!!!!

If Garoppolo indeed becomes a franchise QB, it would be a huge freaking steal!

John Lynch & Shanahan could invent time travel and sign the entire 1989 49ers roster and there would still be clowns on here that would complain about it