Originally posted by Giedi:
Originally posted by genus49:
Colin also didn't show that he could be thrown into a very complicated offense, face good defenses and make chicken salad out of chicken chit.
Jim Plunkett was a late developer. There are QB's that just take a while to develop. Steve Young also took some time to develop. I'm not going to re-argue the past, but again in the right offense Colin was a top QB. If you have speed on offense - the QB reads become very simple and it's just a matter of having the physical talent to get the ball to the reciever at that point.
Having said that, I don't particularly care for Colin's attidude about himself (his tatoo - my talent is my curse) and his politics. Take any QB and keep changing his OC and the schemes he plays and he'll not be a very good QB for very long. That's why I think it was a very important step to have Kyle be the OC *AND* the HC to just make sure there is consistency at that coaching position. Jimmy will benefit greatly from that and will astound the NFL this year because Kyle's build a very fast offense around him that makes his reads very simple (and he already is an elite speed reader of defenses prior to being with Kyle).
I'm sorry but with all respect to Kap he never showed some of the things elite QBs need to do as passers with or without Harbaugh, with or without great teams around him. Jimmy has shown more in his 5 starts with mediocre/crap talent around him last year than Kap did in his whole career.
I thought Kap would keep getting better and better. What he did his first year starting was incredible but you could tell there was a ton of potential to improve, a little more touch on some passes here, better pocket presence here, less happy feet on a few plays there and taking some easier plays based on what the defense gives you...
He never really improved on those things and as the teams fell apart whether free agency, injuries or retirements the growth as a passer wasn't showing. The fact that Colin adopted Harbaugh's world is against me attitude didn't help because he felt he was good enough and didn't need to listen to all these other people who said he should work on the mental part of his game more and work on becoming a better pocket passer.
That's why I'm much more encouraged by the 5 games from Jimmy. He did stay in there under pressure to deliver accurate balls, he did take what the defense was giving him often even though he had moments where he would just go based on the playcall regardless, i'd expect more of the former once he actually knows the full offense. He showed glimpses of elite play. That certainly bodes well as the team improves(hopefully) around him and as he becomes much more comfortable in Kyle's offense.
I know i've had people tell me to pump my brakes on Jimmy because of what happened with Kap but IMO it's apples n oranges.