There are 691 users in the forums
Originally posted by random49er:Also cant blame him for the concussions that ended his career early,...or being stuck behind another All-Time great QB. So given the limited years and patchwork Oline, Young was phenomenal.
Originally posted by Ezekiel38:You are the one who only brought up his yards passing and TDs with no mention of his costly INTs and turnovers. It does help greatly to witness something. I can look at stats from the 60s and 70s but that is not going to tell the whole story esp if LIKE YOU I IGNORED INTS and only stated passing yards and TDs. Go back and watch those games. Young fu**ed up and made costly errors time and time again that Favre and Aikman were not making and that is why they won and not the 49ers. He doesn't make those mistakes and we are winning one or two more Super Bowls in the 90s with him. I was spoiled by the GOAT Montana and freely admit it. I held Young to a high standard of coming through in the biggest postseason games and winning at least a couple SBs. I don't dismiss his whole career. He was a hall of famer. He got one Super Bowl.
And he also disappointed in most of the biggest moments in his career in the postseason. One more Super Bowl and my perception of him is a lot different.
"To dismiss his career because he didn't win the SB in every opportunity is ridiculous."
This is absurd. "Every" opportunity...did I say that? He had 7 or 8 opportunities and came through only once. His costly mistakes directly led to those losses against GB and Dallas. I would have liked to see him win at least one more SB. But that's why he is not a top 5 QB of all time and more like in the top 15 or maybe back end of the top 10. Either way, regular season greatness and MVPs mean sh** to me. I want a QB who comes up back in the postseason CONSISTENTLY and wins the biggest of games. And Young did not. Historically speaking still a great QB but this is due to achievements unrelated to the postseason outside of one year and generally speaking, underwhelmed when it mattered most.
I hope Jimmy G is not the postseason Steve Young or we are only going to get one SB from him as well. If Jimmy has some Joe Montana in him, he will win at least a couple. My perception for now is that Jimmy has the clutch gene and we will see if he can win these games in the postseason when all is on the line.
Originally posted by Niners99:Also i would not ssy he had 7 or 8 chances. I would say he had 2 maybe 3. Derek loville and terry kirby threatened no one. 92-93-94. He lost to a stacked team(dallas) in 92 and 93. Won in 94, then the FO let ricky walk, deion went to dallas
You're a great example of why people dont like Niner fans. The arrogance of saying "one Super Bowl is not enough". What do you do for a living? Hopefully you've maintained the standard of being the best in the world for an extended period of time with an attitude like that.
I would be BEYOND thrilled if Garoppolo ONLY got us one SB. You sound completely ridiculous and out of touch.
Originally posted by NewEraNiner16:
It's a good year when people are arguing about how well or not well Young played in a Jimmy G thread as we kill time waiting for the next 49er game after the bye week...
Cheers
Originally posted by Niners99:Originally posted by Ezekiel38:You are the one who only brought up his yards passing and TDs with no mention of his costly INTs and turnovers. It does help greatly to witness something. I can look at stats from the 60s and 70s but that is not going to tell the whole story esp if LIKE YOU I IGNORED INTS and only stated passing yards and TDs. Go back and watch those games. Young fu**ed up and made costly errors time and time again that Favre and Aikman were not making and that is why they won and not the 49ers. He doesn't make those mistakes and we are winning one or two more Super Bowls in the 90s with him. I was spoiled by the GOAT Montana and freely admit it. I held Young to a high standard of coming through in the biggest postseason games and winning at least a couple SBs. I don't dismiss his whole career. He was a hall of famer. He got one Super Bowl.
And he also disappointed in most of the biggest moments in his career in the postseason. One more Super Bowl and my perception of him is a lot different.
"To dismiss his career because he didn't win the SB in every opportunity is ridiculous."
This is absurd. "Every" opportunity...did I say that? He had 7 or 8 opportunities and came through only once. His costly mistakes directly led to those losses against GB and Dallas. I would have liked to see him win at least one more SB. But that's why he is not a top 5 QB of all time and more like in the top 15 or maybe back end of the top 10. Either way, regular season greatness and MVPs mean sh** to me. I want a QB who comes up back in the postseason CONSISTENTLY and wins the biggest of games. And Young did not. Historically speaking still a great QB but this is due to achievements unrelated to the postseason outside of one year and generally speaking, underwhelmed when it mattered most.
I hope Jimmy G is not the postseason Steve Young or we are only going to get one SB from him as well. If Jimmy has some Joe Montana in him, he will win at least a couple. My perception for now is that Jimmy has the clutch gene and we will see if he can win these games in the postseason when all is on the line.
You're a great example of why people dont like Niner fans. The arrogance of saying "one Super Bowl is not enough". What do you do for a living? Hopefully you've maintained the standard of being the best in the world for an extended period of time with an attitude like that.
I would be BEYOND thrilled if Garoppolo ONLY got us one SB. You sound completely ridiculous and out of touch.
I'd rather not Mullens come in at all tbh. If he's in that would have to mean something happened to Jimmy G. None of us want that (knock on wood), and especially right now in the postseason where the games mean everything. We need to have Jimmy behind center and slinging the rock.Originally posted by jdt84_2:Originally posted by NewEraNiner16:It's a good year when people are arguing about how well or not well Young played in a Jimmy G thread as we kill time waiting for the next 49er game after the bye week...
Cheers
Yep. It is really nice having a QB you trust and believe c as n mske a play. AAlso i have trust the backup can come in for a series or 2 and do well.
Originally posted by Bellaleo:
Originally posted by golfish:If it wasn't for Joe Cool there would be no TB12
Exactly, nothing against Brady but it's two different games.
Originally posted by NinerBuff:
Jimmy's regular season record is outstanding, but the slate is wiped clean for the playoffs.
Previous 49er QB Playoff Record
Kaepernick: 4-2
Smith: 1-1
Garcia: 1-2
Young: 8-6
Montana: 16-7
Time for Jimmy to start catching up
